Tarot III Mafia: Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

Well I think charlou and I did what we could under the circumstances. There was no clear scum target. She made the call. I followed. Zigmen seemed a good choice.

Aza has to be telling the truth. I'm inclined to back of UT accordingly.

[Athene]

short of a counter-claim, I'm going to accept aza's role-claim.

Why did you follow charlou and myself on to aza? Earlier you pointed out to me that profile watching leads to lynching for the wrong reason, and my vote rationale was blatantly based on the information I had received from profile watching.

[Azathoth]

I'm not going to lynch DP on no posts only.

There's scum posting for sure.

Followed a bit later by a hop onto the easy BW for me. That is a big FOS as is Feck's driveby DP vote. I have seen enough scum threads where he gets worried about not being seen to be going after DP when he does exactly that in the game thread. Those are my picks for today

[Don't Panic]

Hey kids, sorry I'm late to the party, just read day one, and have to say I'm very wary of aza's claim. Why wasn't he killed last night if he was a town player? Doesn't make sense to me. And no, I won't buy the scum targeted someone else in case he protected himself line, you never get to kill the doc that way, you try the first night and if they don't die then you try again since generally they can't protect themselves 2 nights in a row, that is scum 101 and the players here are smart enough to know it.

##vote aza##

[Magicziggy]

There was no stand out lynch target. Aza appeared to be as good as any and a slightly better bet than DP. However my judgement is based on trusting my read on charlou.

[Feck]

AZA No ! I voted DP because I've seen him coast for a day or two when scum before . Check the history .

[Azathoth]

I see DP can't resist the scumcrack. Outed special with no counterclaim. Don't waste a NK straight away see if you can WIFOM town into killing them for you, scum 303

[Athene]

There was no stand out lynch target. Aza appeared to be as good as any and a slightly better bet than DP. However my judgement is based on trusting my read on charlou.

charlou followed me on to aza despite an earlier indication of suspicion towards me, that didn't ping for you?

[Don't Panic]

I see DP can't resist the scumcrack. Outed special with no counterclaim. Don't waste a NK straight away see if you can WIFOM town into killing them for you, scum 303

Your claim was a desperation move and reeks of it, my only advice to our doc is keep your head down, aza had nothing to lose yesterday by claiming, he was dead otherwise. Claiming a major role encourages a counterclaim and bags a town special. I'm just surprised you didn't claim seer.

[Athene]

ok, this is interesting.

DP, it's a bold move to lynch vote a claimed special. It goes without saying that given the circumstances, there is a possibility he is lying, but at the same time - without evidence to show he's lying, lynching him doesn't seem like the best idea because of the possibility that he is telling the truth.

[Athene]

Well I think charlou and I did what we could under the circumstances. There was no clear scum target. She made the call. I followed. Zigmen seemed a good choice.

Aza has to be telling the truth. I'm inclined to back of UT accordingly.

What do people make of the bolded bit here?

[MattShizzle]

FOS that voting to lynch a claimed special shit big time.

[Feck]

Lynch voting an uncontested special is more than bold .I'm inclined to think that Aza is the Doc until any evidence to the contrary shows up .

[Magicziggy]

Well I think charlou and I did what we could under the circumstances. There was no clear scum target. She made the call. I followed. Zigmen seemed a good choice.

Aza has to be telling the truth. I'm inclined to back of UT accordingly.

What do people make of the bolded bit here?

In light of what DP has said, I retract.

[Magicziggy]

There was no stand out lynch target. Aza appeared to be as good as any and a slightly better bet than DP. However my judgement is based on trusting my read on charlou.

charlou followed me on to aza despite an earlier indication of suspicion towards me, that didn't ping for you?

No.

I followed her. I didn't see who she followed. I had expressed earlier a willingness to lynch aza based on lack of a better target. I really saw no one as scummy. Aza clearly looks scummy in the cold light of day. A last minute special claim. Uncontested as it happens. Dp's call on that looks valid. I agree with leaving aza for today. And DP. I then have to look at the rest.