Tarot Mafia: Days 1 - 7 archive

[Mantisdreamz]

Gallstones and Zigmen ... big question marks there ... higgs raised a good point about the PM being pretty standard (I mentioned it earlier in the thread, but didn't make the connection that it might point to their guilt)

On the other hand, higgs accusation might be designed to muddy the water and create doubt that is useful for scum.

I think all in all - that situation between Zig & Gall has left me thinking that they are both cleared.

Gall incorporated to what Zig was looking for... and I think that Zig was just slightly too aggressive to be scum.

[charlou]

Gallstones and Zigmen ... big question marks there ... higgs raised a good point about the PM being pretty standard (I mentioned it earlier in the thread, but didn't make the connection that it might point to their guilt)

On the other hand, higgs accusation might be designed to muddy the water and create doubt that is useful for scum.

I think all in all - that situation between Zig & Gall has left me thinking that they are both cleared.

Gall incorporated to what Zig was looking for... and I think that Zig was just slightly too aggressive to be scum.

Yep, that was my impression as it played out .. Still, the doubt is there now.

What do you think about higgs comments on it? She seems to be very keen for us to agree with her theory.

[Mantisdreamz]

Yep, that was my impression as it played out .. Still, the doubt is there now.

What do you think about higgs comments on it? She seems to be very keen for us to agree with her theory.

Mm, I didn't really see her as keen. I thought that she was pointing out that it could be an option for Zig & Gall to be up to no good. Or just Zig, maybe.

I didn't really see it as much at the time.... but, as you said - it could have been a post to 'muddy the waters' about their situation.

Or... perhaps, you are trying to make higgs look suspicious?


I didn't vote yesterday, on account of not knowing who to go for, without enough time.... but, Charlou - why didn't you vote?

[irretating]

Charlou didn't vote? Who else? mantis, sifaka? Did feck vote?

[Mantisdreamz]

Charlou didn't vote? Who else? mantis, sifaka? Did feck vote?

Yea, Feck was the first to vote for Mononoke.

Sifaka didn't, neither did Charlou.

And I left with no vote either.

[charlou]

Yep, that was my impression as it played out .. Still, the doubt is there now.

What do you think about higgs comments on it? She seems to be very keen for us to agree with her theory.

Mm, I didn't really see her as keen. I thought that she was pointing out that it could be an option for Zig & Gall to be up to no good. Or just Zig, maybe.

I didn't really see it as much at the time.... but, as you said - it could have been a post to 'muddy the waters' about their situation.

Or... perhaps, you are trying to make higgs look suspicious?


I didn't vote yesterday, on account of not knowing who to go for, without enough time.... but, Charlou - why didn't you vote?

I didn't know who to vote for either. I was planning to vote for sifaka, simply for posting so little because I've noticed that's what she's like when she's scum .. but the ratskep thing made me hold off.

I'm not making higgs looks suspicious .. I think she's doing a good job of that on her own with her posting style .. but that may be my perception, granted.

[charlou]

Charlou didn't vote? Who else? mantis, sifaka? Did feck vote?

Yea, Feck was the first to vote for Mononoke.

Sifaka didn't, neither did Charlou.

And I left with no vote either.

I see you edited your post ..

I took a look at day one and from what I can tell there were 10 lynch votes from 14 players.

[Mantisdreamz]

I didn't vote yesterday, on account of not knowing who to go for, without enough time.... but, Charlou - why didn't you vote?

I didn't know who to vote for either. I was planning to vote for sifaka, simply for posting so little because I've noticed that's what she's like when she's scum .. but the ratskep thing made me hold off.

I'm not making higgs looks suspicious .. I think she's doing a good job of that on her own with her posting style .. but that may be my perception, granted.

I saw that... someone mentioned to you that sifaka might be busy. I don't remember who it was.


But - still.


I have this thing with UT & higgs where I always think they are guilty. I think it is there posting styles as well.

But - this time, UT seems to have placed his vote at a time, a little too conveniently.

Like I said before these were the votes on Mononoke: Feck, Zgmen, UT, Ghat, Mantis(pulled), Normal, Morticia


I don't think that scum would be the first ones to vote him. But UT, in 3rd position, and then Normal in 6th position. Perhaps, strategically placed? Maybe I'm being paranoid, and have my mind set on them.

But - the fact that Normal & Feck were both online at the time that Mono made his statement (which was yes, a little too late) - they still could have retracted their votes.

And higgs even made mention that their votes should be retracted... yet, nothing was done. Maybe there was not enough time. But... Normal/Feck... what was your line of thinking at this point??

[Mantisdreamz]

Charlou didn't vote? Who else? mantis, sifaka? Did feck vote?

Yea, Feck was the first to vote for Mononoke.

Sifaka didn't, neither did Charlou.

And I left with no vote either.

I see you edited your post ..

I edited it just to include the last 2 lines.

[irretating]

Hmm. Not voting can't help but look scummy. Not knowing who to vote for is not much of an excuse IMO... we all know what day 1 is like. I'm giving sifaka the benefit of the doubt (as I should; I'm the one co-modding the rebooted game with her) for now.

Feck, you have some explaining to do, methinks. I'm happy with my vote on Normal.

I think the timezone differences are having a bigger impact on this game so far.. with higgs, useless, gallstones being more absent than present. Not sure about zigmen's timezone but he was here at daybreak and didn't post.

[charlou]

Hmm. Not voting can't help but look scummy. Not knowing who to vote for is not much of an excuse IMO... we all know what day 1 is like.

Yes, we do ... and that includes the fact that it's not unusual for people not to vote on day 1. The gallstones/zigmen thing, later rehashed by mononoke and then higgs .. really left me not knowing which way to go .. and I gather from the other posts, I wasn't the only one. In the end, the more mononoke posted the more he came across as simply confused town and I did mention that a couple of times.

hmmm ... will try not to be distracted by all that, continue to take a broader look and focus on what the other players are doing. I'm just as concerned about those who lynched a town special as those who didn't know where to place a vote on day 1.

[Animavore]

Vote sifaka, for reasons explained yesterday.

Nice try whoever blocked me too. Pity there was nothing to block. The monkey has no powers.

[normal]

Someone (Normal, I think) commented on how I'd tried to distance myself from the bandwagon on gallstones. Rubbish. From all of her mafia play I've seen she hadn't done a single scummy thing, hence my question on the aggressiveness of the bandwagon.

I don't think it was me that said that. I did say something like that about Mantis, but at the moment I thought Gallstones looked a bit guilty due to what Zig had pointed out.

What do you think about higgs comments on it? She seems to be very keen for us to agree with her theory.

I think higgs just seems generally helpful, and wants to point out that it is not set in stone like some (me included) thought.

But - the fact that Normal & Feck were both online at the time that Mono made his statement (which was yes, a little too late) - they still could have retracted their votes.

And higgs even made mention that their votes should be retracted... yet, nothing was done. Maybe there was not enough time. But... Normal/Feck... what was your line of thinking at this point??

For my part I can say I saw that higgs said we should retract the votes, but I had the feeling that time was too short. I guess it's slightly possible that we could have prevented that death, but I didn't think so at the moment. I regret not unvoting now, but of course, it's too late.

As for voting, you will always see a vote from me. I use it every day, because not voting seems fishy to me.

[Feck]

I should have changed my vote I ran out of time I was checking to see who else had voted for who before I changed my vote but got beaten to the post by nightfall

[Feck]

What's will all the people not voting BTW ok some of us messed up and lynched the wrong person but not voting is anti town play .