I haven't yet done my analysis, but I was thinking about the game and I know who the scum is, thank FSM.
It's Feck.
higgs and mantis, I'm heading out for a bit, but will be back with a more detailed analysis of Feck's game to make it airtight if you are not convinced. So far I only looked at Day 1. There is ample evidence there!
Colubridae voted Feck as mayor (bad idea for scum to vote scum). Feck's first post in the game:
by Feck » Sat Jun 05, 2010 5:22 am
I don't want to be Mayor ...you get killed !
Then Feck votes Normal as mayor (note: doesn't vote for a lynch - unlike him in previous games, and Colubridae was flailing remember).
Feck's next post:
by Feck » Sat Jun 05, 2010 8:48 pm
Just for the record I Am all sweet innocent and townie this time ! oh I'm not sure about Scum tells. ..you see my problem with them is The Scum have read them to..
so protesting my innocence in my first proper post ..that's a scum tell innit ?
in fact long rambling posts of any kind are scum tells ? i think it's because Scum can't stand silences (woo the guilt just ate at me the last game )
And for those who want to confuse themselves and maybe others ..The chances of anyone being or not being Scum are independent of their roles in the last game.Unless the GM say, would reshuffle the deck as it were if DP was seer again and Virphen turned out as Viggi ...oooh wouldn't that be fun
oh i've just thought of lots more reasons why this post could get me killed ......you could think I'm the Don talking too much, secure that the seer will check me out and get a false result . OR since the Mafia would love to see an innocent get lynched they are going to think that first day lynches are pretty random and bandwagon wouldn't need to be very big to lynch me .
oh lynching Colubridae must seem like a good option ....because if doesn't ask loads of questions we can assume that he is annoying the hell out of his scum team mates.....and if he does keep asking lots of questions then he is obviously trying too hard and is scum
Mafia it's great you do all this thinking then one way or another Dp gets you
(Note: he says lynching Col is a good idea BUT DOESN'T VOTE... also note him worrying about DP)
The penny dropped as I was thinking of DP being whacked the first night. I played scum with Feck last game and all game he wanted to whack DP because he fears that DP is onto him. As scum team had nothing solid to go on, Feck got his choice of victim. DP also had realised Feck's post was very scummy.
vote Feck