The Innsmouth Look game thread.

[Mantisdreamz]

I don't trust ksen's out either.

relieved as hell about feck. I tried to stay awake until nightfall, but missed it by about 15 minutes.

he's been pushing on feck though..

[oblivion]

^^ clarifying, he likes to default day 1 vote DP earl, usually well before it's clear where day 1 will go.

[oblivion]

augh. early.

[Mantisdreamz]

it's got to be either Charlou, r.c, or DP

b.ternarius and Ironclad look more towny than them.

ksen has claimed tracker, which agreed - does look like we have a ton of specials now. but, as said above he's been going after Feck the don for the last few days.

[Mantisdreamz]

there was a point where Charlou sort of whiteknighted Feck as well. Said that his posts towards Diva looked like 'town flail'

[Mantisdreamz]

Ob, you mentioned to Irre (end of day2) that there were a few posts that looked naive on her part. And for whatever reason, Irre pointed out the post that she responded to r.c with, and asked if that was the one.

hold on this one..
http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 40#p909969 referring to this post http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 20#p909814

why did Irre think you were referring to that one? i'm wondering if Irre knew/sensed that his post was a little off, yet responded in positive anyway

[Athene]

it's got to be either Charlou, r.c, or DP

b.ternarius and Ironclad look more towny than them.

ksen has claimed tracker, which agreed - does look like we have a ton of specials now. but, as said above he's been going after Feck the don for the last few days.

Yeah, he was on to feck before there was any real suspicion over feck. It's a bit WIFOM but would he do that to a scum buddy who was the don?

[Mantisdreamz]

it's got to be either Charlou, r.c, or DP

b.ternarius and Ironclad look more towny than them.

ksen has claimed tracker, which agreed - does look like we have a ton of specials now. but, as said above he's been going after Feck the don for the last few days.

Yeah, he was on to feck before there was any real suspicion over feck. It's a bit WIFOM but would he do that to a scum buddy who was the don?

I don't think so. And his reactions to Ob always thinking he's scum look genuine

[Mantisdreamz]

..i don't think so/i don't know/mostly doubt it

[r.c]

Always a good idea to see the order of votes.

Order of votes

Before ksen's tracker claim
ksen (1)-ob
mantis(1)- ic
ksen (5)- UT, b.tern,feck,r.c

ksen role claim
feck (1)- ksen
unvote ksen (2)- b.tern,ob, r.c,
feck (2)- athene
athene (2)-ob, DP
unvote ksen(1)- ut
feck (3)- ut
unvote feck (2)- ut
athen (3)- ut
DP (1)- charlou
feck (3)- mantis
athene (5)- r.c, feck

Athene role claim

unvote athene (4)- ob,
feck (4)-ob
unvote DP (0)- charlou
feck (6)-b.tern, charlou

If scum were to sacrifice a player before the seer role claim, the don would be a bad choice. Hence ksen I'm willing to believe in ksen's role claim now. 2nd vote by athene - I'm believing his role claim too.
After athene's role claim, and UT being the mayor, b.tern's vote on feck was critical. She could have abstained from voting if she were scum. b.tern is town in my books now.
Charlou is not yet cleared because her vote was after b.tern. She could have voted athene, but he had already made the role claim. That would be giving away the names of 2 scum players.
So her vote on feck, does not clear her yet.

[r.c]

town

UT
ob
r.c
ksen
athene
b.tern
ic?

scum ?
mantis
Dp
charlou

[Uselesstwit]

mantis has been cleared by the seer r.c., and with the don dead that's a lock for being cleared.

[Don't Panic]

If the brain-scooper's a vig and winds up taking out the vision-giver/roleblocker(?) that would seriously suck.

True, but if it's a sk then they would be making themselves a target by outing.

[oblivion]

Ob, you mentioned to Irre (end of day2) that there were a few posts that looked naive on her part. And for whatever reason, Irre pointed out the post that she responded to r.c with, and asked if that was the one.

hold on this one..
http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 40#p909969 referring to this post http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 20#p909814

why did Irre think you were referring to that one? i'm wondering if Irre knew/sensed that his post was a little off, yet responded in positive anyway

That was not the post I had in mind, as I said, though I can see why she might have thought so. And it is one of r.c's posts that bother me a bit, though I can see someone who feels that the game is really all about vanilla town* saying that sincerely from a meta perspective, even though I felt (and still feel) that it was a mistake not to lynch me yesterday.

The post that prompted me to say that bit about naive posts and trying to blend in was this one http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 20#p909832, which came shortly after the one she thought I meant.

* The game really should be about vanilla town IMO. Who gets the special roles and what they are able to do with them is all very chance-driven. Sometimes the game will come down to one or two players' special actions, and that's great fun for the players involved, but if games always worked out that way, vanilla town would be boring as hell.

The posts in the game thread and the votes people make, along analyzing the results and the bandwagon formations is not up to chance. Every town player no matter what their role can contribute to that, and it is often what wins (or loses) games.

[Uselesstwit]

on the other hand r.c. I can't help but notice that you were the one that broke the tie off of feck onto athene before she role claimed. Not sure you should be that high in your own list.