Carnivale Game Thread

[charlou]

That was in reply to MZ's post above DP's.

[Don't Panic]

I'll stay for a while, but it's 1:40am here.

Do me a favour tomorrow, go back and read day 1 and 2 as if you weren't playing. Look very closely at Gib and Denny, that's where my suspicion comes from.

Higgs is most likely as scum 3.

[Magicziggy]

What do you make of the whole role claim for Higgs?
I am open to switch my vote on DP. But I need it to hammer down on a scum.

[The Curious Squid]

At this point I'm wavering about changing my vote from DP though it seems to me like the whole scenario is just compounding the confusion.

Is it the general consensus that there is a vigilante killing off people as well as the scum killing people? what side would a vigilante be on?

[Don't Panic]

At this point I'm wavering about changing my vote from DP though it seems to me like the whole scenario is just compounding the confusion.

Is it the general consensus that there is a vigilante killing off people as well as the scum killing people? what side would a vigilante be on?

Vigilantes are town, the other option would be a serial killer who is usually independent, they win if they kill everyone.

[charlou]

AFAIK vigilantes are always town. Serial killers are indies (independent) .. I'm not convinced either way about what we have here.

[Magicziggy]

I think I'll stick.
And I'll add charlou to my list of possible scum for teaming up with DP in trying to move votes off him.

Good night.

[charlou]

I think I'll stick.
And I'll add charlou to my list of possible scum for teaming up with DP in trying to move votes off him.

Good night.

There's no teaming up going on, but if DP's town I'm on his side .. if not, you'll rest easy with your decision, I'm sure.

[Uselesstwit]

to answer a question much further back in the thread I'm lodz, and if higgs and I are lovers we haven't been told, at least I haven't. and if we are the odds are good that she's scum since I'm not, if the lovers in this game are one of each.

[Uselesstwit]

So I'm just going to assume that she's not only scummy because of her play but also because of a possible role. It also kind of explains why i'm still here, if she were told.
Higgs was trying to get a bandwagon started on either gib or dp last night. She's also scrapped with me, char and irre. So I think we have 5 fairly cleared town.
She also fos'd callan but that was light for higgs and might be a bussing of a teammate. Usually higgs goes off the rail about stuff like that. That might be a sixth semi cleared but it makes me nervous.
So iff higgs is scum, and I really think she is that short list of likely scum is:
denny
squid
MZ
that can't be cleared by higgs behavior towards them. of those I'd say denny has been the least townish.

vote denny

if you guys want to kill higgs instead I'm okay with that also, a one to one trade is more than welcome, but personally I'd like some more time to analyze higgs posts before I'm bumped out. I have to get ready for bday stuff, I'll see everyone day 4, if I'm alive.

[The Curious Squid]

That was a bad move UT, so far, every character in this game has been faithful to the TV series, Lodes was a bastard and was killed by the main character after he murdered the snake charmer (who was Feck in this game) and your posts for Denny and Higgs seem really BW to me and to top it off I think the last remark of "if I'm alive" is a cheap shot. This one post has been enough to convince me that you are scum.

UNVOTE VOTE Uselesstwit

[higgs2]

Hey guys I'm not lovers with anyone. Seems my lover is dead. If I were going to make up a role I would never take this one because it's tooo likely someone else would whave it.

This is p. funny:
http://tviv.org/Carnivàle/Lila_Villanueva
You have to read all of Season 2 for the funny part.

Season 1
Immediately established as Lodz's bedmate, Lila is a snob without any real money. She entertains delusions of being the focal point of the carnival, and of being above the rest of the carnies. In reality, though, she's just another bearded lady, except that hers is real. She remains fairly unimportant throughout most of season 1, serving more as a catalyst than a character. Lodz employed her to keep tabs on Ben, whom she tried unsuccessfully to seduce on several occasions, and he also used her in his plot to murder Ruthie. Lodz placed the poisonous snake in with Ruthie's dresses that Lila mended and had her deliver them to Ruthie's trailer anonymously. It is unclear as to whether or not Lila was aware of the murder plot, although we can assume that she was not since she and Ruthie appeared to be non-hostile acquaintances.

