Simple Mafia 2 Archive

[charlou]

Though I was wrong with my first two votes due to lack of insight, I'm certain virphen is mafia.


I'm going out on a limb now and vote virphen

[Feck]

Unless you are a seer or scum EVERY argument is Wifom as I pointed out Blip voted to lynch townspeople for days in the last game but was Town .

Virphen has already pointed out my flawed 'logic' but there is no logic, we as town are trying to interpret sneaky deceitful peoples posts and votes ,that is by definition Wifom.

[higgs2]

Unless you are a seer or scum EVERY argument is Wifom as I pointed out Blip voted to lynch townspeople for days in the last game but was Town .

Virphen has already pointed out my flawed 'logic' but there is no logic, we as town are trying to interpret sneaky deceitful peoples posts and votes ,that is by definition Wifom.

I don't know, I think sometimes people, or at least I, get stuck in going round and round about something and it can lead to missing the obvious. You're right, voting for townspeople does not mean you're scum, town do it all the time and you can't fos them based on that.

[higgs2]

Okay, I'm ready to vote. I know I've been hard on some of you, but I had a suspicion and I've been trying to verify it.

Twinkle, it was virphen's comment, not your innocence that I have such a problem with. Who would know you're almost surely cleared? Scum
Feck, you actually might be scum but I'm much less sure of that.
Charlou has convinced me of Useless probable innocence. I'm also following her lead on virphen's guilt, as she seems to be able to see both more clearly than I do.
I have a feeling virphen lynch voted me first thing because he knew I was on to that silliness about a pnut gallery comment clearing someone 99%. Also, it's a great scum move to put the first vote on someone, I've seen scum use that move all the way to end game and win almost singlehandedly.

vote virphen

Guys, lynch me if you want, but it would really suck to be on day four with 2 scum running around. If you don't believe me, I think you should at least listen to Charlou.

[irretating]

Why listen to charlou? Interesting that charlou didn't listen to magicziggy's FOS on higgs2 before he was lynched. No one can say he wasn't pro-town. Charlou is not listening to me, either.

[higgs2]

I don't know. Think about it.

MacZiggy was acting like scum. We had no choice, it was a bummer.

Just re-read the threads, and think about it.

Okay, I'm ready to vote. I know I've been hard on some of you, but I had a suspicion and I've been trying to verify it.

Twinkle, it was virphen's comment, not your innocence that I have such a problem with. Who would know you're almost surely cleared? Scum
Feck, you actually might be scum but I'm much less sure of that.
Charlou has convinced me of Useless probable innocence. I'm also following her lead on virphen's guilt, as she seems to be able to see both more clearly than I do.
I have a feeling virphen lynch voted me first thing because he knew I was on to that silliness about a pnut gallery comment clearing someone 99%. Also, it's a great scum move to put the first vote on someone, I've seen scum use that move all the way to end game and win almost singlehandedly.

vote virphen

Guys, lynch me if you want, but it would really suck to be on day four with 2 scum running around. If you don't believe me, I think you should at least listen to Charlou.

[irretating]

you were more scummy than magicziggy yesterday.. you racked up a number of FoS's

[higgs2]

you were more scummy than magicziggy yesterday.. you racked up a number of FoS's

I got a few revenge fos's lol. Everyone gets fos's, if they talk. You've gotten some too. I'm not a fabulous mafia player but I know that virphen is scum.

Look at now. Look at the evidence against virphen. Read the last days. He's scum. He was using you to look like town. I'm sure now that there was no coordination.

[irretating]

you were more scummy than magicziggy yesterday.. you racked up a number of FoS's

I got a few revenge fos's lol. Everyone gets fos's, if they talk. You've gotten some too. I'm not a fabulous mafia player but I know that virphen is scum.

Look at now. Look at the evidence against virphen. Read the last days. He's scum. He was using you to look like town. I'm sure now that there was no coordination.

