Tarot Mafia: Days 1 - 7 archive

[Mantisdreamz]

No scum would have to mention it as well, otherwise they risk looking guilty as hell tomorrow if someone else come out as blocked.

But that's what I mean - if a scum blocked him - as town... then no, scum wouldn't come out and say that on the thread. That's why saying something like that, as a townie - is safe.

But - if he were scum and said that he was blocked... then a town person could come out and say that yea, they blocked him. And then attention would be drawn to him... and questions would be asked. Not a safe thing to say if he was scum.

[Uselesstwit]

Right but if tomorrow someone said they were blocked and someone came out and said "oh, you get notified of that, so why didn't ani say anything?" and then he's screwed. Town should come out and say if they were blocked or not, scum are kind of trapped once they are notified.

[Mantisdreamz]

Right but if tomorrow someone said they were blocked and someone came out and said "oh, you get notified of that, so why didn't ani say anything?" and then he's screwed. Town should come out and say if they were blocked or not, scum are kind of trapped once they are notified.

Oh, I see. Yea, you've got a point.

Maybe that doesn't clear him then.

But - UT, who are your suspects?

[Morticia]

I thought Ani did say he was blocked

[oblivion]

Current vote count:

sifaka - 5
Normal - 2
Zigmen - 1
Uselesstwit - 1

Nightfall is 6.5 hours from the time of this post.

[Uselesstwit]

I'll just go down the list from today Op.

FECK Looked protown yesterday but the drive by vote on zigmen has me worried. Along with the leaving the vote on mono even though he was here is raising some flags, but he always reads a bit scummy to me.
Gallstones probably town, I just don't see two town going thru that act yesterday and if there is only one scum in the group it's zigmen
higgs2 this seems to be her new town game, but it's less focused than I'm used to seeing.
Charlou a little quieter than normal and didn't vote yesterday. As the mayor I'm really hoping she's been viewed and since we haven't heard anything I'm thinking of leaving her alone for now.
Zigmen either town or very clever scum. He really didn't give anything away yesterday, just pulled knowledge from gallstones so it's hard to tell when he knew something. Spent part of today bragging about another game.
irretating looks pretty good. She's paying attention and putting some pressure on people.
sifaka looks exactly like she did when her, feck and mort. won as a scum team. Definitely not protown is the nicest thing I can say about her this game.
Mantisdreamz I've never been able to read you well. Some posts look innocent others look not so much.
Animavore this still isn't his town game.
uselesstwit
Normal admits to being able to pull his vote off of mono but doesn't. Classic scum hiding tell, but his outing does look believable. Of course if he were scum he might have a good player feeding him that to shake off his behavior yesterday.
morticia I'm thinking town. This reminds me strongly of her last game.

[Uselesstwit]

I thought Ani did say he was blocked

He did, I was explaining why he might have had to mention it if he was scum.

[irretating]

I'll just go down the list from today Op.

FECK Looked protown yesterday but the drive by vote on zigmen has me worried. Along with the leaving the vote on mono even though he was here is raising some flags, but he always reads a bit scummy to me.
Gallstones probably town, I just don't see two town going thru that act yesterday and if there is only one scum in the group it's zigmen
higgs2 this seems to be her new town game, but it's less focused than I'm used to seeing.
Charlou a little quieter than normal and didn't vote yesterday. As the mayor I'm really hoping she's been viewed and since we haven't heard anything I'm thinking of leaving her alone for now.
Zigmen either town or very clever scum. He really didn't give anything away yesterday, just pulled knowledge from gallstones so it's hard to tell when he knew something. Spent part of today bragging about another game.
irretating looks pretty good. She's paying attention and putting some pressure on people.
sifaka looks exactly like she did when her, feck and mort. won as a scum team. Definitely not protown is the nicest thing I can say about her this game.
Mantisdreamz I've never been able to read you well. Some posts look innocent others look not so much.
Animavore this still isn't his town game.
uselesstwit
Normal admits to being able to pull his vote off of mono but doesn't. Classic scum hiding tell, but his outing does look believable. Of course if he were scum he might have a good player feeding him that to shake off his behavior yesterday.
morticia I'm thinking town. This reminds me strongly of her last game.

Interesting.. but who would you gun for, and who would you name as the likely scum team?

[Morticia]

I thought Ani did say he was blocked

He did, I was explaining why he might have had to mention it if he was scum.

