Simple Mafia 2 Archive

[higgs2]

I'm going to be gone for most of the rest of this day, as I'm going on a field trip with my daughter.

You guys are really flexible to be able to take in new information and and make new decisions based on that. You would be surprised at how many people can't, they advocate so hard for one position that they can't stop even with evidence starting them in the face.

Charlou, you rock, you are shrewd and bold. I hope to see you here tomorrow. Damn I wish we had ghat.

I would love to know more about Twinkie (hint). That coordination possibility is really niggling at me from some of the things I'm realizing have been said. Not to mention what verphin said to her all along and especially most recently.

Uselesstwit, high five. Don't forget your .5 tiebreaker vote as mayor. And don't be the don that will piss me off. (Actually, unlikeley in a game this size; 12 people -- wouldn't work so well. But still.)

[Uselesstwit]

Morning everyone, sorry I wasn't on much yesterday but work really kicked my ass. Spending all afternoon outside at a build site in 100+ heat just crushed me.

vote virphen

And to answer the questions, no I'm not the don, and yes I figured Charlou was a likely special.

[charlou]

Charlou, you rock, you are shrewd and bold. I hope to see you here tomorrow. Damn I wish we had ghat.

Yeah, me too ... and thanks , you're playing a great game yourself.

Just want to remind everyone who had their FoS on higgs that virphen was set on getting higgs lynched. I think, even if nothing else does for you, that alone should give you pause to reconsider ...

vote higgs2

She's the one I FOSed yesterday who did herself absolutely no favours.

[Uselesstwit]

New list of innocents in my opinion

Me
Charlou


The rest I think are all at least possible scum. Twinkie or higgs is most likely cleared, but with Vir. he could have set up a little game from the start to get one of them into the end game.
Feck, I'm still leaning towards cleared.
So either normal or mantis is most likely our final scum.

Yes I think we probably started with three scum, and with only 12 starting players that's why we got a doc to balance things.

[charlou]

It seems I'm playing a crap game (my playing, that is) that I'll likely never live down.

Is my vote needed? Seems virphen is going to get the chop anyhow.

Why wouldn't you vote for mafia, Twinkie? The only two reasons that occur to me for why you're reluctant to vote for virphen are that you are mafia too ... or you're friends with virphen and can't keep that separate from the game?

[higgs2]

New list of innocents in my opinion

Me
Charlou


The rest I think are all at least possible scum. Twinkie or higgs is most likely cleared, but with Vir. he could have set up a little game from the start to get one of them into the end game.
Feck, I'm still leaning towards cleared.
So either normal or mantis is most likely our final scum.

Yes I think we probably started with three scum, and with only 12 starting players that's why we got a doc to balance things.

Was there no doc last game with 15?

[Uselesstwit]

New list of innocents in my opinion

Me
Charlou


The rest I think are all at least possible scum. Twinkie or higgs is most likely cleared, but with Vir. he could have set up a little game from the start to get one of them into the end game.
Feck, I'm still leaning towards cleared.
So either normal or mantis is most likely our final scum.

Yes I think we probably started with three scum, and with only 12 starting players that's why we got a doc to balance things.

Was there no doc last game with 15?

Nope, that's why I think we got a doc but kept the same number of scum.

And twinkie not voting for vir. is really odd. I'm going to have to go with the not voting for a friend theory. Any scum should be on that bandwagon asap.

[Feck]

New list of innocents in my opinion

Me
Charlou


The rest I think are all at least possible scum. Twinkie or higgs is most likely cleared, but with Vir. he could have set up a little game from the start to get one of them into the end game.
Feck, I'm still leaning towards cleared.
So either normal or mantis is most likely our final scum.

Yes I think we probably started with three scum, and with only 12 starting players that's why we got a doc to balance things.

Was there no doc last game with 15?

only 3 scum and No powers !and there was a viggi we could have lost in one and a half days FFS

[higgs2]

Yeah, then that makes sense we would have 3 scum.

I've never encountered the '"not vote for a friend" issue. Usually people will vote for confirmed scum whether they are friends or not.

I don't see virphen setting up a game to get me to end game, I saw a lame fosing and lynch votes that almost caused me to be lynched. Based mostly on his posts several people voted for me.

Why are you leaning to cleared with feck?

[higgs2]

New list of innocents in my opinion

Me
Charlou


The rest I think are all at least possible scum. Twinkie or higgs is most likely cleared, but with Vir. he could have set up a little game from the start to get one of them into the end game.
Feck, I'm still leaning towards cleared.
So either normal or mantis is most likely our final scum.

Yes I think we probably started with three scum, and with only 12 starting players that's why we got a doc to balance things.

Was there no doc last game with 15?

only 3 scum and No powers !and there was a viggi we could have lost in one and a half days FFS

Oh there was a vig? But no doc or seer? Wow.

[higgs2]

As my plan has pretty much gone to shit, I'll reveal what I was up to in exaggerating Twinkie's innocence.

I was trying to get whacked as cover for a special. It's one of my favourite tactics, in fact. I refer you to 2 games ago where I did the same. I hinted I had a special role, and took out a scum as I was a bomb. (I am not, to the best of my knowledge, a bomb this time, I didn't know I was one that day). I think Mantis should remember another game on RDF when I actually arranged for a vigilante to shoot me to help town (in a PM allowed game).

That's also why I waited until the 2nd day to make that claim - I wanted it to look like I'd had the chance to clear her as the seer.

Anyway there's no chance of it working now, scum will keep me alive - it's quite clear that scum are not going to whack innocents they think are going to get lynched next.

Mind you, I didn't exaggerate much: the chances of Oblivion missing out the PM to the scum team are next to 0. I bet it's the first PM she sends out. I'm surprised Twinkie wasn't whacked on the first night.

Did he jsut say he was trying to get lynched in order to make Twinkie look innocent. And to make it look like he'd cleared her as seer?

Just re-read this. Wow.

[oblivion]

Current counts:

Virphen - 5
higgs2 - 2

Nightfall is in 2 hours 20 minutes.

[Mantisdreamz]

It seems I'm playing a crap game (my playing, that is) that I'll likely never live down.

Is my vote needed? Seems virphen is going to get the chop anyhow.

Why wouldn't you vote for mafia, Twinkie? The only two reasons that occur to me for why you're reluctant to vote for virphen are that you are mafia too ... or you're friends with virphen and can't keep that separate from the game?

At this point a scum would probably have squeaked their vote in as well. If I were scum, I wouldn't want to stand out like that.

Charlou, it didn't occur to me that you were the seer.

So, if virphen is guilty that leaves either:

-Feck
-Twinkie
-Normal

I think out of those 3, Normal is the most likely suspect.

Though, I could be wrong about Feck and he could be doing an excellent job at double bluffing.

[oblivion]

Nightfall!

Virphen was scum.

Day 4 will start in 12 hours. Night actions are due in 11 hours from the time of this post.

[oblivion]

You find Charlou dead by gunshot. Charlou was the Town seer and could view one player each night and learn that player's alignment.

Among the living:

Feck
Uselesstwit
Normal
higgs
Twinkie
Mantisdreamz


Deceased:

colubridae - vanilla scum
DP - vanilla town
Magicziggy - vanilla town
Ghatanothoa - town doctor
Virphen - vanilla scum
Charlou - town seer

Game Day 4 ends in 23 hours (sorry for the late start).