Tarot Mafia: Days 1 - 7 archive

[higgs2]

tell me againwhy we want to lycnh monoke.

[Zigmen]

unvote

Vote Charlou

[Zigmen]

tell me againwhy we want to lycnh monoke.

I think we're all on the record as to why.

[higgs2]

As I said Not Cleared ,in fact I did say that , Maybe A seer could view or a vig could kill one of them ? I want to lynch Mono today but knowing if Scum were trying to be clever tonight would be good too

and Higgs I did mention that in my much earlier posts .

Well that maybe be true but others have said differently. For example normal just put Zig and 90% clear and Galls and 100% clear.

Can you see why I got concerned that this was becoming a "given"? I can very easily see Zig put together this routine with a scumbuddy to 'clear' them both.

[higgs2]

From raven in the peanut gallery:

<I did not put the vanilla town PM in the OP of this thread, so I am adding it here:

"You are <card name>. You win when all scum are eliminated">

So why is gallstones "cleared" and voting for me after one post?

The whole interrogation thing by Zigmen took place before Oblivion posted the vanilla town PM in the PG. Gallstones finally answered to the letter game friday 10th at 5:34 am. Oblivion posted the town PM in the peanut gallery friday 10th 6:38 am. That pretty much clears him, yes?

No. see posts above.

[higgs2]

Vote Mononoke

So you must be on the record in a coded post? letters 9, 18, and 24?

[normal]

As I said Not Cleared ,in fact I did say that , Maybe A seer could view or a vig could kill one of them ? I want to lynch Mono today but knowing if Scum were trying to be clever tonight would be good too

and Higgs I did mention that in my much earlier posts .

Well that maybe be true but others have said differently. For example normal just put Zig and 90% clear and Galls and 100% clear.

Can you see why I got concerned that this was becoming a "given"? I can very easily see Zig put together this routine with a scumbuddy to 'clear' them both.

True. I did not know the role PMs had been the same in other games, and didn't even think of that possibility. So in fear of looking like a fool later, I'll retract my percentages until we know more.

Zig and Gall would have to play a very tight game to pull that one off, though.

[Feck]

Yes I see that! and if ,as you say, it was a plan then we might have caught 2 scum ,or one or none (damn this game )

I have more to add about the numbers in a bit I Think ,have to go check BRB

[higgs2]

Vote Mononoke

do i get to hear why?

Sure. There's a couple of things.

First: the "I don't see where somebody said something" approach is a bit odd. We know you've read the thread. We know you've gone so far as to employ a text search on this thread. The thread can be read in under 10 minutes and provides every bit of information you say you can't find. Everyone else who has read the thread can find what you can't.

Second: We saw you play last game. Your deductions were solid, mostly. It's odd that you'd pull such a 180 in terms of logical analysis in such a short period.

There are other reasons as well, but those are the two major ones.

Okay, here are the reasons. Who thinks these are good reasons? Raise your hands if you do.

[normal]

Vote Mononoke

do i get to hear why?

Sure. There's a couple of things.

First: the "I don't see where somebody said something" approach is a bit odd. We know you've read the thread. We know you've gone so far as to employ a text search on this thread. The thread can be read in under 10 minutes and provides every bit of information you say you can't find. Everyone else who has read the thread can find what you can't.

Second: We saw you play last game. Your deductions were solid, mostly. It's odd that you'd pull such a 180 in terms of logical analysis in such a short period.

There are other reasons as well, but those are the two major ones.

Okay, here are the reasons. Who thinks these are good reasons? Raise your hands if you do.

I think they're ok. But what I mainly look for on the first day is any reason that is better than the reason to lynch any other player. And I think this is the best we have come up with so far.

[higgs2]

You guys might be right about monoke, I admit I have been disconnected for this first part of the game. Sine mono is way in the lynch lead, I am not going to join that bw. I am going to vote sigmen as an fos with some oomph. And gallstones, I have my eye on you too.

[higgs2]

You guys might be right about monoke, I admit I have been disconnected for this first part of the game. Sine mono is way in the lynch lead, I am not going to join that bw. I am going to vote sigmen as an fos with some oomph. And gallstones, I have my eye on you too.

I mean zigmen sorry about that typo.

[Morticia]

Wow what happened while I was sleeping. I see so much circular talk I don't even know who said what at this point. I will re-read when I get home from real life stuff later. For now, I have seen a lot of posting from Mono but nothing that makes me less suspicious.

Vote Mononoke

I would also say that while it possible that Zigmen and Gallstones were working together. Is it likely that they would go through that much work so early in the game? (asking because I don't have the experience here)

[Azathoth]

Last minute throwaway vote higgs? That pings rather hard

[mononoke]

Okay, here are the reasons. Who thinks these are good reasons? Raise your hands if you do.

I think they're ok. But what I mainly look for on the first day is any reason that is better than the reason to lynch any other player. And I think this is the best we have come up with so far.

this is going to be my last plea. Town certainly don't want to see me dead, i can do a lot more than just vote and look for scum. I don't think i've done anything incriminating, or even suspicious. Anyways, you guys can stick with your vote and find out in a matter of hours or give me another day.