Hide and Seek Game Thread

[Animavore]

Just to recap, my vote on Jynx is to see how he reacts.

I'm off to finish my Tiger painting.

My vote stays where it is.

Vote Magicziggy

(he'll probably try call revenge vote but just remember who voted who first here)

Back in a few hours.

[nellikin]

Jynx, why do you think MZ is scum?

And Charlou - you published a list yesterday: I don't understand your numbering? Could you please explain?


2.Feck
3.Nellikin
4.MZ
5.Squid
6.Gib
7. Higgs
8. MCJ
9. Jynx
10.DP
11.DennyB

[charlou]

And Charlou - you published a list yesterday: I don't understand your numbering? Could you please explain?


2.Feck
3.Nellikin
4.MZ
5.Squid
6.Gib
7. Higgs
8. MCJ
9. Jynx
10.DP
11.DennyB

Here's the post you're refering to http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 63#p730063 ...

... it's a follow on to Denny's post above it. The list and numbering are from the players list in the OP of the day one thread, minus my name (I'm town) at number one, and Mantis's (she was lynched and flipped as town) at number 12

[charlou]

In other words, I think there's scum hiding among the whole list of remaining players.

[charlou]

If Denny could on act at night, then his day actions weren't relevant. FoS MZ.

Day behaviour is very relevant .. analysing it is an equally important part of scum hunting.

[nellikin]

Okay - so basically all who are left and you suspect Feck. Any reason why?

[nellikin]

If Denny could on act at night, then his day actions weren't relevant. FoS MZ.

Day behaviour is very relevant .. analysing it is an equally important part of scum hunting.

Yes. But he couldn't have used his powers during the day to investigate someone. So during the day he was just digging for suspicious actions... Doesn't say much about who he possibly could have investigated at night.

[Animavore]

Jynx, why do you think MZ is scum?

I said yesterday. For fluffy silliness.
And now you can add probability fail to that also. Just because I've been town the last few games doesn't mean I have to be scum now.

[charlou]

If Denny could on act at night, then his day actions weren't relevant. FoS MZ.

Day behaviour is very relevant .. analysing it is an equally important part of scum hunting.

Yes. But he couldn't have used his powers during the day to investigate someone. So during the day he was just digging for suspicious actions... Doesn't say much about who he possibly could have investigated at night.

It says a lot about who he was interested in and who he may have investigated. That said, my pondering about who he wanted to view is academic as we won't know until after the game.


I highlighted Feck's name as I had voted him for this post:

Stating you are town on Day one Mantis

glad to see some one voted DP already

Charlou is being helpful ... too helpful ?

higgs has had a look and not posted

And a few of the others have yet to show face ....

Each point had been made by someone else. It pinged for me. In the previous game Denny pinged for grabbing at oblivion's work and not doing his own. He was later lynched and flipped scum.

[charlou]

If Denny could on act at night, then his day actions weren't relevant. FoS MZ.

Day behaviour is very relevant .. analysing it is an equally important part of scum hunting.

Yes. But he couldn't have used his powers during the day to investigate someone. So during the day he was just digging for suspicious actions... Doesn't say much about who he possibly could have investigated at night.

It says a lot about who he was interested in and who he may have investigated. That said, my pondering about who he wanted to view is academic as we won't know until after the game.

Actually, it's not entirely academic ... if he was onto scum with any of the posts MZ quoted, it's possible that's a reason he was nightkilled by them. There's more to it though .. experienced scum might kill him if they think he's a special ... they were right he had an investigative/seer type role.

[Magicziggy]

If Denny could on act at night, then his day actions weren't relevant. FoS MZ.

Edit: only act at night

Once a player is killed and their alignment is revealed, all their interactions should be looked at with that new information in mind. That he had an investagitive role is not that important. The important thing is he was town and therefore genuinely scum hunting and may have left behind some genuine information for us to follow up on.

Jynx, you are tiring. However, it still looks town behaviour to me.
The minute you don't do this in a game you will be lynched you realise.

unvote

[Feck]

Do you mean experienced scum like Higgs who was caught out falsely claiming not to be looking at the thread ?
or experienced Scum like Jynx who thinks that is fluffy posting or an experienced scum like you and DP who keep floating the idea that I'm scum to see if anyone else will fall for it despite no reason being given .Or inexperienced scum like M who knows what a Ping is and who was fossed by a now dead town player ?
or MZ who seemed to have Higgs on the ropes but then dropped the whole idea really quickly

christ I don't know who to vote for first .

[Magicziggy]

Ok, I have to go out now and won't be back before day's end.

Of all the content so far, M's is perhaps the one that sticks out the most.
Contribution to finding scum is nil. Only a few cursary remarks. As if finding it hard to ask the right questions, and that would be so for a noob in a scum role. Plus that fos from Denny.

vote M

[nellikin]

What a quiet day. Most players didn't even post. My vote for Higgs2 stands and I think both MZ and Charlou are suss - for mentoring me and backing each other up. Did everyone else die already?

[higgs2]

I just haven'tbeen here a lot MZ.

Yeah I over reacted. But no one can explain why non-mods were saying that they could see me online - whether Ii actually was or wasn't -- when I was cloaked. And I didn't change my status until this whole kerfuffle.

So after the game is over I do want it looked into, when people don't think I'm making it up.

At this point I don't have an obvious vote. I'd like to know why jynxx fos'd MZ and MZ voted jynx. I found both of them odd day one by their giddy fluff.
Also, nellikin, why does jynx strike you as town?
And squid, any reasons for your opinions.

Jynx?

answers from nellikin or squid? nelli will say something kind of obvious and then come back with an opinion. Prolly due to mentor input.

Charlous is giving me a headache with the happy homeaker helpful posts. What is the deal with that? vote charlou