Carnivale Game Thread

[mononoke]

Mantis looks like a scum special I doubt scum would vote for him unless the situation was bad for them. So FECK, Ani & Callan are probably town. Well, FECK is town.

[Uselesstwit]

I think we're considering her an indi not part of the scum team. We could be wrong since we can't seem to find an exact match for her role, but it seems like scum would think her town.

[irretating]

higgs, that's a strange response to the OP... isn't it far more likely our vig killed our seer?

Oh.. and squid.. you have some explaining to do with your post in the PG...

Do we get another PM with a description of what happens at night like we did with night 0?

I take it from the description that Mantis was scum as well?

what do you mean charlous? I didn't speculate on who killed our seer. Are you meaning to post this to someone else?

bah. i meant, what do you mean, *irre*

Oh ok, I misunderstood. Still, I don't get why you think there'd be a mason and something happening on night 0

[charlou]

My posting restriction has been lifted overnight .. Shame, I was having fun with the smilie thing

Just catching up on the day's posts now ...

[Magicziggy]

"You are the Doctor Enabler. You have no special power other than the vote. As long as you are alive, the Doctor will be as well. You might not want to tell any mafia this. You win if all the mafia are dead. I made a mistake on this, it was supposed to be the doc can protect people instead of will be alive"

Ok I found this about the enabler role.

Basically, the traitor is still alive. Mantis ensured the traitor lived as long as she did.

[Magicziggy]

This enabler role might take a bit of interpretation. My analysis was a bit hurried.

[Magicziggy]

Here's another one:

"You are the Cop enabler. You have no special power other than the vote. As long as you are alive, then the cop can inspect. You win with the town, and win when there are no mafia left. "

I'm now seeing that the traitor is no longer a traitor.

[charlou]

"You are the Doctor Enabler. You have no special power other than the vote. As long as you are alive, the Doctor will be as well. You might not want to tell any mafia this. You win if all the mafia are dead. I made a mistake on this, it was supposed to be the doc can protect people instead of will be alive"

Ok I found this about the enabler role.

Basically, the traitor is still alive. Mantis ensured the traitor lived as long as she did.

Okay ... if that's the case, the traitor may still be alive, but with the death of the enabler is no longer an active traitor?

[charlou]

... crosspost .. looks like it MZ ...

[Magicziggy]

So Mantis's demise is indeed a win for town. I think that needed clearing up.

[Magicziggy]

Would a role claim for traitor be helpful? A cleared vanilla innocent if uncontested.

[Magicziggy]

Hmm..

"mantisdreamz was Iris Crowe and was a traitorous enabler"

Note that is says traitorous enabler, not traitor enabler.
Any additional interpretation of Mantis' role is welcomed and implications for what remains.

[mononoke]

I think he was working for scum in some way or the other.

[Magicziggy]

I think he was working for scum in some way or the other.

There are different interpretations.
Here's mine:
Mantis was an enabler first and foremost. The simplest explanation is that she enabled the traitor. Now gone, the traitor is vanilla town.

Mono, I find your "interpretation" a little vague.

[mononoke]

I think he was working for scum in some way or the other.

There are different interpretations.
Here's mine:
Mantis was an enabler first and foremost. The simplest explanation is that she enabled the traitor. Now gone, the traitor is vanilla town.

Mono, I find your "interpretation" a little vague.

He was treacherous, therefore not pro town. That's most apparent thing for me. Who he enabled is up in the air, but my guess is that he was enabling some scum role.

I was visited by a prostitute last night, so mantis didn't enable that person at the least