Mythadventures game thread: Mythconceptions

[grit]

Actually, what I'd like to know is why you have me in your scum list?

Why did you ignore this question, grit?

I haven't ignored it. I did in fact list two main concerns in my first summary today: "charlou – Missing 2 days of votes is a huge ping for me. That and posting are two of the most important weapons a townie has." I think UT is scumish too, and UT seemed very protective of you on Day 1. The teamishness of it works for me in trying to sort out who all are scum together. But if it came down to it, and I had my druthers, I'd vote DP, then UT, then either you or Aza.

[b.ternarius]

Eeesh, you guys post a lot in mafia!

I've skimmed enough to understand that MSG has caught a fair amount of suspicion for vaguely worded half-outing and for a not exemplary voting record re lynches. I want to read a bit more and especially look at the voting records and MSG's previous posts before responding to those suspicions, since I'm still trying to get a grip on what's already happened in the game.

FWIW, not scum.

Did you find those little display/sort boxes on the bottom, where you can sort each day by author post? There's nothing like a full careful read-through, but those author sort thingies have really been helpful too.

I hadn't, thanks, that will help.

Er... when exactly does day end?

[b.ternarius]

Eeesh, you guys post a lot in mafia!

I've skimmed enough to understand that MSG has caught a fair amount of suspicion for vaguely worded half-outing and for a not exemplary voting record re lynches. I want to read a bit more and especially look at the voting records and MSG's previous posts before responding to those suspicions, since I'm still trying to get a grip on what's already happened in the game.

FWIW, not scum.

hi borealis, that sounds fair enough and thanks for subbing in!

Welcome. Having managed to live a mere few hours subbing in Elfquest at TR, I was jonesing for a game, so this is good.

[higgs2]

Anyone have a read on grit?

[gib]

Anyone have a read on grit?

nearly

[grit]

I hadn't, thanks, that will help.

Er... when exactly does day end?

I think it's at 8PM, EST tonight.

[grit]

I hate to have a special out at this point.There's a slim possibility that may not have been what MSG meant, but there's no possibility the majority of players are not going to see it as such...

this is kinda silly because scum are reading this thread and if msg/borealis is not scum, then scum will surely assume what everyone else is thinking. iow scum already know if the out was a scumbluff or a real special shitting it.

msg/borealis has a huge red sign over her that says SPECIAL and msg is the one that put it there. There's 2 ways of clearing this up, either borealis outs or we lynch her. The only possible downside i can see to outing is if msgorealis is in fact vanilla and is trying to act 'specially' to draw the nightkill - ie vanilla meatshield - but that isn't what it looked like to me. What it looked like to me was someone trying to save themselves from the lynch. Now that selfsaving may have been legitimate and pro town, or it may have been scummy as hell and anti town

so grit, what am i missing here?

I don't think you're missing. I didn't mean b.ternarius shouldn't full out if half-outing is what MSG meant (which likely it was), just that it's bad timing for town. Seems to me there's likely 2 pro-town specials left, and I hate to have one out at this point in the game. But, yeah, that may be unavoidable, and it will be interesting to see what b.ternarius claims on the MSG follow-up. Any pro-town player could say what MSG did, "voting me is a bad idea", but I agree that that's only usually used when intending a pro-town special claim. I'm with you in the sense that if voting MSG is indeed a bad idea, we need to have b.ternarius tell us just why that is.

[gib]

grit you're making a question out of something that afaics has been cleared up, look:

Eeesh, you guys post a lot in mafia!

I've skimmed enough to understand that MSG has caught a fair amount of suspicion for vaguely worded half-outing and for a not exemplary voting record re lynches. I want to read a bit more and especially look at the voting records and MSG's previous posts before responding to those suspicions, since I'm still trying to get a grip on what's already happened in the game.

FWIW, not scum.

[grit]

Current lynch vote:

MSG/b.ternarius ....... 3 ...... (Aza, [/s]charlou[/s], higgs2, charlou)

[gib]

borealis what do you say?

[b.ternarius]

Well, given that half-out leaves me without a lot of choice, I'd prefer not to see town waste a lynch on me, so I'm going to out fully - though I wish MSG had not done that. I'm the bus driver.

I'm not sure about outing MSG's days 1 and 2 actions, since I haven't noticed in the threads (which admittedly I skimmed) whether the switchees admitted to the switches. Prefer to wait until later in the day now I know there's some time left.

[gib]

you're right, do not out the switches yet

[gib]

aza what do you make of this?

[Azathoth]

Its testable I suppose. Strange that nobody has spoken up about being busdrivered though. Unconvinced but I don't think b. should be today's lynch

##unvote ##

[gib]

totally agree

so how long should we give it for the switchees to out themselves? i'm thinking we have about 6 hours left (i think) so if we haven't heard anything within say 2 hours then borealis needs to start talking