Simple Mafia 3

[Zigmen]

I'm still at work. Whoops on the misquote, but no time to fix it now.

Unvote

I'll review later.

[oblivion]

Vote Count:

Ghat - 2.5
Zigmen - 2

Nightfall is in 14 hours (see the peanut gallery thread for more info).

[Azathoth]

Ani, sorry
Also, sorry MagicZig.

ping
ping

vote Zigman

Explain how this indicated he is scum.

Apologising to the innocent that you just lynched is a standard scum tell. He is probably laughing his head off that people went for the charge he led. Plus he scares me he is an unknown quantity that would make a very dangerous scummer

[higgs2]

Hey zigmen, what do you have to say for yourself? You have seemed a bit scummy here and there.

[higgs2]

Ani, sorry
Also, sorry MagicZig.

ping
ping

vote Zigman

Explain how this indicated he is scum.

Apologising to the innocent that you just lynched is a standard scum tell. He is probably laughing his head off that people went for the charge he led. Plus he scares me he is an unknown quantity that would make a very dangerous scummer

Not sure he led the Ani charge. I was the "lynch all liars" post. And I stand by it even though ani was town. It was the right thing to do.

[Zigmen]

Checking in briefly.

I do not believe Ghat is scum. Back before Ani outed his lie, I admit that Ghat's posts seemed sincere, including his self vote. I'm not going to put my vote on the wagon.

As far as the "lynch all liars" approach, that's a standard practice in Mafia, and I'll provide links if anyone doubts it. Lying is not townish. And to Normal, i misquoted him in my rush to work. That was a mistake, not close to a lie.

I'll read up and post more in depth in about 30-40 minutes, after I eat.

[higgs2]

Misquoting Normal pretty much blows your case in saying he is scum. Do you still believe that Normal is scum?

[higgs2]

I would like to hear from Mantis as well. Is this a time zone issue or is she being extremely quiet?

[Zigmen]

Misquoting Normal pretty much blows your case in saying he is scum. Do you still believe that Normal is scum?

I'm not sure, thus my unvote.

I am still getting used to who's who, and I misremembered a little bit of stuff. I'm rereading now.

[higgs2]

I would like to hear from Mantis as well. Is this a time zone issue or is she being extremely quiet?

Sorry, my bad. Forgot she said she's out of town.

[Zigmen]

Higgs and Charlou~

Higgs you made a mistake yesterday. And you're trying to bus Charlou. I almost didn't spot it . . .

Higgs:

It is possible that there is no seer in this game. There could be a vig and a doc only. Last game we only had 2 specials.

At that moment, before Ani outed his lie, we only had Ani's FoS and Ghat's denial. Of course Ghat would deny it, right? But there was no reason to imagine we had no seer, unless you knew the view was wrong. Charlou had a similar reaction.

Then, 2 minutes later, the seemingly panicky post that was supposed to extinguish the fire:

Of course we can wifom that to death. An option is to lynch ghat and if she is town take out animavore tonight.

btw Good Morningn Everone.

IMHO, that's a "on second thought" post.

Why would you have considered the idea that there was no seer when Ani had claimed to be one?

[Zigmen]

Vote Higgs

I'm sure, now.

[higgs2]

sigh.

[higgs2]

Okay I'll play. Yes, I would have entertained the idea that there was no seer, just like I think there is no doc. And panicky is not even close to how I've felt during this game. We've had a first day suicide, a lying seer, 2 outed specials, and your multiple and ever changing theories, which frankly are hard to follow. Maybe if you're so sure you should lock in your vote.

[higgs2]

And this is the post I made down the line, probably about some of our stupid theories although I don't remember what I was responding to:
"Possible, but longshots.

He's either the seer or scum and lying.

The second is less likely because he couldn't know in advance that we have no seer (if indeed we do)."

enough.