Simple Mafia 2 Archive

[irretating]

I'll let others spell it out to you in the game wash up, then.

[higgs2]

Classic stuff. You can afford to lynch me and have town win, but for the real town people out there, think long and hard about who is leading this charge against me and why.

higgs2, I'm now flabbergasted at you... you are supposedly an experienced player, yet you failed to see that my mistake (and yes Mantis I'm being hard on myself for that) in posting in the thread about not getting my role PM instead of PMing oblivion, DID in fact pretty much put me in the clear. You have maintained that this didn't really mean much, and from such an experienced player it's melted my brain. It has done all game.

And now, you lead a charge against me? Based on a lie? Wow. Fellow town people: higgs2 is lying (or mistaken) when she says that

Also Twinkle's opinion after seer fingered virphen: "My current estimation is that scum are: higgs2 and uselesstwit, or charlou and normal" Charlous was the seer, Useless cleared by Charlous.But we were all fos'g virphen.
her opinion of me: "I feel it's more likely that higgs2 is scum, because she is playing such a different game, a noisy scum flail-y game."

... charlou had NOT come out as seer at this point, she had only said she was certain virphen was scum. My problem with charlou's (and higgs2's) campaign against virphen is that they were using the 'twinkie is in the clear' statement from his AS EVIDENCE that he was scum. Utter bullshit. He was scum, but that was not compelling evidence.

Anyhoo, this has been a frustrating game and I wish town well. I am town and I want town to win. The third scum is doing a good job of either lying low and letting higgs2 bungle, or it's higgs2.

Keep that in mind.

You are right, I went back and looked and I was wrong about charlou having outed as seer before you said that. I apologize.

However, you did not retreat one bit on all of the accusations you had made about charlou and me after you found out she was the seer.

And if you are town you should not beat yourself up about your post in the sign up thread, Virphen was twisting it and using you to make himself seem innocent. I happen to believe there was coordination between you on it though, thus my opinion and vote. THe think where he tried to clear you by saying he was making a play to get killed in place of a special, well that looked like a plan between the two of you gone awry. We'll see.

[irretating]

Good luck with that.

Virphen and I coordinating this whole thing (with both of us as scum and colubridae lynched first day) ? As if.

Town people: start considering who you will lynch next, once you find out I'm town. This is the first time I've been lynched as an innocent and it feels weird.

[normal]

Good luck with that.

Virphen and I coordinating this whole thing (with both of us as scum and colubridae lynched first day) ? As if.

Town people: start considering who you will lynch next, once you find out I'm town. This is the first time I've been lynched as an innocent and it feels weird.

I've tried that in almost all the games. This is a potential welcome to the club (assuming you're truthful)

[higgs2]

Yea, of course I could be lying too... was thinking that during posting but left that out.

I was just going through the previous threads as well, and Feck did say this before Charlou even came out that she was seer and that she read virph as scum:

"I think I expressed the thought that you might be Scum Virphen ..."

So that there, really makes me believe that Feck is likely innocent. Because why would he incriminate his own team member before any one really caught on that virph was actually scum?

Another thing as well, was that I did notice that yes, Twinkie did vote for col the first day. Though, what I didn't realize was that she actually unvoted col and voted for DP. The next day DP was dead. Maybe scum were afraid that DP would question her as to why she put a vote on him. (Or maybe that was nothing).

I don't know, but it seems to be Twinkie or you, Normal...

I'll go with Twinkie for now as well. Though, I still am hesitant...

Good finds. I missed the switch to dp.

vote twinkie

vote Twinkie

I'm redoing this because I messed up the quotes.

I said "Good finds. I missed the switch to dp. "

and then voted for twinkie. Sorry for the mixup.

[Mantisdreamz]

unvote Twinkie

I can't necessarily go with this because I am not sure at all and not confident about the lynch vote.

Whoever the last scum is, is doing a very good job.

I'll make a decision soon I guess. I'm interested in what Useless thinks as well.

[higgs2]

unvote Twinkie

I can't necessarily go with this because I am not sure at all and not confident about the lynch vote.

Whoever the last scum is, is doing a very good job.

I'll make a decision soon I guess. I'm interested in what Useless thinks as well.

Who else do you suspect?