Make a case against him, ignoring his statement about my innocence. Then I'll think about it.

In the meantime, FoS charlou

[charlou]

you were more scummy than magicziggy yesterday.. you racked up a number of FoS's

I got a few revenge fos's lol. Everyone gets fos's, if they talk. You've gotten some too. I'm not a fabulous mafia player but I know that virphen is scum.

Look at now. Look at the evidence against virphen. Read the last days. He's scum. He was using you to look like town. I'm sure now that there was no coordination.

Make a case against him, ignoring his statement about my innocence. Then I'll think about it.

The reason he gave for not responding to my questions, then going on to continue not responding to my questions ...

Also, your corroboration of his story about why he didn't respond means nothing if the too of you are in this together.

[higgs2]

you were more scummy than magicziggy yesterday.. you racked up a number of FoS's

I got a few revenge fos's lol. Everyone gets fos's, if they talk. You've gotten some too. I'm not a fabulous mafia player but I know that virphen is scum.

Look at now. Look at the evidence against virphen. Read the last days. He's scum. He was using you to look like town. I'm sure now that there was no coordination.

Make a case against him, ignoring his statement about my innocence. Then I'll think about it.

The reason he gave for not responding to my questions, then going on to continue not responding to my questions ...

Also, your corroboration of his story about why he didn't respond means nothing if the too of you are in this together.

Okay I take the part back about there being no coordination. It's possible.

What is the deal with verphin that everyone is afraid to vote for him? Do they think he's some sort of mafia god? Sheesh. It is so obvious now. And I love the way he just disappears when any inconvenient questions are being asked. Not only stupid, bad mafia players are scum! It's random! (ranty part not against you charlou. sorry, frustrated)

[higgs2]

Unless you are a seer or scum EVERY argument is Wifom as I pointed out Blip voted to lynch townspeople for days in the last game but was Town .

Virphen has already pointed out my flawed 'logic' but there is no logic, we as town are trying to interpret sneaky deceitful peoples posts and votes ,that is by definition Wifom.

Seers only get information one night at a time. Scum know everyone's alignment immediately. THink about it.

[Mantisdreamz]

you were more scummy than magicziggy yesterday.. you racked up a number of FoS's

I got a few revenge fos's lol. Everyone gets fos's, if they talk. You've gotten some too. I'm not a fabulous mafia player but I know that virphen is scum.

Look at now. Look at the evidence against virphen. Read the last days. He's scum. He was using you to look like town. I'm sure now that there was no coordination.

Why do you say he is scum though? Not that I am against this idea... but, I am curious as to what your reasons are. Just because he stated that he thought Twinkie was innocent?

[Mantisdreamz]

Though I was wrong with my first two votes due to lack of insight, I'm certain virphen is mafia.


I'm going out on a limb now and vote virphen

I should have addressed my last post to you as well. How are you certain?

[irretating]

Interesting. I've just been re-reading the game threads. What do you know... it was virphen who first cast suspicion (rightly) over higgs2 and charlou, and wow now they are voting for him.

Here's his post here

Charlou didn't respond to virphen's post initially, instead wrapping up the (wrong) case against magicziggy. Higgs2 did not question him about his 'twinkie is almost certainly innocent' statement, either. Nor did either of them respond to his FoS of them.

In fact, I went on to FoS both higgs2 and charlou here

uselesstwit said alarm bells were ringing about higgs2, as well here

Here's what higgs2 said about me here

I'd tend to think you're a good deal cleared just on the basis of coming to the game late, usually scum roles aren't handed out in those situations.

It is only when ghat (town doctor, deceased) asked why virphen would think I was cleared, that higgs2 and charlou jump on it and cling to it for dear mercy. At this point Feck votes to lynch higgs2.


My current estimation is that scum are: higgs2 and uselesstwit, or charlou and normal

I feel it's more likely that higgs2 is scum, because she is playing such a different game, a noisy scum flail-y game.