Post
by grit » Sat Jun 25, 2011 6:45 pm
DP claims to be Aahz, Skeeve’s main sidekick. For a lot of the game I had actually thought diva and Mantis were that pair.
If they were scum, I don't think gib and Mantis would have fossed Irre so hard when she was tied for the lynch lead but still could have been saved (which she later was). So... gib and Mantis still townish to me.
UT I still find townish, but he was quick to muddy a sorting out of the MSG/b.tern matter to a gib suspicion fight, even parking his vote on gib. b.tern thought he was scum, though she didn’t reveal much about MSG’s swaps and why she might have thought that. Just to note, there’s been a lot of white-knighting from many of us this game, UT’s has been for diva, charlou, and r.c, IMO.
I couldn’t make much else out about what b.tern may have hinted at in the MSG swaps. MSG seems to indicate he did not swap Feck, that Feck was indeed targeted as the scum NK. Maybe Aden was swapped Night 2, but I think MSG would be quick to say, “Don’t worry about it, silly, SCUM HUNT!”
I still think gib has been townish all game, but it merits saying that Feck, Aden, MSG, higgs2, and UT have all sussed gib. But we overwhelmingly voted him mayor.
That leaves me Aza, charlou, r.c, and diva to sort through.
Aza has seemed scummy all game to me, and has at the very least been anti-town.
As I said, I though diva was an Indie special early on. Irre’s opening game comment about Zig’s vote to lynch diva (which he had not made) would seem to indicate diva is not scum; and gib and Irre seemed on opposite views of the matter. She did initially seem skittish of being voted mayor and possibly viewed by our Seer, with Zig and Feck especially picking up on that. I’m not sure how to read it but diva has stuck up for char, r.c, me, UT, Mantis, gib, and even Irre at points. She did make a safe Day 1 lynch vote on Aden and was pretty firm on Msg/b.tern.
I’m still not too sure about r.c. He comes out early against Irre Day 2, but then votes MSG, taking the pressure off Irre. Day 3 he susses diva and clears UT & higgs, so there’s that.
charlou has maybe light posted, but has been helpful to me all game. She still stands out on Irre’s town/scum list as being listed in between. charlou did the same with Irre, putting Irre in a middle pile between town and scum. She parked her vote on MSG and left on the day diva said we should have expected her contribution to kick in, but she hasn’t been as absent to me as DP or Aden or Aza. She has a very townish sounding post Day 2, over the Feck death. I still very much don’t like the 2 missed days of votes.
So, I guess I’ve got DP, Mantis, gib, and UT as townish.
diva and charlou are questionable.
Aza and r.c I’m leaning as scumish.
