The Ethics of Punching Nazis

[rainbow]

Dude, don't make your grammar problems mine. Write more coherently if you want to avoid this sort of thing.

My writing was coherent. Either you have trouble reading, or you're trolling again.

The problem is, Farty, that some of what you write makes perfect sense, and then you go off on a blustering rant, at which point you lose your audience.



You know I'm right.

[L'Emmerdeur]

Hmm. "Was a Protester Throwing Explosives Into a Berkeley Crowd Before She Was Punched?"

While many media outlets painted a sympathetic picture of Rosealma and claimed that she had been “sucker punched” during the riot, others claimed that she was actually an instigator to the violence. A photograph purportedly showing Rosealma holding a glass bottle was circulated along with the claim that she had filled the bottle with explosives and was preparing to launch it into the crowd when Damigo stopped her:



The web site DrRichSweir.com provided this version of events:

There’s been media coverage of a woman Louise Rosealma being wrestled to the ground by a man. Rosealma was part of the Antifa group in Berkeley, California that attacked pro-Trump marchers.

Nathan Damigo, a Marine veteran who was there saw that Rosealma was putting M80 explosive devices inside glass bottles and throwing them at the pro-Trump rally marchers.

So Louise Rosealma was literally making IED’s. This makes her no better than the Boston Marathon bombers.

Although the post portrays Damigo as a veteran heroically intervening to prevent violence, his past is more complicated than that. He is the founder of a white supremacist group called Identity Evropa (which he was promoting at the event) and has served jail time for armed robbery.

Still, we found no record of Damigo claiming that he saw Rosealma putting an M80 explosive inside a glass bottle and throwing at it protesters. No quotations from Damigo were provided, nor any evidence that the bottle was actually filled with explosives. In fact, the photographic evidence does more to disprove this claim than to support it.

[Forty Two]

The issue with that incident is who threw the first punch. Rosealma was there to take scalps, and she said so. But, that doesn't mean she deserved to get hit. She deserved to get hit if she attacked someone, and vice versa. She would be legitimately allowed to hit someone if someone attacked her. I wouldn't assume either party here was guilty. I've seen video footage, which seems inconclusive as to who was the aggressor. Perhaps both were.

[Forty Two]

Here's how you should have written it:

Nobody, as far as I've heard, has argued that peaceful individuals of leftist, black bloc, anarchist, communist, or whatever left-wing group, should be punched for their views.

Even before correcting it for individuals i had to remove an 'or' and a comma to even make it grammatically coherent.

I'm not going to go on and on with this nonsense. If we're going to be trying to call out everyone's grammar issues, fine. I can live with that. The bottom line here is pErvin could understand what I wrote. This is just his usual tactic of derailing and trolling.

[pErvinalia]

Here's how you should have written it:

Nobody, as far as I've heard, has argued that peaceful individuals of leftist, black bloc, anarchist, communist, or whatever left-wing group, should be punched for their views.

Even before correcting it for individuals i had to remove an 'or' and a comma to even make it grammatically coherent.

I'm not going to go on and on with this nonsense. If we're going to be trying to call out everyone's grammar issues, fine. I can live with that. The bottom line here is pErvin could understand what I wrote. This is just his usual tactic of derailing and trolling.

God you are a fucking cry-baby.

[Forty Two]

God, you are a fucking crybaby.

[pErvinalia]

I dunno. Doesn't the comma mean that God is the cry baby?

[Forty Two]

[pErvinalia]

Who's "Man"?

[Forty Two]

Nobody. It's an interjection.

[pErvinalia]

You're an interjection..

[Forty Two]

Indeed. You were obviously referring to me when you wrote "God."

[pErvinalia]

Well, you are infallible like God, apparently..

[Forty Two]

[rainbow]

Indeed. You were obviously referring to me when you wrote "God."