Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post Reply

Do you choose/craft your thoughts before you have them?

Yes.
1
6%
Almost always.
1
6%
Most of the time.
0
No votes
Frequently.
0
No votes
Pretty often.
0
No votes
About half the time.
0
No votes
Sometimes.
3
17%
Occasionally.
1
6%
Rarely.
2
11%
No.
10
56%
 
Total votes: 18

SpeedOfSound
Posts: 668
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 5:05 am
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by SpeedOfSound » Mon Apr 05, 2010 11:59 am

What is interesting about how we think is that we are only willing to blame a person for something if are certain that he was conscious of what he is doing. Even though it has been shown that anything that we do consciously is supported by hundreds if not thousands of unconscious process.

i think this is our homuncular or dualist thinking. If science finds a cause for some thinking then we automatically excuse that thinking and go in search of the immaterial soul and try to find out what is left over that the soul is responsible for.

We end up thinking that we have this instantaneous vote power and it flows from a soul that is actually in charge of everything.
Favorite quote:
lifegazer says "Now, the only way to proceed to claim that brains create experience, is to believe that real brains exist (we certainly cannot study them). And if a scientist does this, he transcends the barriers of both science and metaphysics."

SpeedOfSound
Posts: 668
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 5:05 am
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by SpeedOfSound » Mon Apr 05, 2010 12:19 pm

Wouldn't it be interesting to get the mystic master who is always living completely in the moment and put him through the change blindness experiment to see if he can tell that he is being fooled?
Favorite quote:
lifegazer says "Now, the only way to proceed to claim that brains create experience, is to believe that real brains exist (we certainly cannot study them). And if a scientist does this, he transcends the barriers of both science and metaphysics."

SpeedOfSound
Posts: 668
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 5:05 am
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by SpeedOfSound » Mon Apr 05, 2010 1:25 pm

I would like to introduce a couple of technical terms to describe the naive idealists basic gambit.
The first is the habit of always slipping the homunculus into the cracks somewhere. Into the quantum states, or chaotic systems, or some introspective drivel about feeling like a bat.

Slip the Homuculus In There or SHIT

Next is the obfuscation achieved by lipping deep philosophical insights or perhaps by jumping from subjective to objective categories.

Basic Undulating Loquacious Labiating or BULL

Combine as you wish.
Favorite quote:
lifegazer says "Now, the only way to proceed to claim that brains create experience, is to believe that real brains exist (we certainly cannot study them). And if a scientist does this, he transcends the barriers of both science and metaphysics."

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by FBM » Mon Apr 05, 2010 3:26 pm

SpeedOfSound wrote:You said earlier that you didn't want to split hairs over theories. I'm confused. Do you want to know how things really are or how we experience them and think they are?
Both, preferably. Then I want to compare them and find out if there are any discrepancies.
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by FBM » Mon Apr 05, 2010 3:30 pm

SpeedOfSound wrote:
FBM wrote: There's a grammar to be obeyed, vocabulary chosen, etc. How and when does all this happen, and if it's an unconscious process, how can it be considered to be volitional?
There is a bunch of painstaking studies that show the processes of speech and reading are completely unconscious until something goes wrong. Most of these studies are boring as hell and I haven't read them. I'm mostly taking other neuroscientists at their word here.

There was one study that Baars talks about that I am desperately trying to find...I'll keep looking for that to see if I explained it right. It was pretty stunning. It seems like we backfill our conscious recollection of things so they make sense to us. Words on pages don't change so we refuse to experience them changing even if they really do change.
Holy shit, yes, please try to find the source of that anecdote. Sounds fascinating and perfectly relevant to the sort of thing I'm trying to figure out. :td:
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by FBM » Mon Apr 05, 2010 3:40 pm

SpeedOfSound wrote:What is interesting about how we think is that we are only willing to blame a person for something if are certain that he was conscious of what he is doing. Even though it has been shown that anything that we do consciously is supported by hundreds if not thousands of unconscious process.

i think this is our homuncular or dualist thinking. If science finds a cause for some thinking then we automatically excuse that thinking and go in search of the immaterial soul and try to find out what is left over that the soul is responsible for.

