Venture Bros: day 1

[irretating]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

[Zigmen]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

Eventually, I'd ask why. Right now I think we can all make our little chalk marks and see what happens.

Think about it.

[Drewish]

##vote amok##

For continuing to use a Metal Gear Solid avatar.

[irretating]

##vote amok##

For continuing to use a Metal Gear Solid avatar.

Phew. For a minute there I'd thought you'd picked a totally random reason for your lynch vote.

[Magicziggy]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

Because I'm hank.

[irretating]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

Because I'm hank.

Why are you not immediately lynch voting him? You're both claiming the same character?

[Magicziggy]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

Because I'm hank.

Why are you not immediately lynch voting him? You're both claiming the same character?

Because either:

1) Linus has fucked up Matt's safe claim

or 2)Linus has fucked up the town roles

or 3) It's a weird arse game with identical characters

you don;t make up a word like fungible. It's why asked about hank.

It's not enough to condemn Matt though.

[irretating]

3) I've never seen
2) possible but unlikely
1) most likely

##vote shizzle##

[Drewish]

There's no reason for anyone to claim a character other than the one given, since we know that scum got fakes. So duplicate claims don't mean a lynch it means

xpost Magicziggy and irretating

Yeah, what Magicziggy said. I don't think it's lynch worthy.

[Magicziggy]

I have 2) and 1) as equally likely (being both a GM fuck up which are following me from game to game) with benefit of doubt being given to shizzle given the probability of him being town over him being scum..

xpost AC

[irretating]

On day 1? I'll wait to see if there's a better option, but claiming the same character as someone else pings for me.

[MattShizzle]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

Because I'm hank.

Why are you not immediately lynch voting him? You're both claiming the same character?

Because either:

1) Linus has fucked up Matt's safe claim

or 2)Linus has fucked up the town roles

or 3) It's a weird arse game with identical characters

you don;t make up a word like fungible. It's why asked about hank.

It's not enough to condemn Matt though.

Wait what??? This would be a very weird move for scum (insane really) so I'm thinking Linus did some weird role thing. Maybe one of us is a miller or such? 2 people with the same role unless he was utterly careless (and if that's the case shouldn't be allowed to GM for a bit) screams something weird.

[MattShizzle]

To reiterate if MZ was scum he'd be dumb to claim the same as me as once I was lynched and my role confirmed he'd be lynched - and 1 scum for 1 VT is good for town. I would almost say we should both be lynched but I wonder about weird roles. Town should still consider lynching both of us...

[Magicziggy]

To reiterate if MZ was scum he'd be dumb to claim the same as me as once I was lynched and my role confirmed he'd be lynched - and 1 scum for 1 VT is good for town. I would almost say we should both be lynched but I wonder about weird roles. Town should still consider lynching both of us...

Now I have reason to lynch you.
##vote Mattshizzle##

[Zigmen]

MZ, when you saw Shizz claim the same as your character, why was your first instinct to trust him?

General question: Would you have trusted Shizz if you were in MZ's spot?

I would not have.

IMHO, this makes MZ look equally if not more suspicious than Shizz.