Stargate SG1 - game thread

[irretating]

Bili, fair enough you weren't around yesterday, but I look forward to seeing an analysis from you that is a bit broader than shizz.

Shizz, who are your suspects?

[irretating]

Zig, who would you triangulate with today?

[praying]

Praying, did you read d1 yet?

I did, I read it this morning.

[Azathoth]

Aza, how come the lack of scum hunting yesterday? How could btern not ping for you?

Just a lazy day 1. I had already gone to bed when b.tern really started looking like scummy mcscummerson. I'm GMT +0

[praying]

I did not have BT pegged for scum and would not have voted her had I been coheerent enough on day 1 that said, Mattshizzle's play was not Matt's usual. In all the games I have played with him to my recollection he has never asked questions like this:

by MattShizzle » Fri Aug 12, 2011 11:00 am
I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

So he is in my scummy pile.

[divagreen]

Diva, your thoughts on the shizz BW yesterday?

I thought b. ternius looked followy of Aza.

First with this post:

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 70#p944070

Then she followed his vote.

I am feeling better about Aza because I do not think that b.ternarius would openly follow a scummate like that.

[irretating]

Aza, how come the lack of scum hunting yesterday? How could btern not ping for you?

Just a lazy day 1. I had already gone to bed when b.tern really started looking like scummy mcscummerson. I'm GMT +0

Who are your suspects now? Have you seen shizz's scum game? I haven't, and I'm finding him too convenient a target. Easy for scum to hide in, or create noise about him (exactly like btern did).

Those voting Aza: do you think as scum he'd plop an easy vote on shizz? And if you do, does that mean shizz is clear town?

[irretating]

I did not have BT pegged for scum and would not have voted her had I been coheerent enough on day 1 that said, Mattshizzle's play was not Matt's usual. In all the games I have played with him to my recollection he has never asked questions like this:

by MattShizzle » Fri Aug 12, 2011 11:00 am
I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

So he is in my scummy pile.

Anyone else stand out? Who could pick nightson's special game?

[MattShizzle]

Bili, fair enough you weren't around yesterday, but I look forward to seeing an analysis from you that is a bit broader than shizz.

Shizz, who are your suspects?

Only aza for now.

[irretating]

Oh...gonzo, nearly forgot about you. Your vote on me yesterday struck me as either lazy or scummy. Your thoughts on diva today? And on bili?

[Zigmen]

I didn't have time to elaborate before.

1) Look at Aza yesterday. Try to picture those posts as Scum play or Town play. Looks like Scum to me.

2) Yesterday, Amok hung around the thread for at least an hour, popping in and out, but not posting beyond her first post. I decided to pressure her with a vote. After she posted, I sensed a Towny vibe, so I pulled my vote.

3) Irre looks far better today than yesterday.

4) I did notice that B.Tern's vote on Shizz looked odd, so I asked who they were at TR, but found out a bit late to make a difference. Yes, Town Borealis would not have read Shizz's posts as Scummy. Good BW there, though I missed it.

[irretating]

I didn't have time to elaborate before.

1) Look at Aza yesterday. Try to picture those posts as Scum play or Town play. Looks like Scum to me.

2) Yesterday, Amok hung around the thread for at least an hour, popping in and out, but not posting beyond her first post. I decided to pressure her with a vote. After she posted, I sensed a Towny vibe, so I pulled my vote.

3) Irre looks far better today than yesterday.

4) I did notice that B.Tern's vote on Shizz looked odd, so I asked who they were at TR, but found out a bit late to make a difference. Yes, Town Borealis would not have read Shizz's posts as Scummy. Good BW there, though I missed it.

I don't think it looks like an Aza scum game.

And, hmmph, I'm looking more than 'better,' :snooty:

You got any vibes on feck? I'm unsure about him, but want him to be town. Also, thoughts on the diva-gonzo show yesterday?

[Zigmen]

My case on Aza todya is based on looking at this post in retrospect:

Aza (discussing "random" votes):

Ones with any sort of reasoning behind them. Coming straight out and slapping a random vote on someone before any discussion at all is bullshit.

Aza seemingly has never heard of a pressure vote?

It doesn't fit.

Then, look at this:

[2] irretating votes for btern
[0] feck votes for amok
[1] azathoth votes for shizz
[0] ksen votes for zig
[1] gonzo votes for irre
[3] mattshizzle votes for aza
[1] zigmen votes for DP
[3] b.ternarius votes for shizz
[0] higgs2 votes for irre
[0] mantisdreamz votes for btern
[0] r.c votes for
[0] praying votes for
[0] bilirubin votes for
[0] fuzzy fungi votes for shizz
[0] athene votes for
[1] amok votes for DP
[0] nightson votes for btern
[0] diva votes for gonzo
[2] DP votes for

Aza kept her vote on Shizz, as if awaiting the cavalry and not wanting to look like a vote-switcher.

Yesterday's vote was very close. B.Tern was on Shizz. Fuzzy was on Shizz. Aza was on Shizz.

I doubt 3 Scum would be on that BW, but Scum also knew B.Tern would flip as Scum, right?

So, I am concerned with odd votes on the other big BW that had odd reasoning, and Aza fits that mold.

Xpost Irre

[Zigmen]

I don't think it looks like an Aza scum game.

And, hmmph, I'm looking more than 'better,' :snooty:

You got any vibes on feck? I'm unsure about him, but want him to be town. Also, thoughts on the diva-gonzo show yesterday?

I will listen to you if you can explain to me why Aza looks Towny. I see 2 major scumtells atm.

And you're looking better, but not cleared.

I have Feck as neutral, and if I had to pick a side in the Diva-Gonzo show, I'd say Gonzo looks bad and Diva has emitted a strong Town tell.

[Azathoth]

,

Who are your suspects now? Have you seen shizz's scum game? I haven't, and I'm finding him too convenient a target. Easy for scum to hide in, or create noise about him (exactly like btern did).

shizz gets bussed ASAP as TR scum.

Aza seemingly has never heard of a pressure vote?

It doesn't fit.

Then, look at this:

[2] irretating votes for btern
[0] feck votes for amok
[1] azathoth votes for shizz
[0] ksen votes for zig
[1] gonzo votes for irre
[3] mattshizzle votes for aza
[1] zigmen votes for DP
[3] b.ternarius votes for shizz
[0] higgs2 votes for irre
[0] mantisdreamz votes for btern
[0] r.c votes for
[0] praying votes for
[0] bilirubin votes for
[0] fuzzy fungi votes for shizz
[0] athene votes for
[1] amok votes for DP
[0] nightson votes for btern
[0] diva votes for gonzo
[2] DP votes for

Aza kept her vote on Shizz, as if awaiting the cavalry and not wanting to look like a vote-switcher.

Yesterday's vote was very close. B.Tern was on Shizz. Fuzzy was on Shizz. Aza was on Shizz.

I doubt 3 Scum would be on that BW, but Scum also knew B.Tern would flip as Scum, right?

So, I am concerned with odd votes on the other big BW that had odd reasoning, and Aza fits that mold.

Xpost Irre

As I said yesterday pressure votes come later. A pile of unexplained votes out of the gate is bullshit. It is just voting for the sake of it. I slapped a vote on shizzle before I went to bed. It was somewhere between 2 and 3 AM and he was the weakest player who wasn't looking towny. Now I think he looks positively scummy after playing on his tr early lynch meme.

##vote shizzle##