LOLCAT Mafia Game Thread

[Animavore]

Here's the short list with the people we are almost certain or certain are innocent (of course any of the self-claimed innocents could be lying and I think Feck is the only person innocent without a shadow of doubt) and Redial removed.

1. Normal
3. DP
5. Blip
11. Twinkie
14. higgs2
16. MantisDreamz
18. Durro
19. Mephistopheles
20. Animavore
21. Tigger

Out of the list one of either Normal or Meph are guilty. That's presuming JA's information is accurate (or even assuming he is innocent although I've no reason to doubt him).

So we have as shortlist of 10 people. Of the ten I'm not even sure if Tigger is supposed to be there. Maybe Oblivion made a mistake?
Of the ten I think it's best to look back on there posts and try pick out who is the most inconsistent or who is throwing out all types of red-herrings and smokescreens.

[J.A.Poisson]

is there a place where I can read all of the rules and what the likely characters are ?

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?tit ... gory:Roles

[Animavore]

Didn't read what Feck said about the list properly.
Here's the people I removed from suspicion.

Feck - Has proven himself.
Lion IRC - Was reluctant to remove him from the list. No reason to believe him.
Twinkie - Most likely telling the truth. Remember the scum went for Owth last night? So it's likely they weren't sure which of the three outed, special innocents was being protected and so went for a more guaranteed kill.
JA Poisson - JA knew he was being checked last night and thought Feck was the one checking him but it turned out it wasn't Feck so it was likely it was the fishnet stocking killer.

[Blip]

Ani, I believe that number 21, Tigger, was a no-show and was replaced by Ghatanothoa after his demise?

Oh, and vote Redial.

[Animavore]

So that just leaves us with 9 left. The only question is how much scum are there? It's usually between 4 and 6 so there is anything between 2 and 4 left. I would bank on there being 6 even 7 to be honest. Usually the creator of the game has one third scum and the rest town. It could be 6 scum with one serial killer.

[Animavore]

Meaning of the 9 roughly half are scum.

[Animavore]

Oops. Forgot to move Twink from the list. So with her and Tig gone there are only 8 on the short list for consideration.

1. Normal
3. DP
5. Blip
14. higgs2
16. MantisDreamz
18. Durro
19. Mephistopheles
20. Animavore

[J.A.Poisson]

So that just leaves us with 9 left. The only question is how much scum are there? It's usually between 4 and 6 so there is anything between 2 and 4 left. I would bank on there being 6 even 7 to be honest. Usually the creator of the game has one third scum and the rest town. It could be 6 scum with one serial killer.

A game this size wouldn't normally have more than 5.

[higgs2]

Wait. What? I don't quite see the chain of reasoning in that. I'm beginning to wonder if you really are hobo cat...

Is it unclear to anyone else, or is this scumflail?

It's a serious question, it's hard to tell around here sometimes.

Scumflail. He's looked scummy for the start. Voting to get backat others, pulling the "offended you don't trust me act" when fos'd or challenged in any way. Big supporter of lynching sifaka if I remember.

[Blip]

Oops. Forgot to move Twink from the list. So with her and Tig gone there are only 8 on the short list for consideration.

1. Normal
3. DP
5. Blip
14. higgs2
16. MantisDreamz
18. Durro
19. Mephistopheles
20. Animavore

Has Ghatanothoa Mk2 been cleared as definitely innocent, Ani? This isn't to suggest I have reason to suspect him but he's still playing (in the Tigger role at number 21), isn't he?

[higgs2]

Wait. What? I don't quite see the chain of reasoning in that. I'm beginning to wonder if you really are hobo cat...

Is it unclear to anyone else, or is this scumflail?

It's a serious question, it's hard to tell around here sometimes.

Scumflail. He's looked scummy for the start. Voting to get backat others, pulling the "offended you don't trust me act" when fos'd or challenged in any way. Big supporter of lynching sifaka if I remember.

Sorry. I meant to be talking about durro, got mixed up.

Meph. I'm guessing scum, not playing a town game, playing a "meph" game.

[Animavore]

So that just leaves us with 9 left. The only question is how much scum are there? It's usually between 4 and 6 so there is anything between 2 and 4 left. I would bank on there being 6 even 7 to be honest. Usually the creator of the game has one third scum and the rest town. It could be 6 scum with one serial killer.

A game this size wouldn't normally have more than 5.

Well let's say there are 4 or 5 there are still 2 or 3 left and one serial killer with a penchant for dressing people as whores.

Has Ghatanothoa Mk2 been cleared as definitely innocent, Ani? This isn't to suggest I have reason to suspect him but he's still playing (in the Tigger role at number 21), isn't he?

Is he I is confused now. Is Ghat reincarnated as Tig? Is that what you mean?

[higgs2]

Didn't read what Feck said about the list properly.
Here's the people I removed from suspicion.

Feck - Has proven himself.
Lion IRC - Was reluctant to remove him from the list. No reason to believe him.
Twinkie - Most likely telling the truth. Remember the scum went for Owth last night? So it's likely they weren't sure which of the three outed, special innocents was being protected and so went for a more guaranteed kill.
JA Poisson - JA knew he was being checked last night and thought Feck was the one checking him but it turned out it wasn't Feck so it was likely it was the fishnet stocking killer.

The fishnet stocking killer is likely a prostitute. I was visited, but I have no special powers so it was a pleasant interlude, that's all.

I'm Rasta Cat by the way. And I'm playing Bob Marley on my ipod right now.

[Animavore]

Wait. What? I don't quite see the chain of reasoning in that. I'm beginning to wonder if you really are hobo cat...

Is it unclear to anyone else, or is this scumflail?

It's a serious question, it's hard to tell around here sometimes.

Scumflail. He's looked scummy for the start. Voting to get backat others, pulling the "offended you don't trust me act" when fos'd or challenged in any way. Big supporter of lynching sifaka if I remember.

Sorry. I meant to be talking about durro, got mixed up.

Meph. I'm guessing scum, not playing a town game, playing a "meph" game.

After reading back through the first round I agree. He's all over the place and it looks like he's just having a laugh enjoying himself knowing he has poweh.

[Blip]

Has Ghatanothoa Mk2 been cleared as definitely innocent, Ani? This isn't to suggest I have reason to suspect him but he's still playing (in the Tigger role at number 21), isn't he?

Is he I is confused now. Is Ghat reincarnated as Tig? Is that what you mean?

Yes. Ghat took over Tigger's role at number 21, whatever that may be.