Carnivale Game Thread

[higgs2]

I'm not scum. I was however visited by someone very sexy, I assume the scum prostitute. Same thing as the others.

I'm surprised about the mason thing, I thought it was lovebirds who were joined so that one died if the other did. I haven't seen that with masons. I think we cannot make any assumptions with this game, and i have been . Abut the "traitorous enabler" (still don't get that), about charlous being part of a mason group. About ghat's behavior being role connected and not ghat connected. On the other hand, UT might be right about the recruitment thing.

UT is right about recruiters having restrictions. Sometimes the restriction is that it takes 2 nights. If anyone feels weird or dizzy or whatever you might be being recruited. If you really want to help town, speak up. Sometimes they have to choose between a scum kill or a recruit. And yeah, like UT says sometimes(often) they cannot recruit specials. And if they can the special usually cannot keep their power.

chalou you saidnsomethingabout mebringingp mantis, and that I kept saying you were part of a mason group. Here yo can see (if you are paying attention and not just trolley tracking me or pissed that I didn't like you tl;dr "summary") that what I was saying is that we can't make assumptions. About you being a mason, about whatever a traitor/enabler is. The actual masons I mentioned were actual masons.

You are really twisting what I say to make a case against me. Maybe becuase you are scum or maybe because you are dum. lol.

The summary you said was tl;dr was irre's not mine. I haven't said anything about you bringing up Mantis .. that was someone else too. I didn't say you 'kept saying' I'm part of a mason group, I just pointed out that I've said a couple of times that I'm not part of a Mason group.

This post of yours is really sloppy, higgs.

I must just be really confused. some of it is to irre and some to you.

Can you tell me when ani said something about recruiting? I'm not finding it. And yes I've had a few glasses of wine, but I don' twant to put this off until tomorrow and miss night fall by accident.

[Uselesstwit]

UT, I'm not talk about what Ani said, but what Oblivion said in today's OP.

"Mononoke and Animavore were Alexandra and Caladonia Potter, conjoined twin acrobats and carnie masons who would both die if one of them were killed or recruited."

This makes this game a recruitment game unless we think it's a red herring.

Not sure why exactly, but I'm thinking it's not a red herring ... probably because including a red herring doesn't seem like something ob would do?

sorry cross post.

[Magicziggy]

Why are people mudding the waters here. Oblivion makes some convoluted games but she doesn't post false info that would cause wifom. Seriously? magic and to an extent char, you think that ob faked a pm and an op that would only hurt town?

That's what I'm asking. Someone else suggested red herring. I want to know if we are dealing 100% for sure with a recruitment game. You've answered that. Thank you.

Seems to me that I've had to point out to you that we are dealing with a recruitment game, not just assuming it from what Ani said yesterday.

No one sugggested anyone faked anything. Where are you getting this from?

[higgs2]

I'm back. OK, Gib's response to my post and my accusation of him is the most pro-town post I've seen in a while. Plus he's holding steady ground against DP (who I think is town).

I think higgs is scum. She's been fixating on the technical aspects (even mentioning mantis again today, gawd only knows why) and it's a good smoke screen for scum. I'm not buying the "I was visited by a prozzie" either. It's lame to claim that today given everyone knows it doesn't clear anyone.
unovte Gib, vote higgs

Re callan, well her play is entirely different this game. This will always ping.

I forgot to mention Squid in my earlier post (sorry Squid!). I think Squid is playing a town game. Whether this is because he has a great mentor is another thing.

Here's the post about me mentioning mantis again, sorry charlous.

I was visited by a prozzie you sillies. Why would I claim that if it were not true? Lying about it could just get me in trouble

I'm not sure what fixating on the technical aspects means, maybe someone would like to explain. Seriously, I am very curious. I have talked about a lot of players as well.

[Magicziggy]

it means To Long; Didn't Read.

ta.

Now I know.

[Uselesstwit]

I must just be really confused. some of it is to irre and some to you.

Can you tell me when ani said something about recruiting? I'm not finding it. And yes I've had a few glasses of wine, but I don' twant to put this off until tomorrow and miss night fall by accident.

as a matter of fact I was looking it up anyway, but decided to yell first at the brain farts that were going on.

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 57#p692957

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 37#p693037

it's not clear cut but when taken with the OP from today I'm pretty sure of it.

