Carnivale Game Thread

[Uselesstwit]

I buy this for now, who are you're picks besides ghat?

[higgs2]

Well I want to say morticia, but with her it's a 50/50 deal because she is often quiet as scum and as town.

Irre makes me suspicious with her silly questions and also that tl;dr blow by blow report from yesterday/today. I haven't seen her such a detailed "summary" with so little content.

Gibsy is almost giddy with posting copy cat posts.

Ghat -- does he really lack that much self control that he'd act that way out of grumpiness? Or is is character based?

UT -- you fos'd me over very little. Which is fine but you said I was the *scummiest* one because of nitpicky goofy shit. That's what scum do so that they seem like they're scum hunting.

[higgs2]

oh also suspicious of the squid. The whole "my mentor is offline" thing stinks like a sardine in the sun.

[mononoke]

This is what I have:

higgs2: no read
Mononoke: scummy as hell. Very cock sure.
Morticia: scummy to the max, talk about hiding a scum vote. I gave her the benefit of the doubt yesterday. My vote stays.
DennyB: townish
Charlou: claimed town role - but vanilla: townish
Ghat: ?????wtf
gib: no read
Animavore: claimed he is unrecruitable, made himself a target. I think town. Could be lying.
Callan: townish; attracting votes which I find interesting.
Uselesstwit: no read.
Irre: has made the most detailed day 1 summary. some confusion over night 0: Has bee cleared by Charlou via zigmen view!
MZ: a lot of analysis over Mantis role. I thought it was important to understand it. Others may disagree.
The Curious Squid: Noob, coached and a little scummy tbh

The Irre clearance is interesting. Zig suspected enough to view. I'm keeping an eye on that.
Ghat's whole dummy spit still has him as town. It's very strange.
Ani's claim is worrying if true. If recruitment was an option of scum, I hope it's been taken out with the demise of Mantis.

So I would eliminate the following from a vote today. Charlou, Ani, Irre, Ghat.

My vote stays on Morticia.

Posting limited today. I have end of term festivities to attend to.
This may be the last you here from me before nightfall unless I get a peak in about 4-5 hours.

This mortica bandwagon is pathetic, MZ.

And is my being cock sure what makes me scummy.

[Uselesstwit]

Well I want to say morticia, but with her it's a 50/50 deal because she is often quiet as scum and as town.

Irre makes me suspicious with her silly questions and also that tl;dr blow by blow report from yesterday/today. I haven't seen her such a detailed "summary" with so little content.

Gibsy is almost giddy with posting copy cat posts.

Ghat -- does he really lack that much self control that he'd act that way out of grumpiness? Or is is character based?

UT -- you fos'd me over very little. Which is fine but you said I was the *scummiest* one because of nitpicky goofy shit. That's what scum do so that they seem like they're scum hunting.

No I fos'd you for playing differently than normal. you're not going after people and your possible scum list is flimsy as hell. irre is guitly for being helpful, ghat for throwing a tizzy, me for fosing you over what you think were light weight reasons. I'll give you gibs but still that's fairly weak.

[mononoke]

This is what I have:

higgs2: no read
Mononoke: scummy as hell. Very cock sure.
Morticia: scummy to the max, talk about hiding a scum vote. I gave her the benefit of the doubt yesterday. My vote stays.
DennyB: townish
Charlou: claimed town role - but vanilla: townish
Ghat: ?????wtf
gib: no read
Animavore: claimed he is unrecruitable, made himself a target. I think town. Could be lying.
Callan: townish; attracting votes which I find interesting.
Uselesstwit: no read.
Irre: has made the most detailed day 1 summary. some confusion over night 0: Has bee cleared by Charlou via zigmen view!
MZ: a lot of analysis over Mantis role. I thought it was important to understand it. Others may disagree.
The Curious Squid: Noob, coached and a little scummy tbh

The Irre clearance is interesting. Zig suspected enough to view. I'm keeping an eye on that.
Ghat's whole dummy spit still has him as town. It's very strange.
Ani's claim is worrying if true. If recruitment was an option of scum, I hope it's been taken out with the demise of Mantis.

So I would eliminate the following from a vote today. Charlou, Ani, Irre, Ghat.

My vote stays on Morticia.

Posting limited today. I have end of term festivities to attend to.
This may be the last you here from me before nightfall unless I get a peak in about 4-5 hours.

Yet another summary that i broadly agree with (although i think Squid seems townish, for now.)These summaries can't all be written by scum so Occam says we're on to something here.

if Mort and/or Mono are not scum then i will hang up my mafia hat in shame. Personally i'd rather go for Mono, but the consensus seems to be to take out Mort today so i'll happily go with that.

Vote Mort

This reeks of scum. if you think I'm scum you should try and get me lynched, following the consensus & constantly 'broadly' agreeing with the consensus is lazy playing. I thought you were scum on day one. The overly aggressive set off alarms for me, it seemed phony. On day two you dropped out from scum hunting and is floating about, why is there this sudden change in strategy? Is it because you couldn't sustain the fake enthusiasm?

