Archive: Zombie Day 1, 2, 3, 4, 5

[charlou]

oblivion, I didn't get UT's idea either.

I think town might consider mono's opinion about UT .. he is very smooth when he's scum. Will look back over his posts ... Irre, you're playing it smooth too ...

I wouldn't discount Mort as scum, even if her reason for not being around is legit, but I'd be reluctant to vote for her .. unless she is noticed online during night actions.


totals, the zombie night actions were a once in a full blue moon thing: http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 76#p624776

[irretating]

Interesting. It certainly puts ghat under the spotlight (I noticed he was lurking in this thread earlier, hasn't posted anything). I've been worried that one of oblivion / useless is scum. If I had to pick one, I'd say it was useless. The question about morticia is interesting.. it's like he's trying to get us interested in voting her. Of course, maneki did return to post.

[Uselesstwit]

he's kind of defending mz and ghat. I don't think he would have voted themaneki today if he was on his team. It was pretty obvious that mort, themaeki or mono was going to be the lynch today. He could have hidden his vote on any of the three without raising suspicion, no reason to go for a team mate.

I'm kicking myself for not hitting him harder about the post you quoted.

[Rob]

This is the list Feck posted in this thread:

ok i will do a list of who I think is scum in order (ish )
12 TheManeki
5 Morticia
6 MagicZiggy
11 ScienceRob

10 Ghat: 14 ut
4 Mononoke

:13 irre :15 Oblivion

3 Feck

I'm not sure on the ration of town to scum but Charlou mentioned 1 or 2. I think that morticia, Themaneki or MZ are most likely. I think Feck would put people he was suspicious as a cover for fellow scum. I want to say MZ but he was very erratic, I don't know what to make of his posts. Mortica is also suspect but it has been so long since he logged in... but that doesn't clear his name.

"FoS" from me is on MZ.

[Uselesstwit]

for that matter why wasn't ghat included in with irre oblivion and myself? His game has looked town and he's a good solid player.

[charlou]

When he's scum, Feck's good at posting 'analysis' and fuzzy reasoning that looks helpful to town. He's also savvy at mixing up the inclusion of scum among his foses and voting for scum team mates either when it's safe (they're unlikely to be lynched, as in early in the game/day) or when they're looking like toast anyway. This mixing up of strategies makes it difficult to glean anything about other players from his posts.

[oblivion]

oblivion, I didn't get UT's idea either.

yabbut you were headed to bed after a night's work.

I think town might consider mono's opinion about UT .. he is very smooth when he's scum. Will look back over his posts ... Irre, you're playing it smooth too ...

Yeah. How good is mono's scumdar usually, though? I don't know yet, personally, so I'm not sure how much to weight that.

I wouldn't discount Mort as scum, even if her reason for not being around is legit, but I'd be reluctant to vote for her .. unless she is noticed online during night actions.

learning she hadn't been online at all today was the reason I changed my vote.

This is why quiet, prickly town players need to rethink their strategy. they are giving scum a lot of hiding places. The best thing you can do for town is participate at least enough for other players to get a read.

If we have a seer, and he/she hasn't viewed at least one of irre and UT yet, please consider that for tonight. I assume I've been viewed since I'm the mayor, and so are the rest of the players. If the seer hasn't viewed me yet I hope it's because they are dead certain I'm town and don't want to waste the view.

[charlou]

I think that morticia, Themaneki or MZ are most likely.
"FoS" from me is on MZ.

I'd give themaneki the benefit of the doubt at least until we've seen his contributions for day 4. I think MZ is town because of his maverick behaviour earlier .. that kind of play was too loud and uncoordinated for a scum team player. Morticia, benefit of the doubt unless she's seen overnight.

[oblivion]

In a regular 14 player game I'd expect at least 3 scum, maybe 4. Adding in the revenant factor and the possibility of a reanimated zombie coming back as scum instead of town, I'm leaning toward 3 initially. So, if we somehow kill 1 more scum and the game doesn't end, then denny needs to go to the top of the lynch list to eliminate that uncertainty.

[irretating]

This is the list Feck posted in this thread:

ok i will do a list of who I think is scum in order (ish )
12 TheManeki
5 Morticia
6 MagicZiggy
11 ScienceRob

10 Ghat: 14 ut
4 Mononoke

:13 irre :15 Oblivion

3 Feck

I'm not sure on the ration of town to scum but Charlou mentioned 1 or 2. I think that morticia, Themaneki or MZ are most likely. I think Feck would put people he was suspicious as a cover for fellow scum. I want to say MZ but he was very erratic, I don't know what to make of his posts. Mortica is also suspect but it has been so long since he logged in... but that doesn't clear his name.

"FoS" from me is on MZ.

Looking at that list, ghat jumps out, as does ziggy. The fact that sciencerob found and posted it has me leaning more for him being town. I'm thinking it's either ghat or UT, and then perhaps oblivion.

I'm going to look over oblivion's posts to see what she said about feck. (as for my posts, dont' bother I fell hook line and sinker for feck as being town)

[oblivion]

I think I stopped doubting feck sometime yesterday. goddamnit.

[charlou]

oblivion, agreed about denny

This is a strange game, but I must say it's a hoot to be able to continue to play throughout, even as a zombie ... in fact, an advantage of that is I can FoS players and inject ideas without any personal repercussions ... most interesting ...

[oblivion]

Yeah. I think I'd give up my lynch vote to be able to speak with a known alignment at this point, though from my perspective the evidence I'm town is all but overwhelming. If I haven't been viewed yet I'm going to have words with the seer after this game. There's absolutely no upside to letting town elect me mayor without a fuss if I'm not going to be viewed.

[Morticia]

Hi guys. RL has had me out of the house much more than usual. I have been helping a friend move out an apartment that she has to be out of by Fri and she has had no help other than me for the last two days. I have had 0 time to read the posts yet. I'm going to catch up on yesterday and today's threads before I make any comments. I'm actually surprised I wasn't lynched for not being here at all. I apologize for the lack of participation.

[Rob]

Just finished reading day 3 again. What about Feck's post makes you suspicious of Ghat?