[charlou]

I've only seen Callan play in the ill fated godkill game when she was scum.
There's nothing in her play that I think is scummy.
This position on the bw thing is bullshit. I will vote whenever, whatever.
I don't mind being first, last or third. It simply is not something I consider.
Of far more importance is whether the eventual lynch was close or a runaway.

This I do agree with and have the same attitude wrt how I vote .. I just think Callan's reaction is out of proportion to the situation. As you pointed out, she's not the only player responsible for that lynch. Her reaction just looks like a sympathy grab to me, and unnecessary if she's town.

[Uselesstwit]

Why are people mudding the waters here. Oblivion makes some convoluted games but she doesn't post false info that would cause wifom. Seriously? magic and to an extent char, you think that ob faked a pm and an op that would only hurt town?

That's what I'm asking. Someone else suggested red herring. I want to know if we are dealing 100% for sure with a recruitment game. You've answered that. Thank you.

Seems to me that I've had to point out to you that we are dealing with a recruitment game, not just assuming it from what Ani said yesterday.

No one sugggested anyone faked anything. Where are you getting this from?

who was it do you remember?
and yes I totally missed that part of the OP, I was just trusting what ani said once he flipped town.
That's kind of what red herring means isn't it? a false clue?

[charlou]

Can you tell me when ani said something about recruiting? I'm not finding it.

It's here

And yes I've had a few glasses of wine,

Enough to explain the wifom?

[higgs2]

I must just be really confused. some of it is to irre and some to you.

Can you tell me when ani said something about recruiting? I'm not finding it. And yes I've had a few glasses of wine, but I don' twant to put this off until tomorrow and miss night fall by accident.

as a matter of fact I was looking it up anyway, but decided to yell first at the brain farts that were going on.

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 57#p692957

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 37#p693037

it's not clear cut but when taken with the OP from today I'm pretty sure of it.

Brain farts is right. Yes, recruiting. Oblivion wouldn't put that in there if it weren't true.

We don't know if recruiting has gone on, or what the conditions are. Is that too fucking technical, am I seeming obsessesed (not at you UT) . It seems like we should talk about stuff like that but when I do everyone freaks out. So.
voteghatdp

[higgs2]

Can you tell me when ani said something about recruiting? I'm not finding it.

It's here

And yes I've had a few glasses of wine,

Enough to explain the wifom?

What wifom do you mean?

[Uselesstwit]

I've only seen Callan play in the ill fated godkill game when she was scum.
There's nothing in her play that I think is scummy.
This position on the bw thing is bullshit. I will vote whenever, whatever.
I don't mind being first, last or third. It simply is not something I consider.
Of far more importance is whether the eventual lynch was close or a runaway.

This I do agree with and have the same attitude wrt how I vote .. I just think Callan's reaction is out of proportion to the situation. As you pointed out, she's not the only player responsible for that lynch. Her reaction just looks like a sympathy grab to me, and unnecessary if she's town.

this kind of gave me a wtf moment. callan voted for mantis on day one, and mort on day two. She's deciding not to vote for a 50/50 record? She's played several games, no way would one town lynch vote cause this much drama. I'm thinking she might be buckling under the pressure.

[Uselesstwit]

I must just be really confused. some of it is to irre and some to you.

Can you tell me when ani said something about recruiting? I'm not finding it. And yes I've had a few glasses of wine, but I don' twant to put this off until tomorrow and miss night fall by accident.

as a matter of fact I was looking it up anyway, but decided to yell first at the brain farts that were going on.

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 57#p692957

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 37#p693037

it's not clear cut but when taken with the OP from today I'm pretty sure of it.

Brain farts is right. Yes, recruiting. Oblivion wouldn't put that in there if it weren't true.

We don't know if recruiting has gone on, or what the conditions are. Is that too fucking technical, am I seeming obsessesed (not at you UT) . It seems like we should talk about stuff like that but when I do everyone freaks out. So.
voteghatdp

what do you think of the missed night kill?

[Magicziggy]

Found the quote. Twas gib.

I believe you. I think the whole recruiting thing is a red herring.

[charlou]

hmmm ... gib, why do you think so?

Okay, higgs, my vote on you and the wifom comment was to apply pressure to see how you'd react .. Apart from the sloppy mix-up, I think your response may be genuine so benefit of the doubt for now.

unvote higgs

higgs is not out of the woods for me .. a scum team can easily orchestrate a prostitute visit to their own team ... and Callan and gib are high on my scum list.

Denny ... hmmm .. I'm going to search his posts ... he's very good at slipping under the radar with me ...