Hitman: Blood Money Mafia - A Dance With The Devil

Post by **oblivion** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 3:30 am

amok wrote:Why did you vote for Charou, Oblivion?

she seemed kinda wishy-washy last night (my time). she made a lot of posts for day 1 compared to her usual game, but didn't give the impression of scumhunting. putting a vote on mattshizzle and then retiring for the remainder of the game day pinged, too.

And, I put some stock in other players that I think are town also finding her posting pretty iffy.

Post by **Zigmen** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 4:44 am

We just got power back on after a big storm. I'll catch up tomorrow.

Post by **oblivion** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 4:50 am

amok wrote:Why did you vote for Charou, Oblivion?

I'd like to ask the reverse. why did you vote for Irre?

Post by **oblivion** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 5:24 am

reporting that ksen read my PM about this game starting about 20 minutes ago, in case I'm dead tomorrow and he doesn't make an appearance.

Post by **amok** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 5:35 am

oblivion wrote:
amok wrote:Why did you vote for Charou, Oblivion?
I'd like to ask the reverse. why did you vote for Irre?

I decided to do what Gib suggested and re-read the first 2-3 pages of the thread. I have been following it (as much as I can, at work), but that first suggestion about mass role-revealing just doesn't sit right with me. And yes, I know there was a lot to follow, but how in heaven's name can that ever be a good idea? It creeped me out, to be frank.

Post by **Magicziggy** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 5:37 am

I'm going to have to read this all again. My half read this morning was just out of interest. Then I'm in the game and I skimmed the rest.
I just looked at the OP and 13 people are invited out of 17 players. So 4 scum. But only three targets. So an SK . Sound right?

Irre mentions mass claim. I need to check her reasoning for that. Doesn't sound like a good idea.

Dp looks solid (

)
Charlou looks dead. Need to see how that bw formed.

The rest I shall have to re-read. I guess I have a few hours.

xpost Amok

Post by **irretating** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 5:39 am

amok wrote:
oblivion wrote:
amok wrote:Why did you vote for Charou, Oblivion?
I'd like to ask the reverse. why did you vote for Irre?
I decided to do what Gib suggested and re-read the first 2-3 pages of the thread. I have been following it (as much as I can, at work), but that first suggestion about mass role-revealing just doesn't sit right with me. And yes, I know there was a lot to follow, but how in heaven's name can that ever be a good idea? It creeped me out, to be frank.

I'm not buying this. You read, carefully, the whole thread and I was the best suspect? Really??

Post by **irretating** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 5:41 am

MZ: there's a traitor. No SK from my read of the OP.

Are you happy with what dp did re seer cover?

Post by **amok** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:04 am

irretating wrote:
amok wrote:
oblivion wrote:
amok wrote:Why did you vote for Charou, Oblivion?
I'd like to ask the reverse. why did you vote for Irre?
I decided to do what Gib suggested and re-read the first 2-3 pages of the thread. I have been following it (as much as I can, at work), but that first suggestion about mass role-revealing just doesn't sit right with me. And yes, I know there was a lot to follow, but how in heaven's name can that ever be a good idea? It creeped me out, to be frank.
I'm not buying this. You read, carefully, the whole thread and I was the best suspect? Really??

Carefully? I'll say yes, under the circumstances, which isn't the same as on the days when I sit quietly and read and re-read. But yes, you were. Obviously much better players than I vote wrong in these games, especially on the first day. I'm not sure, but I don't think a suspicion is all that out of line, either.

Post by **Magicziggy** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:06 am

Irre,
Yes, I have no problem with DPs post. It is clear that if you wish to provide cover for the seer, you give a random "view". As long as people ignore these views in normal play, it becomes effective when the seer turns up dead. With charlou dead I think we've lost that chance. I'll have to look back and see what her reaction to Linus was.

Post by **amok** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:16 am

Irre, I've just re-read again and this is the post that raised my hackles:

Irre wrote:
Oh, I don't think a mass outing will break the game, it'd just be an experiment I'd like to see. And I bet it would be fun.

How wouldn't it be bad for Town? And for that matter, why would anyone believe anyone's claim in the first place? I concede that I may (likely) be missing something here, but that still sounds like someone trying to make light of an idea that's bad for Town, in sort of a "aren't I silly?" sort of way.

Right or wrong, that was my impression.

Post by **Feck** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:19 am

Please make up your minds . Is it scummy of me to vote DP on day one or is it scummy when I don't ? you are not getting to hit me with both ends of the same stick !Talking of the wrong end of the stick ,some people have a firm grasp of it about which side they are on and the game in general .

Post by **irretating** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:21 am

Fair enough, amok. I was just surprised to wake up and read through a thread that had exploded with posts, and you'd decided I should get the vote.

Post by **Magicziggy** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:22 am

I need to read the PG thread. Just saw a reference from there to 4 cops. Liking linus's idea about seer cover but there's bound to be some twisted versions of the cop role. Needs someone to think this through.

Only found shizzle's reference to a traitor so far. The PG is where I'm headed.

Post by **irretating** » Sat Jul 30, 2011 6:23 am

Feck wrote:Please make up your minds . Is it scummy of me to vote DP on day one or is it scummy when I don't ? you are not getting to hit me with both ends of the same stick !Talking of the wrong end of the stick ,some people have a firm grasp of it about which side they are on and the game in general .

Oh don't play coy. You

rationalia.com