We end up thinking that we have this instantaneous vote power and it flows from a soul that is actually in charge of everything.
I suspect this is very probably the case, except in the case of people who don't believe in a soul. I think that soul has been replaced by Self, and practically speaking, it seems to serve much the same role, minus the immortality part, that is.
SpeedOfSound wrote:Wouldn't it be interesting to get the mystic master who is always living completely in the moment and put him through the change blindness experiment to see if he can tell that he is being fooled?
Heh heh heh heh... :plot:
SpeedOfSound wrote:I would like to introduce a couple of technical terms to describe the naive idealists basic gambit.
The first is the habit of always slipping the homunculus into the cracks somewhere. Into the quantum states, or chaotic systems, or some introspective drivel about feeling like a bat.

Slip the Homuculus In There or SHIT
I suspect that Self is playing the role of homunculus for many people.
Next is the obfuscation achieved by lipping deep philosophical insights or perhaps by jumping from subjective to objective categories.
Or from concrete to abstract, from (assumed) substance to properties, to emergent properties, etc. Yes, this sort of thing is either sloppy or disingenuous. The certainty bias tends to make people justify all sorts of linguistic acrobatics. I'd like to avoid that by asking more questions and making fewer dogmatic assertions. Sometimes I slip up on that, of course.
Basic Undulating Loquacious Labiating or BULL

Combine as you wish.
:eddy:
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

SpeedOfSound
Posts: 668
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 5:05 am
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by SpeedOfSound » Mon Apr 05, 2010 3:43 pm

FBM wrote:
SpeedOfSound wrote:
FBM wrote: There's a grammar to be obeyed, vocabulary chosen, etc. How and when does all this happen, and if it's an unconscious process, how can it be considered to be volitional?
There is a bunch of painstaking studies that show the processes of speech and reading are completely unconscious until something goes wrong. Most of these studies are boring as hell and I haven't read them. I'm mostly taking other neuroscientists at their word here.

There was one study that Baars talks about that I am desperately trying to find...I'll keep looking for that to see if I explained it right. It was pretty stunning. It seems like we backfill our conscious recollection of things so they make sense to us. Words on pages don't change so we refuse to experience them changing even if they really do change.
Holy shit, yes, please try to find the source of that anecdote. Sounds fascinating and perfectly relevant to the sort of thing I'm trying to figure out. :td:
I scanned his books quickly to no avail. I am rereading two of them currently and I will let you know as soon as I find it.

A Cognitive Theory of Consciousness
In the Theater of Consciousness.

Bernard Baars. My main man.
Favorite quote:
lifegazer says "Now, the only way to proceed to claim that brains create experience, is to believe that real brains exist (we certainly cannot study them). And if a scientist does this, he transcends the barriers of both science and metaphysics."

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by FBM » Mon Apr 05, 2010 3:50 pm

SpeedOfSound wrote:
FBM wrote:
SpeedOfSound wrote:
FBM wrote: There's a grammar to be obeyed, vocabulary chosen, etc. How and when does all this happen, and if it's an unconscious process, how can it be considered to be volitional?
There is a bunch of painstaking studies that show the processes of speech and reading are completely unconscious until something goes wrong. Most of these studies are boring as hell and I haven't read them. I'm mostly taking other neuroscientists at their word here.

There was one study that Baars talks about that I am desperately trying to find...I'll keep looking for that to see if I explained it right. It was pretty stunning. It seems like we backfill our conscious recollection of things so they make sense to us. Words on pages don't change so we refuse to experience them changing even if they really do change.
Holy shit, yes, please try to find the source of that anecdote. Sounds fascinating and perfectly relevant to the sort of thing I'm trying to figure out. :td:
I scanned his books quickly to no avail. I am rereading two of them currently and I will let you know as soon as I find it.
Gracioso. I'll see if I can track some reference to it online.
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
charlou
arseist
Posts: 32528
Joined: Thu Jun 28, 2012 2:36 am

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by charlou » Tue Apr 06, 2010 1:54 am

SpeedOfSound wrote:What is interesting about how we think is that we are only willing to blame a person for something if are certain that he was conscious of what he is doing. Even though it has been shown that anything that we do consciously is supported by hundreds if not thousands of unconscious process.

i think this is our homuncular or dualist thinking. If science finds a cause for some thinking then we automatically excuse that thinking and go in search of the immaterial soul and try to find out what is left over that the soul is responsible for.

