Timebomb Game Thread

[irretating]

Feck, get a spreadsheet going, man.

[Feck]

where do you get 2 more feck?

I read day one carefully

Yes.

Feck do you normally pay such close attention to a game?

No I was having a bad day I spotted some things that didn't ring true ,pointed it out and everybody told me I was mad ! I play scum a lot more casually and play town games with a reveal on my hunches ,but this game doesn't work like that . Charlou was not the only one who messed up towns win condition and now UT is missing what was said about specials .

@ OB OK I wasn't adding the one we started with

[gib]

Hi oblivion.

Shit this thread moves fast. Now the kids are at school and I have some time online. Apologies to everyone, but my first priority (after IRL stuff) will be the FF mafia game, seeing as I've invested 2 years of my life into it

OK, I had the benefit of reading the whole of day 1 after day 1 ended, with fresh eyes of being new to the game. I think charlou is legit, because she outed after clearly thinking long and hard about it (after aza's suggestion of a mass outing) and she got a pile of points overnight. I think oblivion is townish because she's been doing proper scum hunting (putting people under pressure, moving on to others). UT is someone that I have a good read on, because of how often we've played mafia together. Outing as a vanilla town I think helps town, though unless we think a mass outing is a good thing I don't recommend other vanilla towns out because then scum can special hunt more easily. Gib indicated a very townish thing that I note mantis has also picked up on. That gib didn't get a load of points overnight suggests to me that mantis is town.

MZ going after charlou today is so weird, even for MZ standards, so I have him as very suspicious. Bolero is pinging, too, following charlou but now putting her doubts about her. Gonzo, I know you'll never let me live down that vote for you on FF, but your game is quite different. I'll try not to trolley track on you, but so far my vote stays.

Aza needs to participate. His mass out idea is one I'd have had at that time in the game, because I tend not to read PG and rules much. I have done this game, just to get my head around this codeword and points thing.

It looks like a vig and scum 'hit' overnight, to me, but the targets seem wrong...they would both be scum targets, and the vig might be having a shocker. MZ has dropped a couple of threats in the thread, I'd like to hear more from him.

someone tell me in the postgame about this towntell i have, i could find a use for that :evilmoustachetwiddle:

[praying]

Is ratz crashing for other people? I keep getting 'cannot find site' and my post took 5 minutes to go through

I am getting get not find site also

[Bolero]

I really wish we had more information. I'm wondering if someone had a view last night and could clear things up for us. I'm NOT suggesting an outing, but I'm wondering if there have been any major vote-pattern changes, or any unusual certainties. MZ seems very certain of gonzo's guilt, for example. Gib seems certain of fuzzy's innocence (although that was his line yesterday, too).

I'd really like to hear more from Gonzo, gib, praying and Aza. Also, I think UT has made some really really useful contributions, and someone out there has deducted points from him, so he's looking townish.

[Feck]

I got Gib was town from day one ,can't quite remember why , but my towndar spotted it .

@gib I could tell you a few of your scum tells but it will £ost you

[irretating]

Hi oblivion.

Shit this thread moves fast. Now the kids are at school and I have some time online. Apologies to everyone, but my first priority (after IRL stuff) will be the FF mafia game, seeing as I've invested 2 years of my life into it

OK, I had the benefit of reading the whole of day 1 after day 1 ended, with fresh eyes of being new to the game. I think charlou is legit, because she outed after clearly thinking long and hard about it (after aza's suggestion of a mass outing) and she got a pile of points overnight. I think oblivion is townish because she's been doing proper scum hunting (putting people under pressure, moving on to others). UT is someone that I have a good read on, because of how often we've played mafia together. Outing as a vanilla town I think helps town, though unless we think a mass outing is a good thing I don't recommend other vanilla towns out because then scum can special hunt more easily. Gib indicated a very townish thing that I note mantis has also picked up on. That gib didn't get a load of points overnight suggests to me that mantis is town.

MZ going after charlou today is so weird, even for MZ standards, so I have him as very suspicious. Bolero is pinging, too, following charlou but now putting her doubts about her. Gonzo, I know you'll never let me live down that vote for you on FF, but your game is quite different. I'll try not to trolley track on you, but so far my vote stays.

Aza needs to participate. His mass out idea is one I'd have had at that time in the game, because I tend not to read PG and rules much. I have done this game, just to get my head around this codeword and points thing.

