Stargate SG1 - game thread

[Bilirubin]

She's kind of drawing a lot of attention to herself, which scum tend not to do. Not sure I've seen her scum game yet, but if this is it its worse that gib's. Might be worth considering some of the votes on her BW, the hit and runs by higgs and gonzo in particular.

[MattShizzle]

I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

What sort of votes would not qualify as random on Day 1?

Ones with any sort of reasoning behind them. Coming straight out and slapping a random vote on someone before any discussion at all is bullshit.

This. And rather scummy to boot.

[Don't Panic]

Self voting is scummy by convention, like 3rd or 4th on the bw being scum, rules of thumb are wrong more often than right, irre hasn't posted enough yet for me to read her either way so a mayor vote gets people talking, as does a lynch vote.

##Vote Irre##

But, surprisingly, not so much for the self-vote.
More so for apologizing that she broke Guapo's rule.
The apology seems a bit too glittery.

What's guapos rule?

[divagreen]

Self voting is scummy by convention, like 3rd or 4th on the bw being scum, rules of thumb are wrong more often than right, irre hasn't posted enough yet for me to read her either way so a mayor vote gets people talking, as does a lynch vote.

##Vote Irre##

But, surprisingly, not so much for the self-vote.
More so for apologizing that she broke Guapo's rule.
The apology seems a bit too glittery.

What's guapos rule?

Don't answer for other people, allow them to answer for themselves.

[b.ternarius]

I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

What sort of votes would not qualify as random on Day 1?

Ones with any sort of reasoning behind them. Coming straight out and slapping a random vote on someone before any discussion at all is bullshit.

Gotta agree, if only because I said something similar about day one town lynch votes not being terribly significant in the Innsmouth game on day one and was damn near lynched over it. I learned. So why are we getting a little pack of random voters? If it's all sort of in-group teasing, it's going to be confusing for non ingroupers, guys.

[divagreen]

I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

What sort of votes would not qualify as random on Day 1?

Ones with any sort of reasoning behind them. Coming straight out and slapping a random vote on someone before any discussion at all is bullshit.

This. And rather scummy to boot.

Matt, you are being uber followy there, buddy.

[divagreen]

I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

What sort of votes would not qualify as random on Day 1?

Ones with any sort of reasoning behind them. Coming straight out and slapping a random vote on someone before any discussion at all is bullshit.

Gotta agree, if only because I said something similar about day one town lynch votes not being terribly significant in the Innsmouth game on day one and was damn near lynched over it. I learned. So why are we getting a little pack of random voters? If it's all sort of in-group teasing, it's going to be confusing for non ingroupers, guys.

What is honestly bugging me is that Aza felt the need to poin it out when I have seen Aza himself do this. He is acting like he has never seen this before and therefore it kind of looks to me like is distancing himself in a subtle way while seeming active. It also sets up for a genral tone of future suspicion; he can point later and say, "that looked scummy" when it just looks like the usual d1 'everyone trying to stick out their feelers and see what happens' to me.

[b.ternarius]

Okay, but I still think if not scummy it's not good practice.

[Zigmen]

I have to go to work soon. I'll be back before nightfall, thanks to the time extension.

[Azathoth]

I'm also wondering what's with all the random votes.

What sort of votes would not qualify as random on Day 1?

Ones with any sort of reasoning behind them. Coming straight out and slapping a random vote on someone before any discussion at all is bullshit.

Gotta agree, if only because I said something similar about day one town lynch votes not being terribly significant in the Innsmouth game on day one and was damn near lynched over it. I learned. So why are we getting a little pack of random voters? If it's all sort of in-group teasing, it's going to be confusing for non ingroupers, guys.

What is honestly bugging me is that Aza felt the need to poin it out when I have seen Aza himself do this. He is acting like he has never seen this before and therefore it kind of looks to me like is distancing himself in a subtle way while seeming active. It also sets up for a genral tone of future suspicion; he can point later and say, "that looked scummy" when it just looks like the usual d1 'everyone trying to stick out their feelers and see what happens' to me.

There is a difference between poking a quiet one with a vote later in the day and a the first couple of pages being nothing but random votes. No discussion, nothing

[divagreen]

What is honestly bugging me is that Aza felt the need to poin it out when I have seen Aza himself do this. He is acting like he has never seen this before and therefore it kind of looks to me like is distancing himself in a subtle way while seeming active. It also sets up for a genral tone of future suspicion; he can point later and say, "that looked scummy" when it just looks like the usual d1 'everyone trying to stick out their feelers and see what happens' to me.

There is a difference between poking a quiet one with a vote later in the day and a the first couple of pages being nothing but random votes. No discussion, nothing

Uh...I seem to remember you voting for me early in the game just so you could watch me flail all day.

I am less concerned aboout those and more concerned about the shoddy reason votes. For instance, what do you think of Gonzo's reason for voting Irre? Especially considering he self-mayor voted in the Russian Roulette game? He was town in that game. I have a big fat FOS on him at the mo.

[Don't Panic]

Self voting is scummy by convention, like 3rd or 4th on the bw being scum, rules of thumb are wrong more often than right, irre hasn't posted enough yet for me to read her either way so a mayor vote gets people talking, as does a lynch vote.

##Vote Irre##

But, surprisingly, not so much for the self-vote.
More so for apologizing that she broke Guapo's rule.
The apology seems a bit too glittery.

What's guapos rule?

Don't answer for other people, allow them to answer for themselves.

Makes sense.

Anyway, ##unvote feck##

Time for food, and a leisurely read.

[r.c]

Voting amok as mayor for being MVP in the last game.

@@vote amok@@

[Feck]

Zigmen just posted about a conspiracy to see if anyone would jump in his Wifom ...that Pings a little .

[Bilirubin]

Zigmen just posted about a conspiracy to see if anyone would jump in his Wifom ...that Pings a little .

How so?