Simple Mafia 3

[Animavore]

Because the vigi shows up guilty to a seer.

[Zigmen]

Because the vigi shows up guilty to a seer.

What?

Vigs are town. They are viewed as town.

[Animavore]

No. Vigis, because they have a gun, view as scum. It's to balance off the don viewing as town thing.

[charlou]

I know the Don shows as town to a seer, but I don't know about other roles showing incorrectly ...

[charlou]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

[Animavore]

It's always been that way

[higgs2]

No. Vigis, because they have a gun, view as scum. It's to balance off the don viewing as town thing.

Vigis view as town. A miller is the role that is town but views as scum.

[higgs2]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

[normal]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

So Ani... Is insane or lying?

[Animavore]

A "miller"? What's that?

[Feck]

In these quotes from Useless, I see a couple of things:

1) He protects MagicZig twice (sort of).
2) He protects Ghat (who is viewed as scum).
3) He votes Feck.
4) He FoSes DP (now dead).

I sense a "hide my eggs in two baskets" strategy here.

MagicZig, who do you think is scum?

Feck, Who do you think is scum?

I thought Magic ,,, but then Magic has been FOsing Ghat from the start ,I will have another think then get back to you .

[normal]

A "miller"? What's that?

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Miller

[Animavore]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

So Ani... Is insane or lying?

Or Ghat is being really clever trying to protect his ass.

[charlou]

Do any other players have previous experience or rule knowledge of vigilante viewing as scum?

Only with an insane seer.

So, no.

Reading here, an insane or paranoid cop/seer would view a vig as scum, and there's also the possibility of a random cop/seer.

I doubt a seer in these simple games would be handicapped in any of those ways.

[higgs2]

Okay, from the post from oblivion in the PG:

...There may be some special town roles. If there are, they will be restricted to the following kinds of roles: investigative, protecting, blocking, killing.

There may be some special scum roles. If there are, they will be restricted to the following kinds of roles: don (views as town), blocking.

A serial killer is an indie roll. I think we can quite speculating about that one unless we think she would post all that and then throw in an indie.

IMO we need to go with the simplest explanation, ani is seer, ghat is scum. Vig knows what to do if ani turns up town.

Also with the don already killed (yay!) it seems unlikely to me that there will be another scum role, but it's possible.