Cannibal Holocaust Game Thread

[irretating]

gib well if DP and feck are who they say they are, then its you or mantis as the final scum. Mantis views as town, apparently.

LOL higgs, I cant wait to hear what you have to say once the game is over!

[Don't Panic]

Oh,irre, if you keep saying tizzy it doesn't mean it is one.

I have to admit that I'm surprised to see a seer at all. My undertanding is that in no reveal games there is no reveal, including a seer, until players have died and some mechanism shows their alignment. Like this zombie game a while back elsewhere, I didn't play but that's how it worked. No seer. Of course, feck would know this being a p. experienced player so the seer bluff might not be a bad one since he knows that this style of game does not have a seer. After all, it worked for Zigmen a couple of days ago.

It's either that, gibs is scum, or mantis is don. assuming irre is scum of course which I do. But lynch town today and it's over. I you get rid of town (irre) and dp gets a shot at scum then there's still a chance for us to win the game. In fact, given that scenario, dp could hit town and we'd still have a shot at it.

I think this is the same as what I said:

The game isn't over even if we make one mistake, 3 possible scum(assuming feck is telling truth and Mantis isn't Don) lynch one, night kill one, scum night kill one town, game goes into tomorrow with two town and one possible scum. Town win.

[irretating]

Okay, and it goes without saying but here I am saying it that if feck is bluffing seer he is scum. I think he "cleared" mantis just to make it seem real, of course he knew her alignment as scum. She probably is town. She's sure acted like it p. consistently.

Town: would you like extra WIFOM with your irre meal?! Higgs is on a roll

[higgs2]

Don't count on DP being able to hit scum, I'm not sure of the order of kills now that I think of it. We need to kill scum. Mantis, what about my postng would lead you to believe that I would be scummier than irre? I think she has acted very odd and scummy, and all she can say is "pingP.

[Mantisdreamz]

hmmm

[Feck]

Up to you but I think Irre . I think lynch Irre and that leaves you Gibs or higgs
Irre seems to have freaked at being voted for ,while all the time accusing Higgs of getting upset !

we have night chat which will be handy ! and I get a view (if I survive ) your kill should take place before the scum NK ,as the Nk is normally the last in the round ,you might what to check that with ghat ,

It would be nice to lynch the scum don (if there is ?) because then we could be sure of Mantis

I think this Irre/Higgs thing is a ploy

[Mantisdreamz]

Something is strange here.

Irre is implying that gib is scum.
Higgs is implying gib is scum.

If either of them are his team mate, would they do this?

Feck is the seer. DP's story makes sense.

Is there only one scum left?

[Mantisdreamz]

I think this Irre/Higgs thing is a ploy

I was just thinking that.

[Azathoth]

All kills happen simultaneously. If a kill order is placed it will go through

[higgs2]

Oh,irre, if you keep saying tizzy it doesn't mean it is one.

I have to admit that I'm surprised to see a seer at all. My undertanding is that in no reveal games there is no reveal, including a seer, until players have died and some mechanism shows their alignment. Like this zombie game a while back elsewhere, I didn't play but that's how it worked. No seer. Of course, feck would know this being a p. experienced player so the seer bluff might not be a bad one since he knows that this style of game does not have a seer. After all, it worked for Zigmen a couple of days ago.

It's either that, gibs is scum, or mantis is don. assuming irre is scum of course which I do. But lynch town today and it's over. I you get rid of town (irre) and dp gets a shot at scum then there's still a chance for us to win the game. In fact, given that scenario, dp could hit town and we'd still have a shot at it.

I think this is the same as what I said:

The game isn't over even if we make one mistake, 3 possible scum(assuming feck is telling truth and Mantis isn't Don) lynch one, night kill one, scum night kill one town, game goes into tomorrow with two town and one possible scum. Town win.

That's not exactly what I said, there are only 2 possible scum. But you're right I was saying that we could lynch a town and win. But then I realized that we don't know whether a scum or vig kill would go first or whether it would be randomized. Ghat sometimes randomizes stuff like that, so we could be taking a real chance.

[Don't Panic]

Something is strange here.

Irre is implying that gib is scum.
Higgs is implying gib is scum.

If either of them are his team mate, would they do this?

Feck is the seer. DP's story makes sense.

Is there only one scum left?

If either of them is his team-mate then they would both do it, bussing him makes them look good tomorrow.

[Mantisdreamz]

Hm, risky though.


If Irre or higgs aren't making a ploy. And they are not on a team together - than, it is either one of them and gib as their partner.

We could just lynch gib, if we think that higgs and Irre aren't playing us.

[Don't Panic]

Oh,irre, if you keep saying tizzy it doesn't mean it is one.

I have to admit that I'm surprised to see a seer at all. My undertanding is that in no reveal games there is no reveal, including a seer, until players have died and some mechanism shows their alignment. Like this zombie game a while back elsewhere, I didn't play but that's how it worked. No seer. Of course, feck would know this being a p. experienced player so the seer bluff might not be a bad one since he knows that this style of game does not have a seer. After all, it worked for Zigmen a couple of days ago.

It's either that, gibs is scum, or mantis is don. assuming irre is scum of course which I do. But lynch town today and it's over. I you get rid of town (irre) and dp gets a shot at scum then there's still a chance for us to win the game. In fact, given that scenario, dp could hit town and we'd still have a shot at it.

I think this is the same as what I said:

The game isn't over even if we make one mistake, 3 possible scum(assuming feck is telling truth and Mantis isn't Don) lynch one, night kill one, scum night kill one town, game goes into tomorrow with two town and one possible scum. Town win.

That's not exactly what I said, there are only 2 possible scum. But you're right I was saying that we could lynch a town and win. But then I realized that we don't know whether a scum or vig kill would go first or whether it would be randomized. Ghat sometimes randomizes stuff like that, so we could be taking a real chance.

All kills happen simultaneously. If a kill order is placed it will go through

That eliminates that potential problem, so long as Feck is telling the truth we can't really lose.

[Don't Panic]

Hm, risky though.


If Irre or higgs aren't making a ploy. And they are not on a team together - than, it is either one of them and gib as their partner.

We could just lynch gib, if we think that higgs and Irre aren't playing us.

And if you are the Don, you just bussed him, don't ya just love mafia.

[Feck]

Something is strange here.

Irre is implying that gib is scum.
Higgs is implying gib is scum.

If either of them are his team mate, would they do this?

Feck is the seer. DP's story makes sense.

Is there only one scum left?

Because If we lynch Irre or higgs
the other one will tell us they were right all along and that Gib is the other scum (if we lynch the don ,if we don't lynch the don then they will say Gib or Mantis could be the scum ) or in fact they could just spend the next few hours spreading Wifom that DP and/or Feck is lying .