Russian Roulette Game Thread

[Gonzo]

Trust me. There will be ways to know she is lying once she answers why she felt she was being 'hinted in'. The town is in a good position, if she is scum.

[Gonzo]

I can't get over the fact that you won't agree to my having a point, at least, Athene. I'd hate to think you are scum just because you hadn't considered what I hade to say hard enough.

Anyone else have an opinion on this? Should Athene unvote? Does she have a point? Do you see where I am coming from?

[Gonzo]

Just to make sure it is answered for us: What allowed you to determine diva was dropping a hint, Mantis? Do you have information we don't or not?

[Athene]

I can't get over the fact that you won't agree to my having a point, at least, Athene. I'd hate to think you are scum just because you hadn't considered what I hade to say hard enough.

Anyone else have an opinion on this? Should Athene unvote? Does she have a point? Do you see where I am coming from?

Which point? The first one which was based on a misunderstanding. I take responsibility for that misunderstanding btw, I wasn't clear enough in my post. Or the second one where you are saying there could be other possible explanations behind mantis's actions but I have to wait until mantis comes along. What are you honestly expecting me to do? Unvote purely based on some other hypothetical explanation?

[DennyB]

Just to make sure it is answered for us: What allowed you to determine diva was dropping a hint, Mantis? Do you have information we don't or not?

+1

[Gonzo]

I don't expect you to unvote or suggest that you should, but because you agree there could be more than one explanation for Mantis seeing a hint other than that scum are aware there are bombs - I think it would make sense for you to unvote if town. Otherwise it appears to me you don't wish to give Mantis a fair chance to make an explanation - one which will allow you to make a better judgement. If Mantis claims to have additional info, we can tell if he is lying given the fact he saw the hint.

[DennyB]

I think either Irre or Ksen are scum.
Voting for one should provide us with info I think

[Gonzo]

unvote Athene

I suppose I'll wait to see how things go. Right now I think you're town, so I shouldn't be voting for you just because I disagree with your play.

[DennyB]

I wonder if scum has bombs as well. I'd bet the odds are good.

Gonzo seems to be makin g sence today, though he does this as scum as well. He has moved down my list.

I'm Not sure if the think with gonzo and athene was a misunderstanding at first or just back tracking to save face.

[DennyB]

edit: if I think..

[Gonzo]

To a degree it was a misunderstanding. I thought she was claiming to believe scum new who the Bombs were, that is not the case. Athene is saying the scum might know there are Bombs, period, so that would explain Mantis' additional info. I counter that by saying there could be another explantion for Mantis having that info we think she has. Objectively I can see where Athene is coming from (One of the explanations is incriminating - but I would rather we wait to see which explanation Matis uses), I am in no rush to vote Mantis until he says more.

[Mantisdreamz]

Just to make sure it is answered for us: What allowed you to determine diva was dropping a hint, Mantis? Do you have information we don't or not?

no way. it was the way she said it - I know her. I had no clue that she was a bomb when I unvoted - there's no way I would know that.

But it was on hindsight that it occurred to me that she knew that she was a bomb, after the fact.

This post -

I have already stated that I am happy to be viewed, in fact I encourage it, since I know that I am innocent. But if anybody else really thinks that I am scum and they are town then I suggest that everyone remove their lynch votes from all other players and let Irre's vote for me stand alone...I will be lynched by her vote, so what have you got to lose? (Except a town player.)

Diva wanted Irre to go at this point, she knew she would blow up.

[Mantisdreamz]

no way. it was the way she said it - I know her. I had no clue that she was a bomb when I unvoted - there's no way I would know that.

just to further explain that, because I realize it might be unclear. She sounded alarmed, which alarmed me enough to unvote her. Though, I didn't know she was a bomb.

[DennyB]

Ksen,

Ive seen you around.
Ya gona post?

[Adenosine]

He already has. He dropped a vote on Irre and ran. Then came back and told Zigmen that if he wasn't voting for Irre he'd be voting for Zigmen again.