Mythadventures game thread: Mythconceptions

[gib]

MSG half an out is worse than no out at all tbh

[Azathoth]

meh, let's just save Ob the trouble of finding a sub. That unvote on day one was classic wishy washy scum voting to try to save a teammate. MSG already gave some half arsed excuse yesterday. If there is a sub we pretty much need to let them off the hook and get a fresh read. I would rather not go down that road

[oblivion]

I have found a sub for MSG. I have requested that her registration be approved. she should join the game soon.

[gib]

i was thinking same thing as aza but hey fresh meat is fresh meat

[Azathoth]

If we aren't going to kill MSG today they need to be seer viewed as a priority. I have seen scumsubs skate through to endgame too many times

[gib]

or just take msg's soft out as scummy unless the sub wants to make it a full out

[oblivion]

b.ternarius is subbed in for MSG

[grit]

meh, let's just save Ob the trouble of finding a sub. That unvote on day one was classic wishy washy scum voting to try to save a teammate. MSG already gave some half arsed excuse yesterday. If there is a sub we pretty much need to let them off the hook and get a fresh read. I would rather not go down that road

That "save Ob the trouble of finding a sub" is not winning you any points in my book, Aza. If it's borealis, I don't think she'd expect any free pass today. She just subbed in the TR Elf game where the quitter was likely scum, and sure enough she quickly was killed as scum. I just remain convinced there's 3 players who seem scummier than MSG to me. Though it would have helped considerably if MSG had said something more in his one post above.

I don't like that both sides on a DP or MSG vote seem stuck, but even if we were to ask our GM for a time extension today, that too may not be fair game play. I think the MSG sub may have enough time to catch up, so I'd like to at least them them a chance to speak to the matter. Besides, I could easily support a charlou, UT, or even Aza lynch at the moment. Is there some agreement that 2-3 scum are likely still in the game?

[divagreen]

Is that borealis?

xpost with Grit.

[divagreen]

Thanks, r.c, I would have completely missed that.

Also on rethinking the DP thing, is it fair for us to lynch a player who's dazed and gagged? That seems to have been what scum did with Aden, that is, a very scumish sort of thing to do?

Grit...why are you offering this up but DP is still in your pile of lynchables today? That does not make sense.

I am wondering about Adenosine's gag order and then death. I am wondering if they are connected? I am concerned that DP will bite the dust before we have a chance to talk to him. Sorry, but I want to give him a chance to respond.

[grit]

i thought we were working under the assumption of a non lethal day vig typa thing?

higgs2, with help from charlou, brought up a silencer/immobilizer role, which makes good sense.

[b.ternarius]

Hi guys.

I'm subbing for MSG. I'll try to catch up over the day.

(I am borealis at TR. Apparently someone's already using that name here. Poser! )

[grit]

or just take msg's soft out as scummy unless the sub wants to make it a full out

I hate to have a special out at this point. There's a slim possibility that may not have been what MSG meant, but there's no possibility the majority of players are not going to see it as such at this point (town and scum alike). I think it will be helpful for us to see what the sub will decide to say about it, and for us to carefully examine any claim or non-claim made. Still, since it's a sub we're talking about, I'd be happy looking closely at other suspects too, for our lynch today.

I'm inclined to think most of the scum left are vanilla, maybe with a roleblocker.

[Azathoth]

You are really fucking yourself over with all this whiteknighting of MSbt. Also stop trying to push the lynch onto me

[grit]

Thanks, r.c, I would have completely missed that.

Also on rethinking the DP thing, is it fair for us to lynch a player who's dazed and gagged? That seems to have been what scum did with Aden, that is, a very scumish sort of thing to do?

Grit...why are you offering this up but DP is still in your pile of lynchables today? That does not make sense.

Was i? I didn't mean too. I only mean that DP is still tops on my scum pile, and that charlou had even previously agreed with that - it was something on which we had reached consensus.