[normal]

Classic stuff. You can afford to lynch me and have town win, but for the real town people out there, think long and hard about who is leading this charge against me and why.

higgs2, I'm now flabbergasted at you... you are supposedly an experienced player, yet you failed to see that my mistake (and yes Mantis I'm being hard on myself for that) in posting in the thread about not getting my role PM instead of PMing oblivion, DID in fact pretty much put me in the clear. You have maintained that this didn't really mean much, and from such an experienced player it's melted my brain. It has done all game.

And now, you lead a charge against me? Based on a lie? Wow. Fellow town people: higgs2 is lying (or mistaken) when she says that

Also Twinkle's opinion after seer fingered virphen: "My current estimation is that scum are: higgs2 and uselesstwit, or charlou and normal" Charlous was the seer, Useless cleared by Charlous.But we were all fos'g virphen.
her opinion of me: "I feel it's more likely that higgs2 is scum, because she is playing such a different game, a noisy scum flail-y game."

... charlou had NOT come out as seer at this point, she had only said she was certain virphen was scum. My problem with charlou's (and higgs2's) campaign against virphen is that they were using the 'twinkie is in the clear' statement from his AS EVIDENCE that he was scum. Utter bullshit. He was scum, but that was not compelling evidence.

Anyhoo, this has been a frustrating game and I wish town well. I am town and I want town to win. The third scum is doing a good job of either lying low and letting higgs2 bungle, or it's higgs2.

Keep that in mind.

I'll just explain what I thought when I read this post:

I think this is a VERY bad post if you are town, Twinkie. Complaining about one's own imminent lynching, and repeatedly proclaiming to be town should never be a priority for town player. What our focus needs to be is to win the game (and you try to focus on that in the last part by shifting focus to higgs, so that's ok). But the emotional pressure you exert in order to (maybe) not get lynched seems to me to be a dirty trick, or a poor tactic. This is one of my main reasons for keeping my vote on you.

[irretating]

No emotional pressure, Normal. I'm amazed that I'm going to be lynched when my initial mistake in this game cleared me. It's hilarious.

I started this round saying that I deserve to be lynched because I've played a crap game, so I'm not complaining about being lynched. I'm gobsmacked at higgs2, is all.

[higgs2]

I have not heard a rational explanation as to how that post in the signup thread clears you. If someone could logically explain that to me, I would be able to reconsider, but using that as being "clear" by you as well as virphen adds to my suspicions.

[normal]

I have not heard a rational explanation as to how that post in the signup thread clears you. If someone could logically explain that to me, I would be able to reconsider, but using that as being "clear" by you as well as virphen adds to my suspicions.

Yes, this is what I found a bit fishy as well. I didn't see anything clear you

[irretating]

I have not heard a rational explanation as to how that post in the signup thread clears you. If someone could logically explain that to me, I would be able to reconsider, but using that as being "clear" by you as well as virphen adds to my suspicions.

As I say, people not at liberty to comment (i.e. people other than the six of us in this game) will explain it to you in the game wash up. If you are town...

[higgs2]

I have not heard a rational explanation as to how that post in the signup thread clears you. If someone could logically explain that to me, I would be able to reconsider, but using that as being "clear" by you as well as virphen adds to my suspicions.

As I say, people not at liberty to comment (i.e. people other than the six of us in this game) will explain it to you in the game wash up. If you are town...

Don't you know?

[irretating]

I have not heard a rational explanation as to how that post in the signup thread clears you. If someone could logically explain that to me, I would be able to reconsider, but using that as being "clear" by you as well as virphen adds to my suspicions.

As I say, people not at liberty to comment (i.e. people other than the six of us in this game) will explain it to you in the game wash up. If you are town...

Don't you know?

Of course I know. As I've been saying all game, I made a stupid mistake. I do not wish to get some advantage out of a mistake, so I'm not going to use the mistake. The fact that you, as an experienced player, can't see it places huge suspicion on YOU. I've been saying this all game. I'm not convinced of your scumminess - although I have strong suspicions - so you might be bungling. If you are town, I don't wish for you to be lynched next.

Consider me lynched. Town people need to think about who they'd lynch next... discuss it now so that you have more posts from everyone to consider. From my point of view, the higgs2 blunder (or not) clouds my thinking. I voted for Normal but Feck is almost as likely (that is, if higgs2 simply blundered and isn't playing everyone).

[higgs2]

Why are you unwilling to explain it, Twinkie? If I am completely wrong, you should correct me. I was mistaken about something else that you pointed out and I went back and checked and corrected it. I don't undertand why it has to be someone who is not part of the six people here, or whatever. And I don't want to vote for town, my intention is to get scum.