We end up thinking that we have this instantaneous vote power and it flows from a soul that is actually in charge of everything.
I don't. I grew up being told that is the case, but have since learned it's not and am very comfortable with that understanding. I accept that it is neuron based and mediated by our neurochemistry and culture. No soul/extrinsic entity required.
no fences

User avatar
Hermit
Posts: 25806
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 12:44 am
About me: Cantankerous grump
Location: Ignore lithpt
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by Hermit » Tue Apr 06, 2010 3:30 am

Charlou wrote:I accept that it is neuron based and mediated by our neurochemistry and culture. No soul/extrinsic entity required.
That's basically it for me. One of the intellectual hurdles the vast majority of people can't seem to vault is the concept that there must be something fundamentally existing other than matter. The prejudice that "there must be something more than that" is almost universal.

To me a car is more than the sum of its parts, in so far as the configuration of those parts makes that heap of metal, plastic, rubber and fuel capable of things which those components would not otherwise have, but I challenge anybody to pull one apart and then show me the leftover called driveability. Same goes for the mind, thinking, consciousness or whatever.
I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein’s brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops. - Stephen J. Gould

User avatar
GoodSmeagol
Posts: 65
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 3:49 am
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by GoodSmeagol » Tue Apr 06, 2010 7:08 am

I have thoughts, THEN craft and choose them depending on my goals.
I have many thoughts yet act on only a few, am I alone?
Image

User avatar
NoFreeWill
Posts: 29
Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2010 2:44 am
Location: Melbourne, Oz
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by NoFreeWill » Tue Apr 06, 2010 7:12 am

GoodSmeagol wrote:I have thoughts, THEN craft and choose them depending on my goals.
I have many thoughts yet act on only a few, am I alone?
No, FBM is asking if you craft your thoughts before you have them
"Faith" means not wanting to know what is true.
Friedrich Nietzsche

The will to overcome an emotion, is ultimately only the will of another, or of several other, emotions.
Friedrich Nietzsche

A thought comes when "it" wishes, and not when "I" wish.
Friedrich Nietzsche

SpeedOfSound
Posts: 668
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 5:05 am
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by SpeedOfSound » Tue Apr 06, 2010 7:19 am

Does anyone have a good example of crafting a thought?
Favorite quote:
lifegazer says "Now, the only way to proceed to claim that brains create experience, is to believe that real brains exist (we certainly cannot study them). And if a scientist does this, he transcends the barriers of both science and metaphysics."

User avatar
NoFreeWill
Posts: 29
Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2010 2:44 am
Location: Melbourne, Oz
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by NoFreeWill » Tue Apr 06, 2010 7:33 am

SpeedOfSound wrote:Does anyone have a good example of crafting a thought?
Maybe if you chose to solve a particular problem then the thought the finally led you to the solution might be said to have been crafted. :dono:
"Faith" means not wanting to know what is true.
Friedrich Nietzsche

The will to overcome an emotion, is ultimately only the will of another, or of several other, emotions.
Friedrich Nietzsche

A thought comes when "it" wishes, and not when "I" wish.
Friedrich Nietzsche

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do you craft/choose your thoughts before you have them?

Post by FBM » Tue Apr 06, 2010 7:38 am

SpeedOfSound wrote:Does anyone have a good example of crafting a thought?
Insofar as 'crafting' implies volition, no I don't have any examples. I'm not going to rule out that others may, though. That was pretty much what the OP was about. Finding out whether or not others do, I mean.
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests