Carnivale Game Thread

[higgs2]

I'm guessing charlous got her post restrictions from someone's night 0 move. I don't think they say anything about her role or alignment. I think the person who selected her probably didn't know them.
I'd love to vote ghat at this point but on the off chance he's got something weird connected with being lynched I'll wait. I think. But it's weird and stupid to vote yourself. And scummy.
Zigmen is seeming particularly clueless.
Gib seems towny to me for a noob.
Monoke's posts seem forced, like she's looking for something to say is scummy but not finding much.
Thank god irre seems to have changed from her sarcastic raised eyebrow in a smoking jacket style she seemed to be trying last time and is trying to make some sense.
Don't know about the squid. I'm suspicious though.

[Magicziggy]

Just skim read through 8 pages.
There's a lot of noise.
Can't get back on for at least 3 hours.

vote ani

[DennyB]

How many games has Gib played?
~off to see a man about a horse~
BBL

[Feck]

Irre I agree with most of your summary but Charlou hasn't said she is a jester ,? all she has indicated is that she can't tell us why she has to post only in smilies.

[gib]

Sooooo...
Ghat tries to vote Feck for mayor
Charlou claims a posting restriction - what would she have to gain from that? - and is vigorously challenged by (among others) Gib.
Zigmen reckons Squid is being coached in appearing nooby by scum team-mates.
UT defends Charlou and asks for votes to be removed from her - Gib and Denny oblige.
Ghat self-votes for lynching - is that allowed? - seemingly in despair.
Mono decides - from thin air - that Gib is scum.

Through all the above Ani provides his usual freak-show and Feck stirs the pot from time to time.

Good morning, all. Good summary, callan.

My comments are:
1. Charlou is claiming a posting restriction (jester) AND being town. This doesn't seem right. A jester is an indie and I doubt oblivion would do something too weird. The other game when there was a jester, they turned into vanilla town the next day IIRC. I don't see an issue with lynching charlou tbh. If no scummier candidate fronts up then this is where my vote is likely going to go.
2. Zigmen's hassling of Squid pings a bit. Squid IS a noob and I think is allowed to ask noob questions in his first game, especially if his mentor is not online (and I don't think anyone should pressure him to say who it is, it's not in his interest to do so).
3. UT's defending of charlou.. I can kind of see the logic, if she is a harmless town who is cursed, but she should definitely have the pressure applied. UT do you have a better lynch candidate?
4. Ghat... WTF is with self-voting? That's just bizarre and not in town's interest (if you are town). What is with that? I'd lynch vote you but now I'm thinking you might be a bomb or a real jester. The WIFOM is strong with this one.
5. Mono, I don't see the Gib trolley tracking you are claiming, at all. Sounds more like an excuse for YOU to trolley track on Gib.

For now: vote mono

Would be nice to hear thoughts from:
higgs2
Feck
Morticia
DennyB
Ghat (as in, explain yourself, sir)
Mantisdreamz
MZ
The Curious Squid

Good summary, but Charlou is not claiming jester. As Higgs says, Charlou's silenced condition is most likely the result of someone's randomish Night0 move.

[gib]

How many games has Gib played?
~off to see a man about a horse~
BBL

I think this is about number 5.

[gib]

charlou can you tell us if you are under the effect of another players actions

or your own?

Ok so Charlou, you're saying the restriction was given to you by the Gm in the original PM?

Does it automatically end after day 1?

Is there another way the restriction can be lifted?

[Feck]

Think by the looks of it she is not allowed to say .

[gib]

It's early in the morning down south .


Denny Squid WHAAAAAAT I don't want lynching it's Google bot that who was saying that that's why I put it in quotation marks .

Feck, If you read my post you will see I was agreeing with you.
I don't think we should lynch Ghat.....today......either

You were agreeing with Feck? Then why did you say you thought Feck was a bomb/jester?

Yep being harassed by Ani can be upsetting but 'Lynch me and then you will find out I'm town!!!' on day one FFS Especially as it does tell us if Ani is scum or not

Correct. Then when we lynched Ani we could be down 2 town. Makes no sence to me. But I think your a day 1 bomb/jester or an Indie with an odd win condition. So we can wait and lynch you tomorrow.

Or were you somehow addressing gbot with those last 2 sentences?

[Feck]

@ Gib Seems he was ....had me confused as well

[Animavore]

you guys

[gib]

Think by the looks of it she is not allowed to say .

suggest Charlou uses this smiley if she is asked a question she's not allowed to answer:

[The Curious Squid]

@ Gib Seems he was ....had me confused as well

I read it as him talking about Ghat.

[Feck]

Think by the looks of it she is not allowed to say .

suggest Charlou uses this smiley if she is asked a question she's not allowed to answer:

You can suggest a ball gag to Charlou I'm not she knows where I live !

[Azathoth]

you guys

This is the shit I'm talking about ani. It doesn't help town it just makes you look like a cock and muddies the thread. I bet scum love you even when you are town