[higgs2]

Wow useless twerp buckles under pressure!

[higgs2]

Well I want to say morticia, but with her it's a 50/50 deal because she is often quiet as scum and as town.

Irre makes me suspicious with her silly questions and also that tl;dr blow by blow report from yesterday/today. I haven't seen her such a detailed "summary" with so little content.

Gibsy is almost giddy with posting copy cat posts.

Ghat -- does he really lack that much self control that he'd act that way out of grumpiness? Or is is character based?

UT -- you fos'd me over very little. Which is fine but you said I was the *scummiest* one because of nitpicky goofy shit. That's what scum do so that they seem like they're scum hunting.

No I fos'd you for playing differently than normal. you're not going after people and your possible scum list is flimsy as hell. irre is guitly for being helpful, ghat for throwing a tizzy, me for fosing you over what you think were light weight reasons. I'll give you gibs but still that's fairly weak.

lol you did ask. What is this tizzy crap? Everyone's talking about tizzy's. There's a difference between telling people they suck and why, and self voting because you're pissed.

[higgs2]

Charloo am I right you are a mason? Are there any other masons? If you're not a mason,then what.

[Uselesstwit]

This is what I have:

higgs2: no read
Mononoke: scummy as hell. Very cock sure.
Morticia: scummy to the max, talk about hiding a scum vote. I gave her the benefit of the doubt yesterday. My vote stays.
DennyB: townish
Charlou: claimed town role - but vanilla: townish
Ghat: ?????wtf
gib: no read
Animavore: claimed he is unrecruitable, made himself a target. I think town. Could be lying.
Callan: townish; attracting votes which I find interesting.
Uselesstwit: no read.
Irre: has made the most detailed day 1 summary. some confusion over night 0: Has bee cleared by Charlou via zigmen view!
MZ: a lot of analysis over Mantis role. I thought it was important to understand it. Others may disagree.
The Curious Squid: Noob, coached and a little scummy tbh

The Irre clearance is interesting. Zig suspected enough to view. I'm keeping an eye on that.
Ghat's whole dummy spit still has him as town. It's very strange.
Ani's claim is worrying if true. If recruitment was an option of scum, I hope it's been taken out with the demise of Mantis.

So I would eliminate the following from a vote today. Charlou, Ani, Irre, Ghat.

My vote stays on Morticia.

Posting limited today. I have end of term festivities to attend to.
This may be the last you here from me before nightfall unless I get a peak in about 4-5 hours.

Yet another summary that i broadly agree with (although i think Squid seems townish, for now.)These summaries can't all be written by scum so Occam says we're on to something here.

if Mort and/or Mono are not scum then i will hang up my mafia hat in shame. Personally i'd rather go for Mono, but the consensus seems to be to take out Mort today so i'll happily go with that.

Vote Mort

This reeks of scum. if you think I'm scum you should try and get me lynched, following the consensus & constantly 'broadly' agreeing with the consensus is lazy playing. I thought you were scum on day one. The overly aggressive set off alarms for me, it seemed phony. On day two you dropped out from scum hunting and is floating about, why is there this sudden change in strategy? Is it because you couldn't sustain the fake enthusiasm?

This is a really good point. but if ani is right there is another explanation, he might have been recruited.

[Uselesstwit]

Wow useless twerp buckles under pressure!

the pressure of a halfassed fos? we all know better than that higgs.

[Morticia]

I'm back, as promised. I have been busy with RL stuff and have been sleeping at weird for me hours. I am going for a re-read of today's posts but from my first skim through I still stand by my vote on Callan. I also would like to "agree" with the fos on Gib for being too agreeable.

[mononoke]

I'm back, as promised. I have been busy with RL stuff and have been sleeping at weird for me hours. I am going for a re-read of today's posts but from my first skim through I still stand by my vote on Callan. I also would like to "agree" with the fos on Gib for being too agreeable.

what happened to you. You were AWOL

[Morticia]

Ok...re-read done. I have a thought on the the blocking. I think there has to be only one blocker at this point and it is most likely a scum prostitute. My reason for thinking this is because only one person per night has reported being blocked and described it like a prostitute visit. Also as it seems I will be dead today, when I flip town look at Callan and then Gib.

[charlou]

Higgs, I'm not a mason. I only knew from my role PM that I am catatonic Apollonia who is a telepathic seer and had no night action of my own ... the posting restriction (the smilies) remained as long as Sofie lived ... I got the view information PMed via the GM and didn't know who Sofie was until Zigmen was killed. I thought at first after Zigmen/Sofie was killed that I might have seer ability of my own, but a PM to oblivion confirmed that's not the case.

look at Callan and then Gib.

People already are ... What are your reasons?