Cannibal Holocaust Game Thread

[oblivion]

All that said, at the moment I don't think ani is scum. He's just annoying.

[Animavore]

All that said, at the moment I don't think ani is scum. He's just annoying.

To you maybe, like the way Columbo was to the scumbags he hassled.

[gib]

Oh, I dunno, bussing his team mate to score bonus town points?

My point is that the exact motivation he's ascribing to me also works on his vote.

OK and the most parsimonious explanation is that both yourself and Ani are town tbh

[gib]

He's just annoying.

How rude!

[oblivion]

Oh, I dunno, bussing his team mate to score bonus town points?

My point is that the exact motivation he's ascribing to me also works on his vote.

OK and the most parsimonious explanation is that both yourself and Ani are town tbh

Yep. though parsimony and mafia have only a nodding acquaintance.

[charlou]

All that said, at the moment I don't think ani is scum. He's just annoying.

To you maybe, like the way Columbo was to the scumbags he hassled.

Sorry .. that tickled


I'm off to bed.

[oblivion]

Dammit, this always seems to happen. I have someone in mind to vote, and by the time I get to the end of the thread, someone in the post above me, votes for that person.

So, no, I am not following or starting bandwagons.


But, gib's little drop by stuck out to me for some reason:

Hi all, where is everyone?

vote gib


vote Charlou since she seems to have the same line as reasoning as me so far -- agreement that MZ was voting for a good reason & pointing out gib.

this is an interesting post, given how the lynch turned out.

[DennyB]

Well my plan may not CLEAR 4 players but I don't see Ani's deciding vote as a buss. Could be, but I don't think so.
I think scum is quiet and having a good chuckle with town tearing itself apart again.
I think the OB and MZ show looks like 2 town to me. We all know the easiest thing for scum to do is hide in the background.
I think the active players on day one are least suspect at this point and serious pressure need be applied to all the quiet ones.
I think Charlou need viewed as mayor. So if nothing is heard we can move on.

[DennyB]

Ghat,
If we have to many no shows by day 2 will replacements be considered?
It makes it tough when only half the people actually the game.

[Azathoth]

Yeah. I'm going to start looking for subs soon if people don't start turning up

[Uselesstwit]

I'm here and catching up. dinner last night lasted to about 3 am. I'm reading now.

[DennyB]

I'm here and catching up. dinner last night lasted to about 3 am. I'm reading now.

That must have some party!

[Uselesstwit]

it was good fun, before we clear MZ to much let's remember

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 50#p679659

it really reads to me like he knew the answer to that lynch before the results came in. He looks good in the rest of his posts but certainty is always something scum have over town.

[mononoke]

Well my plan may not CLEAR 4 players but I don't see Ani's deciding vote as a buss. Could be, but I don't think so.
I think scum is quiet and having a good chuckle with town tearing itself apart again.
I think the OB and MZ show looks like 2 town to me. We all know the easiest thing for scum to do is hide in the background.
I think the active players on day one are least suspect at this point and serious pressure need be applied to all the quiet ones.
I think Charlou need viewed as mayor. So if nothing is heard we can move on.

Scum being quiet on day is an old story. Most decent scum don't play that way.


That comes with a FoS as well

[Uselesstwit]

who's that a fos of mono? If it's denny I'd tend to agree. The way zigmen singled him out for a fluff fos with all the fluff going around does feel like a light scum bus to me.