Simple Mafia 3.5

[Uselesstwit]

I still like mantis and higgs but mantis going after higgs makes that a little iffy, either that or higgs is coaching her.

I'd still really like to hear from the seer. 1 or 2 cleared innocents would really make this a much easier decision.

Does anyone have a list of 3 suspects they'd like to share?

mine is

mantis
higgs

really don't have a third yet.

vote useless
Always love having the target on my back.

Do we really want our seer to out this soon in the game? If we have a seer.
Can you explain why you are so suspicious of me?
I do have a concern about mantis, we can discuss that if you wish.

Also, need to hear from the quiet ones.

We have a real opportunity here, we have not lost any specials, if we start getting scum now we can still win.

I originally voted DP, got distracted by animavore, then dropped animavor of col.

Can you all help me evaluate DP and Animavore? I'm inclined to take another look since they were my first votes.

I want the seer to out because if this is our normal 3 scum game, an innocent lynch today would put us to 4 town to 3 scum, and after the night kill it's game over.

are you unwilling to address the rest of my post to you?

Nope, was just focused on the seer part.
I'm suspicious of you for distancing yourself from the vote yesterday, and not scum hunting as much as usual.
Anything you want to add about mantis I'll be glad to hear.
DP and animavore are on my list of likely to be scum. Neither one has done anything much protown.

I am curious as to why you're focusing so much on animavore and DP. Do you have any other suspects?

[higgs2]

crossposted.

Charlou,who are your suspects and why?

Do you think the seer should out?

I don't think it's necessary as it's been obvious to me who it is since yesterday and a post from that person today has me convinced (look carefully at both days posts and it's staring you in the face) .. I'm not going to out the seer as I have no idea what rationale the seer may have for wanting to remain anonymous. That said, I agree the seer should out today for the reason Useless gave.

I suspect either you and Mantis for the late switch to col (maybe both, but unlikely), and Ani's behaviour is still under my radar ... though today he seems to be trying to be useful. A few posts by mantis today including her vote on you with flimsy reasoning has me leaning toward her at the moment.

Charlou, after a detailed look at today and yesterday, I'm thinking that animavore and maniz are good possibilities for scum. Does that sound reasonable?

[higgs2]

and yeah, if the seer has 2 scum views for example, out. THat would rock if you had that and we might able to protect you to get another view. But we've got to quite fumbling around. If you've got views of dead people or maybe just a cleared town or 2, then get another view tonight.

[charlou]

Charlou, after a detailed look at today and yesterday, I'm thinking that animavore and maniz are good possibilities for scum. Does that sound reasonable?

Well, yes, I've already said so and why.

I also think you're a good possibility. Along with your late switch to col and MagicZiggy's death after he focussed attention on you at the end of day 2, a couple of posts you made at the start of day 2 and day 3, seeming surprised that Normal and MagicZiggy had been killed, are odd to me. Why are you surprised when Mafia kill town?

[higgs2]

Charlou, after a detailed look at today and yesterday, I'm thinking that animavore and maniz are good possibilities for scum. Does that sound reasonable?

Well, yes, I've already said so and why.

I also think you're a good possibility. Along with your late switch to col and MagicZiggy's death after he focussed attention on you at the end of day 2, a couple of posts you made at the start of day 2 and day 3, seeming surprised that Normal and MagicZiggy had been killed, are odd to me. Why are you surprised when Mafia kill town?

I was surprised at normal because he was not that high profile. I don't think I was really surprised at Magic, as he was mayor and all. I have to admit that I'm always a little surprised when I get passed over by scum as I've bee hit early so many times and the one time I wasn't was when I kind of burned you all as the last scum standing.

I explained my swithc to col, take it or leave it, I was bactracking on animavore and col was the most logical place to land.

Now I'm pretty comfortable focusing on ani and mantis, trying to figureout which would be the most logical one. I'm kind of thinking animavore since I am the one who defected and got col killed.
vote animavore

[charlou]

I'm kind of thinking animavore since I am the one who defected and got col killed.
vote animavore

I don't see how that makes Ani more guilty?

higgs, pressing Useless and I on Ani and Mantis looks like you might be deflecting attention from yourself while trying to start a bandwagon on either one of them.

That said, I'm also looking closely at Ani and Mantis. I think I'll see what more they and the others have to say .. would like to hear from DP too - he's too quiet.

[higgs2]

charlou, not pressing, just doing what I think makes the most sense given the situation that we're in. By all means we could hear more from DP, either today or tomorrow, don't know what his schedule is.

Not trying to deflect attention, I have nothing to hid unless its an occasional stupidity. Any questions, I'll answer them, and try to help town find scum as much as possible. But I think my two suspects are our best bets based on the information available.

[charlou]

vote charlou That is where I guess I'll start, we have to stop lettingquiet people slip past us.

I know you unvoted me when you realised I'd posted, but if your reasoning for voting me was as you stated, why not then vote DP or Feck?


Where is Feck, by the way? He's usually more talkative .. he's been so quiet I almost forgot he's still in the game.

[charlou]

Ah, nevermind the Feck thing ..

Dunno where Feck is tonight but he was complaining about intermittent connection. Maybe his broadband went altogether?

I hope he gets back on soon.

[higgs2]

vote charlou That is where I guess I'll start, we have to stop lettingquiet people slip past us.

I know you unvoted me when you realised I'd posted, but if your reasoning for voting me was as you stated, why not then vote DP or Feck?


Where is Feck, by the way? He's usually more talkative .. he's been so quiet I almost forgot he's still in the game.

tbh i saw you looking at the thread, didn't realize you were posting, and put a vote on you to get your attention.

What about dp? I would really like to know.

[charlou]

What about dp? I would really like to know.

Has he even been on today?

[charlou]

What about dp? I would really like to know.

Has he even been on today?

Ayep, page 1 - two posts .. he mentioned mantis and the col bandwagon ...

DP, I'd really like to hear more from you.

[higgs2]

reading what zigmen posted earlier, I am beginning to think that the correct bandwagon to be on (or start) is mantis. Very interesting posts from zigmen earlier today that make a lot of sense. I'm going to go ahead and switch, because the timng of this game is such that I don't know how easily I will be on later.
unvot vote mantis

[Zigmen]

Anyone have vote count?

My vote is on Mantis right now, and I'm happy with that.

That said, part of the reason I'm on Mantis is because of the late vote-switch yesterday from Ani to Cole. But one thing i realised today: Maybe scum was not so concerned with lynching Cole as they were saving Ani . . .

So, I think that the Mantis/Higgs voteswitch from yesterday is somewhat condemning, but we should not lose site of they seem to be protecting which was Ani.

Higgs actually seems to be playing towninsh today.

So I'd entertain switching my vote to Ani or leaving it where it is.

[Zigmen]

ETA if I had to chose the scum team, I'd pick Mantis, Ani, DP.

Just for the record.