Simple Mafia 3

[charlou]

Or Ghat is being really clever trying to protect his ass.

How so?

I'll read the threads again, I think ...

[higgs2]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

So Ani... Is insane or lying?

Huh? Or telling the truth.

[Animavore]

Or Ghat is being really clever trying to protect his ass.

How so?

I'll read the threads again, I think ...

By being really clever in saying "Go ahead and vote me and then lynch Ani when it turns out I'm innocent". It could be a huge bluff.

[Zigmen]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

So Ani... Is insane or lying?

Ani just didn't know that Vigs view as town.

Also, lack of understanding does not mean its a scum tell.

I would doubt that this game would have an insane (paranoid) seer. I also doubt that Ani is lying. We will know by the end of the day if Ani was lying, and we will deal with him then. Right now, we need to assume he's the seer and that Ghan is scum. Short of a counterclaim by another seer, we have no reason to doubt him.

[higgs2]

A "miller"? What's that?

It's basically a horrible role in which you are town, you win with town, but you view as scum.

[Animavore]

A "miller"? What's that?

It's basically a horrible role in which you are town, you win with town, but you view as scum.

Never heard of it.

[higgs2]

Or Ghat is being really clever trying to protect his ass.

How so?

I'll read the threads again, I think ...

By being really clever in saying "Go ahead and vote me and then lynch Ani when it turns out I'm innocent". It could be a huge bluff.

They would be gambling that we don't have a seer who could counterclaim.

[charlou]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

So Ani... Is insane or lying?

Ani just didn't know that Vigs view as town.

Also, lack of understanding does not mean its a scum tell.

I would doubt that this game would have an insane (paranoid) seer. I also doubt that Ani is lying. We will know by the end of the day if Ani was lying, and we will deal with him then. Right now, we need to assume he's the seer and that Ghan is scum. Short of a counterclaim by another seer, we have no reason to doubt him.

Okay, benefit of the doubt for now, but interested in anything others have to add ... unvote

[Zigmen]

By being really clever in saying "Go ahead and vote me and then lynch Ani when it turns out I'm innocent". It could be a huge bluff.

It won't make much difference. Ghan needs to die no matter what. Either he's scum and needs to die, or Ani is lying and Ghan needs to die to prove it.

[higgs2]

Why did ani out so early? Day 2?

[Azathoth]

By being really clever in saying "Go ahead and vote me and then lynch Ani when it turns out I'm innocent". It could be a huge bluff.

It won't make much difference. Ghan needs to die no matter what. Either he's scum and needs to die, or Ani is lying and Ghan needs to die to prove it.

[Animavore]

Why did ani out so early? Day 2?

Because 1 scum is dead. I have a guilty view on another. There can only be 3 at most. Could be 4 but I doubt it. It made sense to come forth with the information now instead of risking dying with the information.

[higgs2]

Okey dokey. Next time, end of the day might allow more scum sniffing.
vote ghat

[Zigmen]

Why did ani out so early? Day 2?

Because 1 scum is dead. I have a guilty view on another. There can only be 3 at most. Could be 4 but I doubt it. It made sense to come forth with the information now instead of risking dying with the information.

There's another option you can use in the future. If you did die, we would all read back your previous posts. You could have hidden your views as FoSes like: "I get the sense that Ghat is scummy."

After a seer dies, that is taken as a view and acted on immediately. It's also transparaent enough that the scum team may not pick up on the fact you are a seer.

[higgs2]

Gotta go. If ghat and ani both turn up town I'd look at charlou and zigmen.