Russian Roulette Game Thread

[Mantisdreamz]

Mantis, why did you change your vote at the last minute from diva to denny?

Since we now know Diva was Town, isn't a better quesation why Ksen tried to change his vote onto Diva?

No, if ksen were scum he could have left his vote where it is and not switched on to diva - she was already the lynch leader even if he had put his vote down just before nightfall. Given the suspicion you were under yesterday, nobody would have batted an eyelid for his leaving his lynch vote there.

true enough. though, there is the option that he didn't know she was the lynch leader. I noticed he hadn't posted in the last bit of the thread. though, maybe it's best not to go there right now.

[Mantisdreamz]

Mantis, why did you change your vote at the last minute from diva to denny?

because I crossposted with her and saw her post that said "Mantis get your vote off me now!" Denny was a quick choice, because of the Gonzo vote with him and how he votes him and then came up with the reason for 'self mayor' after the fact.

Do you normally take your votes off people when they tell you too?

Diva looked for real. And I did think she was town previous to that.

[Zigmen]

Diva did know she was the bomb.. she made that weird suggestion of everyone not voting and only irre voting her. Denny, in the night chat you seemed to come to the conclusion that I voted you for revenge of that vig kill. As much as I'm still bitter about that (not really), no that's not the reason. See above post.

This doesn't make any sense.

If Irre was the only vote on Diva, she wouldn't have detonated in the first place.

[Athene]

Ok, then. So why did you put a vote for her in the first place if you thought she was town?

[Athene]

Ok, then. So why did you put a vote for her in the first place if you thought she was town?

To Mantis.

[Mantisdreamz]

'cause apparently Ob was seeing something that resembled her scum game. this is why I wanted her viewed, because her scum game is very dramatic as well - she's the person on the timebomb game who we all trusted. Out of something like 15 players it came down to town picking 2 to trust. And she was one of them. in other words - I thought she might have been town but there was still a bit of doubt.

just saw your post below Zig - what do you mean it doesn't make sense? if everyone didn't vote, and only irre did - then she would have. Who is your choice for a lynch?

[Athene]

This isn't making sense.

You thought diva was town but voted for her because oblivion thought she was doing something she does when she's scum. Diva then tells you to take her vote off and you do so and put it on somebody who hasn't got a single vote on them.

I'm wondering if scum knew in advance about some town members being bombs.

[Athene]

oh and vote mantis

[Mantisdreamz]

This isn't making sense.

You thought diva was town but voted for her because oblivion thought she was doing something she does when she's scum. Diva then tells you to take her vote off and you do so and put it on somebody who hasn't got a single vote on them.

meh. Okay. Would it have been better if I just unvoted without getting another vote out there? I think that would look anti town as well.

[Athene]

This isn't making sense.

You thought diva was town but voted for her because oblivion thought she was doing something she does when she's scum. Diva then tells you to take her vote off and you do so and put it on somebody who hasn't got a single vote on them.

meh. Okay. Would it have been better if I just unvoted without getting another vote out there? I think that would look anti town as well.

As a scum strategy it's probably best not to leave it till the last minute to vote. hth

[Gonzo]

Gonzo your second last post on the other thread is weird. You think that adenosine being followy of oblivion, given her flip, is townish. How on earth do you come up with conclusion, when the only way adenosine could have know oblivion was town is if adenosine is in fact scum? You are the one with the flakey game. Self voting as mayor is just as weird. And you only choose to make judgements of the 'obvious' people and don't comment on Athene, for eg, or mantis.

vote gonzo

Simmer a bit. I said it was townish in that he could have been following Ob soley do to the fact that he trusted her and I have no evidence to reason it otherwise. You see - scum don't often take orders from townies or follow their suggestions so quickly, but it was objectively scummy to last-minute vote under the circumstance of him saving another scum (say, Zig) by voting diva. It isn't that complicated.

[Gonzo]

Concerning your criticism that I only comment on 'obvious people', that's a strange FOS there. As strange as most of the FOSes you've made of me and others, Irre. Seems like a desperate cherry on top that sort of exagerates the non-case you've built against me: 'and he's letting others lay-low, too!'.

I've not listed off all the inactive players as people I find suspicious, no, but why would I? I had substancial posts to respond to. Am also quite sure I'm not the only one not to make a case of inactive players, so you sound extra stupid to accuse me for it.

[ksen]

vote irre

Why?

Because if I don't vote for Irre I'd be voting for you again.

[Gonzo]

Can we vote a new Mayor before we lynch them or do we have to lynch them first?

Irre, I trust you as much as Gonzo at the moment. You were clearly reaching. Still are. But G is being very flakey. Uh-huh, you self voting brought Oblivion to the fore as a Mayoral candidate; a cunning Machiavellian plot brought to fruition. Why didn't you just vote for her?

I didn't claim it was clever, num nuts. It was to tie myself with the person I thought was most likely town. That way, very simply, the town would choose between either of us. I'm not interested in being mayor anymore, so I don't care if you vote for me or not. It was strategic. Most all votes in Mafia are a choice between two: one or the other. Me or Oblivion. Me or Zigmen. Both of my votes served a purpose I thought most pro-town. Lynch who I thought was scum - elect myself or who I thought was town. It was a reasoned decision.

[Gonzo]

Has anyone the vaguest idea of what triggered diva to explode and why it was Oblivion? Do you have an opinion on it, Mantis?