Carnivale Game Thread

[The Curious Squid]

Fair enough if i get booted, my own fault and i'll remember it for next time.

[charlou]

ok one other thing a night zero prostitute sounds like a scum blocker. It's not like the town blocker is going to stop the scum from killing on night zero.

Errr, but what was a scum prozzie going to stop town from doing?

seer can be blocked.

From the Bones Yard OP:

This game has some night zero actions. Once I have those actions in hand and processed, I'll start the day 1 thread.

This suggests it wasn't only the blocker who was active on night one, irre.

[oblivion]

I have PMed Squid and I'll post my decision here as well. Squid will stay in the game because
1. this is his first game, and I think he was genuinely unaware of the restriction and why it is a restriction
2. posting this particular PM was not game-breaking (which is why there is a restriction in the first place)

Move along, carnies, the game wasn't gaffed.

[The Curious Squid]

Sorry all!

[gib]

I've only had time to skim today's posts but i agree we shouldn't get too sidetracked about Mantis' role unless we get some further info.

Meanwhile, i'veseen nothing to change my mind from the list i made yeterday:

Subject: Carnivale - Day 1

I have to go soon, here's my thoughts so far


Townish
DennyB
Charlou
Callan
Uselesstwit
Irre
The Curious Squid
Feck

Unsure
higgs2
MZ
Zigmen

Scummy
Mononoke
Morticia
Mantisdreamz


Just Weird
Ghat/gbot
Animavore

I'd be keen to hear if any of the players i've listed as townish have similar thoughts.

I will definitely be back in about 8 hours, may get a chance to catch up sooner but doubt i'll have time to post before then.

I think we made some good progress yesterday and i'm hoping we can build on that.

[mononoke]

ok one other thing a night zero prostitute sounds like a scum blocker. It's not like the town blocker is going to stop the scum from killing on night zero.

Errr, but what was a scum prozzie going to stop town from doing?

seer can be blocked.

From the Bones Yard OP:

This game has some night zero actions. Once I have those actions in hand and processed, I'll start the day 1 thread.

This suggests it wasn't only the blocker who was active on night one, irre.

I though Zigmen had a night action on day zero

[charlou]

Sorry all!

You're lucky .. I would have spanked you.

[The Curious Squid]

Sorry all!

You're lucky .. I would have spanked you.

[charlou]

ok one other thing a night zero prostitute sounds like a scum blocker. It's not like the town blocker is going to stop the scum from killing on night zero.

Errr, but what was a scum prozzie going to stop town from doing?

seer can be blocked.

From the Bones Yard OP:

This game has some night zero actions. Once I have those actions in hand and processed, I'll start the day 1 thread.

This suggests it wasn't only the blocker who was active on night one, irre.

I though Zigmen had a night action on day zero

I got no indication of that. I got the results of his night 1 view .. nothing for night 0.

[mononoke]

^^ Ah ok, I thought that was a night zero view. Since your character is supposed to telepathically get all of his views but given that you didn't get anything from night 0 it's seems like he wasn't active on night zero. So what was the blocker blocking. scum blocker had no target to block since there weren't any town actions. town blocker has nothing to block as well. :scratch:

[DennyB]

It said Mantis was an "enabler". I think she had a role where she could recruit people. I have reason to believe, given my role, that there are recruiters.

Can you elaboriate some more on this Ani?

At this point My sus is similar to day 1.

My vote will either go to Morti or Ghat but there is alot of day left for things to change.

I think Callen is looking a bit more scummy with her logic.

This game is odd to me with night 0 actions, no mayor, etc..

[mononoke]

^^ Ah ok, I thought that was a night zero view. Since your character is supposed to telepathically get all of his views but given that you didn't get anything from night 0 it's seems like he wasn't active on night zero. So what was the blocker blocking. scum blocker had no target to block since there weren't any town actions. town blocker has nothing to block as well. :scratch:

wait the town blocker could have blocked the recruiter.

[The Curious Squid]

Has Ghat even been on? Seems too quite after his antics yesterday...

[charlou]

^^ Ah ok, I thought that was a night zero view. Since your character is supposed to telepathically get all of his views but given that you didn't get anything from night 0 it's seems like he wasn't active on night zero. So what was the blocker blocking. scum blocker had no target to block since there weren't any town actions. town blocker has nothing to block as well. :scratch:

wait the town blocker could have blocked the recruiter.

That's what I'm thinking.

And would also very much like Ani to elaborate on what he knows .. but only if it's not risky for town.

[Animavore]

^^ Ah ok, I thought that was a night zero view. Since your character is supposed to telepathically get all of his views but given that you didn't get anything from night 0 it's seems like he wasn't active on night zero. So what was the blocker blocking. scum blocker had no target to block since there weren't any town actions. town blocker has nothing to block as well. :scratch:

wait the town blocker could have blocked the recruiter.

That's what I'm thinking.

And would also very much like Ani to elaborate on what he knows .. but only if it's not risky for town.

I already said, here http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 64#p693064