Moderator: Mafia Mods
Excellent. That means she can protect herself and one of the others again. Or was it Feck and Lion, with her bluffing ? Maybe it was her and Lion, not Feck. Or the other way around.DP wrote:Oh and I'm pretty certain that the same players can be protected over subsequent nights, someone(Twinkle/Oblivion) posted it here at some stage.
Mafia is a game where the small numbers of bad guys is compensated for by their ability to coordinate and communicate. I've NEVER seen a mafia game where the bad guys don't know who each other is and have the ability to PM or set up their own writeboard for communication. Otherwise, you'd have bad guys voting for each other accidentally for lynching and killing each other at night.Redial wrote:actually i don't even know the people on my scum team...believe it or not....i just randomly picked them because i knew their names
Well, maybe not completely, but I think it would be at least 90% certain I am in the clear if Meph is scum. I think it would be strange if the mason group was 50% scum, but then again, I thought it was strange that even one was scum until I was shown the wiki page about mason/neighbour groups.J.A.Poisson wrote:Durro, your analysis is p good, and I agree we should focus on blip and mantis once redial and meph / normal are out of the way.
Couple of things.... in the places where I normally play, I wouldn't be so fast to clear any of us for lynching RA if I were you... here seems a bit, ahem, special, in that regard, though.
Also, Durro referred to it obliquely, but if Lion kills meph tonight and he is scum, don't fall into the trap of thinking that clears Normal, everyone.
Let us think the unthinkable, let us do the undoable, let us prepare to grapple with the ineffable itself, and see if we may not eff it after all.
-Douglas AdamsNot true, I have voted every day. Finger pointing with flawed information? Very scummy tactic DP.DP wrote:The only vote Ghat has cast since his reincarnation was to vote for Sifaka(yes, I know I did too.) right after Meph broke the tie between Sif and Redial, since we now know redial is scum, does that tell us anything?
Code: Select all
// Replaces with spaces the braces in cases where braces in places cause stasis
$str = str_replace(array("\{","\}")," ",$str);So redial is saying he's scum but doew not know his team mates?Durro wrote:Mafia is a game where the small numbers of bad guys is compensated for by their ability to coordinate and communicate. I've NEVER seen a mafia game where the bad guys don't know who each other is and have the ability to PM or set up their own writeboard for communication. Otherwise, you'd have bad guys voting for each other accidentally for lynching and killing each other at night.Redial wrote:actually i don't even know the people on my scum team...believe it or not....i just randomly picked them because i knew their names
Given that the TEAM of bad guys has to choose ONE person to whack, there simply HAS to be coordination to choose that bad person.
Nice try, but I'm not swallowing it.
But I am going to bed.
Yeah, I'd say it would be about that. If he is scum there will certainly be better places to look than you, I'm just mentioning it in case it gets to a 2v1 end game with you in it, and someone thinks you are 100% clear because of it.Normal wrote: Well, maybe not completely, but I think it would be at least 90% certain I am in the clear if Meph is scum. I think it would be strange if the mason group was 50% scum, but then again, I thought it was strange that even one was scum until I was shown the wiki page about mason/neighbour groups.
Yes. It's called lying.higgs2 wrote: So redial is saying he's scum but doew not know his team mates?
Ah, yes, of course. I think we shall be able to root out the baddies before that timeJ.A.Poisson wrote:Yeah, I'd say it would be about that. If he is scum there will certainly be better places to look than you, I'm just mentioning it in case it gets to a 2v1 end game with you in it, and someone thinks you are 100% clear because of it.Normal wrote: Well, maybe not completely, but I think it would be at least 90% certain I am in the clear if Meph is scum. I think it would be strange if the mason group was 50% scum, but then again, I thought it was strange that even one was scum until I was shown the wiki page about mason/neighbour groups.
Let us think the unthinkable, let us do the undoable, let us prepare to grapple with the ineffable itself, and see if we may not eff it after all.
-Douglas Adamsok i just read my 17 unopened emails, and read the write board, I KNOW WHO THEY ARE NOW!!J.A.Poisson wrote:Yes. It's called lying.higgs2 wrote: So redial is saying he's scum but doew not know his team mates?
lol, I don't want you on my team in any gameRedial wrote:ok i just read my 17 unopened emails, and read the write board, I KNOW WHO THEY ARE NOW!!J.A.Poisson wrote:Yes. It's called lying.higgs2 wrote: So redial is saying he's scum but doew not know his team mates?
Let us think the unthinkable, let us do the undoable, let us prepare to grapple with the ineffable itself, and see if we may not eff it after all.
-Douglas AdamsProve it.Redial wrote:ok i just read my 17 unopened emails, and read the write board, I KNOW WHO THEY ARE NOW!!J.A.Poisson wrote:Yes. It's called lying.higgs2 wrote: So redial is saying he's scum but doew not know his team mates?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests
