Carnivale Game Thread

[irretating]

Okay I'm getting technical again.

So scum has recruiting and a role blocker.

Town had a seer. It seems like town should have a vig and a doc to make it even shouldn't they? Or maybe just one of those? I don't see the Masons as being very "helpful specials" especially with the lovebird suicide thingy.


Would someone who designs games care to comment?

There is a vig, surely. Two kills on night one, what other explanation is there?

And the vig has kind of hinted at who they are. If they want to make a hit count they could take out higgs tonight. Just sayin'

[higgs2]

Okay I'm getting technical again.

So scum has recruiting and a role blocker.

Town had a seer. It seems like town should have a vig and a doc to make it even shouldn't they? Or maybe just one of those? I don't see the Masons as being very "helpful specials" especially with the lovebird suicide thingy.


Would someone who designs games care to comment?

For the nth time, I think Mantis enabled one of the scum powers. If not the blocker, then it has to be recruitment surely.

I know but what is the traitor part about then? Sorry I'm not getting this more quickly, I've never played a game with an "enabler"

[charlou]

I think charlous is the one who made the role outing suggestion. I am p. sure she is town because of her past. I asked her her part to be snotty, not becuase I think there is anything to out, she has given us what I think is all of it. I should have refused to answer her and left whether I am the vig ambiguous. Wasn't thinking.

I did not, you volunteered your character .. it's such a safe townish looking character isn't it? I'm very skeptical about it and that's why I asked. I do not everyone to out their roles.

[higgs2]

Charlou, you said "What part do you have in all this then?" I didn't know what would satisfy you but I wanted you to stop special hunting.

[Magicziggy]

Traitor is an indie. Views as town. Wins with scum.

[charlou]

I can assure you I wasn't special hunting, but seeing if you have any useful thoughts along the lines of character flavour.




How much time until nightfall? It would be good to hear more from Denny, DP and gib.

[higgs2]

Traitor is an indie. Views as town. Wins with scum.

I know but to be an enabler and traitor is unusual to me. Actually my experience they view as scum. But whatever.

[irretating]

back in a few hours.. I'm happy with my vote today

[higgs2]

unvote vote callan to weird to whiny, and not voting seems scummy. Gibs is right up there too though. I'm still suspicious of ghat that was but that can wait.

gotta go to bed.

[charlou]

I can assure you I wasn't special hunting, but seeing if you have any useful thoughts along the lines of character flavour.




How much time until nightfall? It would be good to hear more from Denny, DP and gib.

And Callan .. Especially Callan. I am thinking of voting for her due to her over reaction to the vote thing .. I'd like to hear what she thinks now that there have been more posts to analyse ... if she's changed her mind about voting ...

[charlou]

fuckit .. I'm going to vote Callan too .. As I said from the start, her post about the vote thing looks like a passive aggressive flail.

[oblivion]

Nightfall is in 12 hours.

[Magicziggy]

In Carnivale blind mentalist Lodz and Lila the Bearded Lady were lovers.
Higgs has done enough research by her own admission to know this.

Who is Lodz?
Not me.

Lila could be signalling to her lover to protect her.

[Magicziggy]

Lovers would be one of each alignment, with both dying if one is killed.

[charlou]

Yes, I was just reading that in the wiki ...