Carnivale Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

vote DP

Bed time for me.

[charlou]

gib is looking more townish .. squid looks townish .. higgs, she seems scummy as fuck, but I'm not sure .. Callan, hasn't posted anything to change my mind ... UT, townish but he's always hard to read .. irre, probably cleared by Zigmen's view .. Denny, my reread of today's posts from him ring alarm bells .. he's voted DP, telling him to speak up now, right at the start of the day .. he's not given DP an opportunity to get into the role and play a bit .. I think that's really off, just voting for the most obvious option rather than waiting to see how the new day's play and DP's contribution unfolds, so FOS Denny ...


I'm going back through the day's posts to count the votes ...

[charlou]

vote DP

Bed time for me.

Why?

[charlou]

The vote count I have is:

Ghat/DP (Denny, Squid, Callan, MZ)

gib (DP)

higgs2 (irre, gib)

Callan (higgs, Charlou)


On my reread of the thread to tally the votes I noticed MZ rolling around with his votes quite a bit, going with popular choice each time. I think of the votes on DP, at least one is scum. With a revised perspective from the reread, I'm thinking Denny is likely and MZ looks suspicious.

unvote vote Denny


New count:

Ghat/DP (Denny, Squid, Callan, MZ)

gib (DP)

higgs2 (irre, gib)

Callan (higgs)

Denny (Charlou)

UT is the only one who hasn't voted yet.

Please check this count for yourselves though as I may have missed a vote or vote change.

[Magicziggy]

Well just before I turn in, I'll answer that.
I voted DP, then I voted Higgs then I've gone back to DP.
The Higgs vote was mote to get a reaction as she wasn't making much sense at that time.

I've stated that I find both to be scummy.
I've also noted that higgs is claiming a role that is a potential lover.
Killing a lover would mean killing town.

This is my reasoning.

[charlou]

Okay.

[Magicziggy]

Why Denny. You've merely stated he is likely.

[Magicziggy]

I really have to turn in.
I think Denny is a possibility.
But DP is very likely indeed.

[charlou]

Actually, where did you state you find DP scummy?

[charlou]

I really have to turn in.

Yeah, 1.30 here .. I should soon too ..

[charlou]

Actually, where did you state you find DP scummy?

I want to know the why, rather than the where ... ?

[Magicziggy]

Just repeating the obivous maybe, but just so I've got this clear.
Mono (+ani) was a vig kill.
No scum kill.
It's recruitment game.

I think scum would have started with 2 and had a night 0 recrtuitment. Looks like Ghat.
Maybe they could kill or recuit, no specials as someone said.
So they killed night 1 (feck), recruited night 2?

vote DP/ Glogboy

I agree with Higgs about Irre. She's been cleared via Charlou, but the extensive day 1 summary could be an attempt to look busy. However, having done this type of thing myself as town, I've never bothered with it as scum. I still think it's likely that she's town.

When I voted him this morning.
DP responded well to the onslaught this morning. Doesn't change the fact that the damage was done on day 1.
I didn't dind DP scummy as such. But the whole scenario points to DP being scum.

[Don't Panic]

gib is looking more townish .. squid looks townish .. higgs, she seems scummy as fuck, but I'm not sure .. Callan, hasn't posted anything to change my mind ... UT, townish but he's always hard to read .. irre, probably cleared by Zigmen's view .. Denny, my reread of today's posts from him ring alarm bells .. he's voted DP, telling him to speak up now, right at the start of the day .. he's not given DP an opportunity to get into the role and play a bit .. I think that's really off, just voting for the most obvious option rather than waiting to see how the new day's play and DP's contribution unfolds, so FOS Denny ...


I'm going back through the day's posts to count the votes ...

Denny always finds me scummy, it's kind of his default state in mafia, not sure how scummy that is, but he does look scummy in general.

[Magicziggy]

I'll stay for a while, but it's 1:40am here.

[charlou]

That's if you buy your own recruitment scenario .. I don't see why you should.

I think DP's inherited an unfortunate situation due to a genuine meltdown by Ghat. I think Denny's vote is very convenient and I suspect yours may be too, although you've at least tried to give it some credence apart from the baggage of Ghat's meltdown behaviour.