Old West Mafia game thread

[Uselesstwit]

and zigmen as well, i almost was convinced to vote for him.

[Zigmen]

MZ looks a little better now. RC looks worse.

And MZ, spare me your "Zigmen and Jerome are too stupid for words" bullshit.

I gave a list of 5 players (With Mantis on it) and said that 2 were Scum. I, like you, removed UT from that list. I think my radar is pretty stellar, thanyouverumuch. Now, let's bury the hatchet and work together without the insults. ok?

RC and DP are the only players left that are, imho, still not cleared in some way.

Does anyone's list differ from mine?

If so, why?

[Magicziggy]

Zigmen had to be town. No way scum would play like that.

[Zigmen]

Zigmen had to be town. No way scum would play like that.

Thanks. There was also the voting thing from day 1 where neither Gonzo nor I could possibly have been scum unless we both were, which was impossible, but however you found your way to the conclusion, it works.

Now, we might want to discuss a mass out?

Or do we still want to play like puritans?

[Uselesstwit]

i like feck for the second most likely scum. the 2 people that haven't voted for one of the successful lynches are dp and jerome. i still think a post restriction on a scum would be to harsh so that leaves dp. if it's not him then i'd say feck, his vote yesterday was pretty out of nowhere and he does love bussing teammates. also the no vote on a 25 hour day doesn't look good.

[Magicziggy]

I've claimed as vanilla. Others should decide for themselves. Seems likely that only a don remains rendering a seer useless.

[Zigmen]

i like feck for the second most likely scum. the 2 people that haven't voted for one of the successful lynches are dp and jerome. i still think a post restriction on a scum would be to harsh so that leaves dp. if it's not him then i'd say feck, his vote yesterday was pretty out of nowhere and he does love bussing teammates. also the no vote on a 25 hour day doesn't look good.

I can back this plan.

MZ, you in?

[Magicziggy]

MZ looks a little better now. RC looks worse.

And MZ, spare me your "Zigmen and Jerome are too stupid for words" bullshit.

I gave a list of 5 players (With Mantis on it) and said that 2 were Scum. I, like you, removed UT from that list. I think my radar is pretty stellar, thanyouverumuch. Now, let's bury the hatchet and work together without the insults. ok?

RC and DP are the only players left that are, imho, still not cleared in some way.

Does anyone's list differ from mine?

If so, why?

I take offense to your "I wasn't talking to you" tone. I don't hold grudges. I have no idea at all about why you are so protective of Jerome. Any mention seemed to give you amo on me. That to me was stupid. I'm glad you saw sense in the end.

For me I have a short list of one atm. DP. It's a starting point. But nailing a don can be tricky.

[Zigmen]

I've claimed as vanilla. Others should decide for themselves. Seems likely that only a don remains rendering a seer useless.

Yeah, i saw that. I kinda wanted the approval of a majority before anyone outed, but i see why you did. Good job.

I'm in favor of a mass out. Tomorrow probably makes more sense than tonight, though.

[Magicziggy]

i like feck for the second most likely scum. the 2 people that haven't voted for one of the successful lynches are dp and jerome. i still think a post restriction on a scum would be to harsh so that leaves dp. if it's not him then i'd say feck, his vote yesterday was pretty out of nowhere and he does love bussing teammates. also the no vote on a 25 hour day doesn't look good.

I can back this plan.

MZ, you in?

What's the plan exactly? Lynch DP then Feck? I'll go with the first part. Not convinced about feck at all.

[irretating]

Hi guys, good call on mantis. That changes things.

I had no idea ksen asked to sub out til someone mentioned it ITT, so his scum buddies would have been happy to bus him. Rc and feck do look worse now, but DP has to figure in the scum lists, too.

My gut says DP.

[Uselesstwit]

yeah, we can talk about it again, but no one should out until the nk goes thru.

[Uselesstwit]

Hi guys, good call on mantis. That changes things.

I had no idea ksen asked to sub out til someone mentioned it ITT, so his scum buddies would have been happy to bus him. Rc and feck do look worse now, but DP has to figure in the scum lists, too.

My gut says DP.

yeah, I don't see much of a way not to lynch dp tomorrow, everyone else but jerome has lynched a scum. after dp it could be a coin toss for rc and feck. Feck's just my personal choice of those two.

[Magicziggy]

What do we think of rc now?

[Zigmen]

MZ looks a little better now. RC looks worse.

And MZ, spare me your "Zigmen and Jerome are too stupid for words" bullshit.

I gave a list of 5 players (With Mantis on it) and said that 2 were Scum. I, like you, removed UT from that list. I think my radar is pretty stellar, thanyouverumuch. Now, let's bury the hatchet and work together without the insults. ok?

RC and DP are the only players left that are, imho, still not cleared in some way.

Does anyone's list differ from mine?

If so, why?

I take offense to your "I wasn't talking to you" tone. I don't hold grudges. I have no idea at all about why you are so protective of Jerome. Any mention seemed to give you amo on me. That to me was stupid. I'm glad you saw sense in the end.

For me I have a short list of one atm. DP. It's a starting point. But nailing a don can be tricky.

MZ, you were in my uncleared pile, and I'm often snarky to those I suspect. Nothing personal. I apologize.

I'm not defending Jerome, either. I'm just trying to make sure that everyone knows as much as I do about spotting his Scum game, and that his voting is not an indicator of his alignment and never has been, afaik.

Shall we work together for a bit until we have reason not to?

xpost x5 or so.