Reservoir Dogs Mafia Game thread

[Animavore]

Great game, Gonzo. A bit different.

[irretating]

More scumboard lulz.

I agree that Ani is most likely vanilla. He’s pretty random so he’s good for end game. I’d want ade and Aza gone before end game.

The irony.

[irretating]

Feck, what do you mean the player order?

List the players on day one ...now who was a town special who were the scum ?

Yes, gonzo, how was it that scum were all listed in a clump? Just a fluke?

[Feck]

I'm changing my name too Abaacus before the next game !

[Azathoth]

GG Gonzo. I can't believe I made it to endgame

[DennyB]

Great Game Gonzo. I really enjoyed this one with the loaded specials.
Charlou, Why the kill on me?

[divagreen]

And good job on your vote, Ani!

[irretating]

GG Gonzo. I can't believe I made it to endgame

You wouldn't have, if I'd had my way

[Mantisdreamz]

Feck, what do you mean the player order?

List the players on day one ...now who was a town special who were the scum ?

ohh yaa

[Azathoth]

GG Gonzo. I can't believe I made it to endgame

You wouldn't have, if I'd had my way

[Feck]

I think it was nice that Ani got to play a game all the way through for once .

[irretating]

It was.. alas he wasn't as random as I'd hoped for

[Mantisdreamz]

I think it was nice that Ani got to play a game all the way through for once .

that's true. There is a certain few that never seem to be able to make it through... like, Zigmen for one. And Denny. No wonder Zig was getting so frustrated. But at the same time - Zig comes up with such outlandish things while scum, it's tough to actually believe him when he is town!

[irretating]

Zig is a failure of his success at BS'ing when he's scum, I'm afraid. I've no sympathy for him at all *sniff*. But why I can't make it to endgame any more, well that is outrageously unfair

[charlou]

Denny, I killed you because I've wanted to see you suffer in agony and facing your death for so long ... I enjoyed every moment of it ...












*ahem*

I think the game balance was interesting for all concerned. Both scum and town were more laden with specials than we've seen here for a while, iirc.

Reading the scum writeboard, as the game progressed Linus and Feck certainly had their work cut out trying to second guess the town specials' possible night actions, and tailor their own night actions accordingly. At least they had the advantage of both being scum specials and being able to communicate to coordinate their night actions.

Town was loaded with specials, but the three seers, all with different levels of sanity, made the seer thing a wild card / wifom generator. Denny was vig killed and Zigmen quit/lynched, and Aza's level of sanity (random or paranoid) was always in question, so Feck's alignment was questionable for the most part ... I think those factors, and the fact that I was essentially vanilla for all of the nights except the one I chose to hit Denny, kinda balanced things as the game panned out. Had scum lost their specials early, my view of that may be different, though. As it was, Feck made it through to end game with only two town in play (and having done so with two nights without a kill) - kudos to the scum team for that - so there was a chance scum could have taken the game on numbers ... But I'm not sure if they'd have won, even then - Where were the diamonds in the end?


The game was very engaging and fun to play. Thanks to all of you, and to you, Gonzo The role/special action, and your writeups were excellent, really imbuing the game with the fullness of flavour ... Mr Blonde ahehehe

Zigmen, I really was undecided about you. I was weighing up between you and Denny for my nightkill. In the end I thought Denny's play was odd.

Denny, this post, including your list of who your thought were most townish is what led me to think you were scum:

Frankly, I'm not buying Zigs story.
He has pulled this many times. Without another claim It's silly to lynch him though.
I think if it is infact a ruse the real seer should get some views before outing.

Most townish so far to me is:
Irre
Mantis
Athene
Feck
Charlou

The fact that on the one hand you weren't buying Zig's story, while on the other not wanting him lynched ... I thought you were possibly both scum. He was a claimed special though, so I went for you. The list of 'most townish' ... usually lists include a spectrum from most townish to most scummy, and noting who are most townish on day one also looked like possible grooming at that point of the game.

As it turned out, your card flip was useful to town ... It augered the call for Zigmen's head, but it also ensured Aza's claim was more believable.

Kudos to Aza for your cool headedness when Zigmen claimed, and your conduct throughout from there on ... Denny too, actually - Even though I misinterpreted your post, Denny, you were pretty cool under the circumstances. Must have been at least a bit startling for both of you? Certainly was for Zigmen.

Zig

Yeah, good game ALL!