Oh ok... I have will list my observations/suspicions as well.

Ani - says he is posting only what's relevant but were the posts really relevant?
Feck- has been incredibly quiet and then showed up just to vote and did not answer any questions asked to him.
Sifaka - what one post in two days?
Normal - I am getting more convinced his outing was for real
Charlou - Is mayor and where is she? She was here for about an hour around daybreak and was active then disappeared.
Gallstones - I'm pretty sure she was cleared yesterday
Zigmen - this is my first game with him, unsure how to read him yet. I would have to base an opinion on everyone elses.
Higgs2 - appears clear to me

UT, Mantis and Irretating - I'm not sure of, although nothing has stood out as suspicious.

[Uselesstwit]

I'll just go down the list from today Op.

FECK Looked protown yesterday but the drive by vote on zigmen has me worried. Along with the leaving the vote on mono even though he was here is raising some flags, but he always reads a bit scummy to me.
Gallstones probably town, I just don't see two town going thru that act yesterday and if there is only one scum in the group it's zigmen
higgs2 this seems to be her new town game, but it's less focused than I'm used to seeing.
Charlou a little quieter than normal and didn't vote yesterday. As the mayor I'm really hoping she's been viewed and since we haven't heard anything I'm thinking of leaving her alone for now.
Zigmen either town or very clever scum. He really didn't give anything away yesterday, just pulled knowledge from gallstones so it's hard to tell when he knew something. Spent part of today bragging about another game.
irretating looks pretty good. She's paying attention and putting some pressure on people.
sifaka looks exactly like she did when her, feck and mort. won as a scum team. Definitely not protown is the nicest thing I can say about her this game.
Mantisdreamz I've never been able to read you well. Some posts look innocent others look not so much.
Animavore this still isn't his town game.
uselesstwit
Normal admits to being able to pull his vote off of mono but doesn't. Classic scum hiding tell, but his outing does look believable. Of course if he were scum he might have a good player feeding him that to shake off his behavior yesterday.
morticia I'm thinking town. This reminds me strongly of her last game.

Interesting.. but who would you gun for, and who would you name as the likely scum team?

I'm not gunning for anyone right now, these games usually get interesting in a couple of hours so I want to see what happens then.

Most likely scum for me are:
Sifaka
ani
feck
charlou.

[charlou]

Mantis, you haven't explained your fos on me?

Charlou - Is mayor and where is she? She was here for about an hour around daybreak and was active then disappeared.

Would have been less than an hour .. I was catching up on some mod forum stuff and read a bit of this thread then had RL things to do.


There are several players who oddly look either very innocent or very scummy, depending on how you look at the scenario possibilities. I'm agreeing more with higgs in-so-far as we can't take anything for granted. Interesting to learn that other players have limited sprinkles too .. I'm inclined to believe Normal about his.

There are three players who stand out to me as not playing protown games, mainly due to little to no input .. Feck, Ani and sifaka .. for now I'm going to vote sifaka

[Morticia]

Mantis, you haven't explained your fos on me?

Charlou - Is mayor and where is she? She was here for about an hour around daybreak and was active then disappeared.

Would have been less than an hour .. I was catching up on some mod forum stuff and read a bit of this thread then had RL things to do.


There are several players who oddly look either very innocent or very scummy, depending on how you look at the scenario possibilities. I'm agreeing more with higgs in-so-far as we can't take anything for granted. Interesting to learn that other players have limited sprinkles too .. I'm inclined to believe Normal about his.

There are three players who stand out to me as not playing protown games, mainly due to little to no input .. Feck, Ani and sifaka .. for now I'm going to vote sifaka

Are you saying you have sprinkles too?

[charlou]

Are you saying you have sprinkles too?

I'm curious about what they are ... though at this point I hope it's not a vig thing as I'm not sure who I'd go for

[charlou]

There are three players who stand out to me as not playing protown games, mainly due to little to no input .. Feck, Ani and sifaka .. for now I'm going to vote sifaka

Actually, reading back through again I see that Feck has made a bit more contribution than I noticed first time I scanned through.

[charlou]

Also, there's something niggling me with the Ani/sifaka thing .. the way he voted for her .. then encouraged us to leap on ... I'm wondering if he's either running with the 'sifaka's not posting so let's lynch her' because it's easy, or if the two of them have decided she'd be a good sacrifice in order for him to look pro town.