Season 2
Lila, distraught over Lodz's mysterious disappearance, seeks out Samson's help. Samson, who was in the middle of trying to dispose of Lodz's body, feeds her a flimsy line about Lodz deserting in the night. Unconvinced, and mistrustful of Samson, Lila discovered the clues that indicate that Lodz's disappearance was as much a surprise to him as it was to her. Her fears are moderately allayed, however, when she is woken one night in Lodz's traditional fashion. Namely, cunnilingus. Amusingly enough, though, it is not Lodz who is the cunning linguist, but Ruthie (albeit possessed by a deceased Lodz). Heartened by the temporary return of her lover, Lila tries to force Samson's hand by revealing what she knows, but her insurrection goes awry when no one really cares that Lodz is gone. Beaten, she has no choice but to throw her lot in with the rest of the carnies.

[higgs2]

So I'm just going to assume that she's not only scummy because of her play but also because of a possible role. It also kind of explains why i'm still here, if she were told.
Higgs was trying to get a bandwagon started on either gib or dp last night. She's also scrapped with me, char and irre. So I think we have 5 fairly cleared town.
She also fos'd callan but that was light for higgs and might be a bussing of a teammate. Usually higgs goes off the rail about stuff like that. That might be a sixth semi cleared but it makes me nervous.
So iff higgs is scum, and I really think she is that short list of likely scum is:
denny
squid
MZ
that can't be cleared by higgs behavior towards them. of those I'd say denny has been the least townish.
vote denny

if you guys want to kill higgs instead I'm okay with that also, a one to one trade is more than welcome, but personally I'd like some more time to analyze higgs posts before I'm bumped out. I have to get ready for bday stuff, I'll see everyone day 4, if I'm alive.

I was tryng to find scum. You asked me who I thought would be a likely recruit and I told you.


Do you really think I am so stupid that if I'm scum I will argue with the town and copletely ignore the scum? It is actually a little weird that you're claiming lodtz or whatever hi name is since he is dead from everything I have read. I can't beleive you are using my behavior towards the other players to clear them or say they are scum? That's not what you meant is it?

[higgs2]

Hey guys I'm not lovers with anyone. Seems my lover is dead. If I were going to make up a role I would never take this one because it's tooo likely someone else would whave it.

This is p. funny:
http://tviv.org/Carnivàle/Lila_Villanueva
You have to read all of Season 2 for the funny part.

Season 1
Immediately established as Lodz's bedmate, Lila is a snob without any real money. She entertains delusions of being the focal point of the carnival, and of being above the rest of the carnies. In reality, though, she's just another bearded lady, except that hers is real. She remains fairly unimportant throughout most of season 1, serving more as a catalyst than a character. Lodz employed her to keep tabs on Ben, whom she tried unsuccessfully to seduce on several occasions, and he also used her in his plot to murder Ruthie. Lodz placed the poisonous snake in with Ruthie's dresses that Lila mended and had her deliver them to Ruthie's trailer anonymously. It is unclear as to whether or not Lila was aware of the murder plot, although we can assume that she was not since she and Ruthie appeared to be non-hostile acquaintances.

Season 2
Lila, distraught over Lodz's mysterious disappearance, seeks out Samson's help. Samson, who was in the middle of trying to dispose of Lodz's body, feeds her a flimsy line about Lodz deserting in the night. Unconvinced, and mistrustful of Samson, Lila discovered the clues that indicate that Lodz's disappearance was as much a surprise to him as it was to her. Her fears are moderately allayed, however, when she is woken one night in Lodz's traditional fashion. Namely, cunnilingus. Amusingly enough, though, it is not Lodz who is the cunning linguist, but Ruthie (albeit possessed by a deceased Lodz). Heartened by the temporary return of her lover, Lila tries to force Samson's hand by revealing what she knows, but her insurrection goes awry when no one really cares that Lodz is gone. Beaten, she has no choice but to throw her lot in with the rest of the carnies.

Also, I can't believe raven would make a role of lovers and not tell either one of them. I guess it's possible. But I've not seen that before.

[oblivion]

NIGHTFALL