It looks like a vig and scum 'hit' overnight, to me, but the targets seem wrong...they would both be scum targets, and the vig might be having a shocker. MZ has dropped a couple of threats in the thread, I'd like to hear more from him.

someone tell me in the postgame about this towntell i have, i could find a use for that :evilmoustachetwiddle:

OK that makes me nervous. I have to re-evaluate you and mantis.

And, what is up with that fuzzy thing? I saw it on TR, too.

[praying]

okay I have read

questions:

I believe gonzo also asked this but as far as I know it was not addressed; if charlou is doc why didn't she protect herself?

why does gonzo (I think need to go back and check) KEEP SAYING RAVEN ob put points on him last night and if so how does he know that?

Is our point total our letter or our letter plus one?

[irretating]

okay I have read

questions:

I believe gonzo also asked this but as far as I know it was not addressed; if charlou is doc why didn't she protect herself?

why does gonzo (I think need to go back and check) KEEP SAYING RAVEN ob put points on him last night and if so how does he know that?

Is our point total our letter or our letter plus one?

ob voted him yesterday, but she is mayor, so her one vote became two. So he got two points. I have a spreadsheet otherwise I'd never be able to follow this game.

[praying]

Charlou, Yes, I have that. You are armed and on 6 points, although I called them votes.

The negative 2 for UT is interesting.
I think the negative points could be a scum action. How difficult would it be to use that power without giving yourself away? that is wifom. Disregard.

This post really pinged for me, I mean if it is unnecessary wifom and you realize that BEFORE you posted, why not just remove the offending comment? Why tell us to disregard?

[irretating]

Charlou, Yes, I have that. You are armed and on 6 points, although I called them votes.

The negative 2 for UT is interesting.
I think the negative points could be a scum action. How difficult would it be to use that power without giving yourself away? that is wifom. Disregard.

This post really pinged for me, I mean if it is unnecessary wifom and you realize that BEFORE you posted, why not just remove the offending comment? Why tell us to disregard?

Yeah that stuck out for me, too. Are we supposed to disregard his FoS on UT, or that he was thinking out loud?

[gib]

ok, so the thing that's really bothering me about bolero now is that she's followed Charlou two days, and still has her vote on fuzzy, after she followed Charlou there, but is now trotting out this hypothesis after MZ first advanced it.

unvote; vote bolero

God, there's no mystery. I'm no good at playing town, that's all.

playing can mean acting

[gib]

I got Gib was town from day one ,can't quite remember why , but my towndar spotted it .

@gib I could tell you a few of your scum tells but it will £ost you

i got a good one of dean's he's done a few times now i could swap u!

[Feck]

Charlou was blocked last night .... is that why she couldn't protect herself ?

[gib]

Hi oblivion.

Shit this thread moves fast. Now the kids are at school and I have some time online. Apologies to everyone, but my first priority (after IRL stuff) will be the FF mafia game, seeing as I've invested 2 years of my life into it

OK, I had the benefit of reading the whole of day 1 after day 1 ended, with fresh eyes of being new to the game. I think charlou is legit, because she outed after clearly thinking long and hard about it (after aza's suggestion of a mass outing) and she got a pile of points overnight. I think oblivion is townish because she's been doing proper scum hunting (putting people under pressure, moving on to others). UT is someone that I have a good read on, because of how often we've played mafia together. Outing as a vanilla town I think helps town, though unless we think a mass outing is a good thing I don't recommend other vanilla towns out because then scum can special hunt more easily. Gib indicated a very townish thing that I note mantis has also picked up on. That gib didn't get a load of points overnight suggests to me that mantis is town.

MZ going after charlou today is so weird, even for MZ standards, so I have him as very suspicious. Bolero is pinging, too, following charlou but now putting her doubts about her. Gonzo, I know you'll never let me live down that vote for you on FF, but your game is quite different. I'll try not to trolley track on you, but so far my vote stays.

Aza needs to participate. His mass out idea is one I'd have had at that time in the game, because I tend not to read PG and rules much. I have done this game, just to get my head around this codeword and points thing.

It looks like a vig and scum 'hit' overnight, to me, but the targets seem wrong...they would both be scum targets, and the vig might be having a shocker. MZ has dropped a couple of threats in the thread, I'd like to hear more from him.

someone tell me in the postgame about this towntell i have, i could find a use for that :evilmoustachetwiddle:

OK that makes me nervous. I have to re-evaluate you and mantis.

And, what is up with that fuzzy thing? I saw it on TR, too.

you wanna ask me a question then ask me a question

also, nite all!