Simpsons Game Thread

[oblivion]

also, your link goes to the OP of the day 2 thread. What post are you talking about?

[DennyB]

And go ahead guys. lynch me if you want to lynch another town,
You better be dead on with the rest of the scum afterwards as we will not get many more chances.

[DennyB]

also, your link goes to the OP of the day 2 thread. What post are you talking about?

Hmmm.
It's the 22nd post incl the OP

[Uselesstwit]

On the other hand, scum are going to want to get rid of the extra kill in the next day or so, too.

it really comes down to 2 things. how many scum are left and what is the indies win condition. If there are only 2 scum left we should go straight for the win and get rid of them now, we have enough numbers on them after callan died we can afford the extra night kill one more time. If there are 3 scum left, we're better off getting rid of the extra night kill.

How certain are you that the sk will have a last man standing win condition and not a find the item and survive to end game? If this were ratskep I'd bet on the second one, but here with zigmen I'm just not sure. Having to find the item and be sole survivor makes a very hard role almost impossible.

[DennyB]

I just did a quick search of Denny's posts, can someone else do the same and tell me what they think.


1 higgs2 - Otto, Town Busdriver
5 Gallstones - Dr. Nick, Town Doctor
9 Ghatanothoa - Patty, Town
13 Normal - Selma, Town
16 MZ - Chief Wiggum, Town Seer

Denny voted the first 2, FoS'd the second 2, can anyone remember what he had to say about MZ?

Who did you vote for gib?

[oblivion]

On the other hand, scum are going to want to get rid of the extra kill in the next day or so, too.

it really comes down to 2 things. how many scum are left and what is the indies win condition. If there are only 2 scum left we should go straight for the win and get rid of them now, we have enough numbers on them after callan died we can afford the extra night kill one more time. If there are 3 scum left, we're better off getting rid of the extra night kill.

How certain are you that the sk will have a last man standing win condition and not a find the item and survive to end game? If this were ratskep I'd bet on the second one, but here with zigmen I'm just not sure. Having to find the item and be sole survivor makes a very hard role almost impossible.

I'm not certain. When I give an SK a dual win condition in my games, I usually make the althernate condition difficult to attain. So far, none of the SKs in my game have won via an alternate condition.

[DennyB]

I just did a quick search of Denny's posts, can someone else do the same and tell me what they think.


1 higgs2 - Otto, Town Busdriver
5 Gallstones - Dr. Nick, Town Doctor
9 Ghatanothoa - Patty, Town
13 Normal - Selma, Town
16 MZ - Chief Wiggum, Town Seer

Denny voted the first 2, FoS'd the second 2, can anyone remember what he had to say about MZ?

Who did you vote for gib?

BTW. this is plain and simple bullshit.
I voted higgs to save Irre. Would have voted myself to do the same.
Gall's play was crap.
And if I fos town that makes me scum?
Pain and simple bullshit!

[Mantisdreamz]

I think I'm going to go with Animavore.

vote Animavore

[oblivion]

I went back and looked at Irre's votes and the foses she threw out with them.

Day 1
Voted Ani "because I like to see how he acts when I light a fire under him"
Voted mono "just for sport"
Voted Denny for jumping on an easy bandwagon. later suggested denny was good target for the vig
Late in the day, voted higgs to save her self.

Day 2
Voted gib because she didn't believe the jester story
FoSed Mort
Voted Feck for being lazy

Voted DP "needs pressure"
Voted Normal "no substance"
Voted gallstones

So far today
Voted DP (and is happy with the vote.

Lining it up like this, it really looks bad. She's been throwing votes on people who weren't the major bandwagons until late in the game day. She's FoSed people and then not followed up the next day.

In the midst of all that she's claimed some people are cleared and created a whole lot of stir in the process.

[gib]

I just did a quick search of Denny's posts, can someone else do the same and tell me what they think.


1 higgs2 - Otto, Town Busdriver
5 Gallstones - Dr. Nick, Town Doctor
9 Ghatanothoa - Patty, Town
13 Normal - Selma, Town
16 MZ - Chief Wiggum, Town Seer

Denny voted the first 2, FoS'd the second 2, can anyone remember what he had to say about MZ?

Who did you vote for gib?

BTW. this is plain and simple bullshit.
I voted higgs to save Irre. Would have voted myself to do the same.
Gall's play was crap.
And if I fos town that makes me scum?
Pain and simple bullshit!

Bullshit as in lies? Which bits aren't true?

[gib]

I went back and looked at Irre's votes and the foses she threw out with them.

Day 1
Voted Ani "because I like to see how he acts when I light a fire under him"
Voted mono "just for sport"
Voted Denny for jumping on an easy bandwagon. later suggested denny was good target for the vig
Late in the day, voted higgs to save her self.

Day 2
Voted gib because she didn't believe the jester story
FoSed Mort
Voted Feck for being lazy

Voted DP "needs pressure"
Voted Normal "no substance"
Voted gallstones

So far today
Voted DP (and is happy with the vote.

Lining it up like this, it really looks bad. She's been throwing votes on people who weren't the major bandwagons until late in the game day. She's FoSed people and then not followed up the next day.

In the midst of all that she's claimed some people are cleared and created a whole lot of stir in the process.

Yeh that does look wayyyyy worse than Denny.

[oblivion]

Out of a sense of fairness I went back through my own votes and heavy foses to see how they compare to Irre's game.

Day 1

vote normal - "pressure voting another anomolous player", irre was the other bandwagon
voted mono* - because I changed my mind about normal being anomolous
FoSed Irre - I waved my hands because I didn't want to point out someone I thought at the time was a special, but I FoSed Irre over her being suspicious of Ani.
voted DennyB - thought he looked scummy, but mostly trying to get lynch off Irre
voted higgs - mostly trying to get lynch off Irre

Day 2
Voted Mort and stayed with that.


* I want to point out that one of the reasons I feel that mono is probably town has to do with her reaction to my vote. She brushed it off, and it didn't affect how she perceived my gameplay.

[DennyB]

I just did a quick search of Denny's posts, can someone else do the same and tell me what they think.


1 higgs2 - Otto, Town Busdriver
5 Gallstones - Dr. Nick, Town Doctor
9 Ghatanothoa - Patty, Town
13 Normal - Selma, Town
16 MZ - Chief Wiggum, Town Seer

Denny voted the first 2, FoS'd the second 2, can anyone remember what he had to say about MZ?

Who did you vote for gib?

BTW. this is plain and simple bullshit.
I voted higgs to save Irre. Would have voted myself to do the same.
Gall's play was crap.
And if I fos town that makes me scum?
Pain and simple bullshit!

Bullshit as in lies? Which bits aren't true?

How many town did you vote for and fos in the past 2 days gib?

Looks like your just trying to appear helpful and looking for a bandwagon to jump on.

[oblivion]

I'm not going to have time to do that for every single player who is still in the game. I think it would be good to do that for UT, Feck and DP, though. If anyone has some time. They weren't prolific posters compared to Irre and me. I used the in-thread sort mechanism to sort by author.

[Mantisdreamz]

And the more I think on it too, the more the object thing doesn't really make sense.

There has to be some reason for why she was told those things.