The Innsmouth Look game thread.

[irretating]

Why iclad?

iclad claimed to have played 2 games before in the sign-up thread, so probably won't be NKed early.

Really? That is the best that you can do?

@@vote b.ternarius@@

Why vote for the person who mayor voted you?

What's wrong with linus' seer suggestion and the reasoning?

Why not?

Linus is using a previous game to justify not viewing the mayor...hey, it worked in that game, but I am going to be suspect of the motivations.

So...no reason for your mayor vote?

[divagreen]

Would you like me to vote for you, Irre?

Because I could totally be down with that as well...as long as you were viewed.

[b.ternarius]

I'd ask the same question, though. Why would having only played two games make you less likely to be nk'd? Ime, being newish is no protection.

[b.ternarius]

Also, I'm out for a couple hours now.

[charlou]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why crumple?

[Atheist-Lite]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why crumple?

Why me? That's what I'd like to know?

[Linus]

Linus is using a previous game to justify not viewing the mayor...hey, it worked in that game, but I am going to be suspect of the motivations.

Which game are you thinking of here?

[Mantisdreamz]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why crumple?

wouldn't it be because he's new - so we won't be able to tell if he's giving off n00b vibes or scummy vibes. So the view seems like a good idea, at some point at least


@@vote Linus@@

[oblivion]

hi guys.

[Linus]

wouldn't it be because he's new - so we won't be able to tell if he's giving off n00b vibes or scummy vibes. So the view seems like a good idea, at some point at least

You missed the first post after the OP. Crumple is my mayor-vote and iclad my seer suggestion, though it could have been the other way around too.

[charlou]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why crumple?

wouldn't it be because he's new - so we won't be able to tell if he's giving off n00b vibes or scummy vibes. So the view seems like a good idea, at some point at least


@@vote Linus@@

Why not let Linus answer for himself?

wouldn't it be because he's new - so we won't be able to tell if he's giving off n00b vibes or scummy vibes. So the view seems like a good idea, at some point at least

You missed the first post after the OP. Crumple is my mayor-vote and iclad my seer suggestion, though it could have been the other way around too.

That's not an answer either. Why crumple to break ties?

[Mantisdreamz]

wouldn't it be because he's new - so we won't be able to tell if he's giving off n00b vibes or scummy vibes. So the view seems like a good idea, at some point at least

You missed the first post after the OP. Crumple is my mayor-vote and iclad my seer suggestion, though it could have been the other way around too.

ohh okay.

Charlou, sorry - couldn't help myself. didn't realize i had it mixed up though. beyond that, it is true that it is tricky to read a newcomer sometimes

[Linus]

That's not an answer either. Why crumple to break ties?

I think tie-breaking by an inexperienced player is somewhat more informative than tie-breaking by an experienced player, and Crumple claims to be new to Mafia.

[ksen]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why?

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 14#p906814

[ksen]

Why iclad?

iclad claimed to have played 2 games before in the sign-up thread, so probably won't be NKed early.

Then why did you make a point that your mayor vote on Crumple wasn't a seer view suggestion since by his own admission he is also a newb?