Stargate SG1 - game thread

[Zigmen]

Does anyone know on which part of the globe KSen lives? He hasn't answered questions, but it might be because of where he lives.

Zigmen, I'm going to ask two questions:

1) Why did you not think it might be good to shoot out even one hint about blue or oval or stone, if not right away, but toward the latter part of the game? Or did you?

2) Is my scenario about lynching you or KSen (no matter how you flip), at least reasonable for a Town win?

1) I considered outing a hint at end-game if needed. But, as I've already said, for all i knew the blue stones could have been stolen and used against us, perhaps as recruiting tools or weapons. I was not going to risk outing a hint about them.

2) I haven't done the math, but I can. Here goes:

8 Players= 2 Scum +1 Indy +5 Town (probably)

1 lynch+2 NKs = 3 deaths

Tomorrow:

5 players

If we mislynch and misNK, that means:

5 players = 2 Scum +1 Indy +2Town.

That's pretty bad, but indies often count as Town in terms of parity, according to MartinM at TR, whom i trust.

If we lynch properly, that clears Ksen and me (cuz there can't be 3 scum right now). Even with a MisNK, that would leave:

5 Players = 1 Scum +1 Indy +3 Town (2 of whom will be cleared)

Missing Scum today would be way bad. Killing one Town to clear another is not good, statistically.

We're back to what we have now, which is:
3 uncleared players: Higgs, Athene, and Charlou.
1 Indy (confirmed): Amok
2 mildly cleared players: RC and Diva (Mayor)
2 mostly cleared players: Zigmen and Ksen.

I'd lynch Charlou today. Assuming she's Scum, we would be in a good spot to win this.

I personally think Charlou looks the scummiest.

xpostx5 or so.

[higgs2]

Diva, you are without a doubt one of the worst and most unpleasant players I have had the misfortune to play with, with your "it's all about me", tantrumy, self voting for effect, revenge for what happened in previous games that no one remembers style of play. I suggest you consider getting a mentor before you pull the whole fabric of tr and ratz mafia down into the mire of feelings and emotions rather than logic and scum tells.

I know that was p. harsh, I will probably regret it later.

That said.

I'm the doc, actually the body guard.

day one i protected irre
day two, bili
day three, athene
And I think maybe I should keep last night to myself unless you guys really want me to tell.

I would wait as long as possible to out but we're going in circles so it seems that I should now.

[amok]

Amok, if we pop any Scum today, would you then think it safe to assume that neither Ksen nor I could be Scum?

That would mean there are currently 3 living Scum. That's impossible by any stretch of game balance.

Jesus Xpost city

No, no, of course not. It's either you & KSen as Scum (and no others), or you & KSen as Town Specials (and two other Scum). My scenario attempted to take that into account.

I'm still not entirely sure if Town can win (taking me out of the equation for me - because I'm the only one who knows for certain that I'm telling the truth - but leaving it in for the others, because they don't) if we bump one of you off and you flip Town Special.

I asked before if some people with better number-logic could help with that, but I haven't seen a reply.

[higgs2]

oh and I'm Teal'c, a Jaffa formerly sworn to serve Apophis as his First Prime, and now a member of the SG1 team. whatever that means

[amok]

Diva, you are without a doubt one of the worst and most unpleasant players I have had the misfortune to play with, with your "it's all about me", tantrumy, self voting for effect, revenge for what happened in previous games that no one remembers style of play. I suggest you consider getting a mentor before you pull the whole fabric of tr and ratz mafia down into the mire of feelings and emotions rather than logic and scum tells.

I know that was p. harsh, I will probably regret it later.

That said.

I'm the doc, actually the body guard.

day one i protected irre
day two, bili
day three, athene
And I think maybe I should keep last night to myself unless you guys really want me to tell.

I would wait as long as possible to out but we're going in circles so it seems that I should now.

Why did you chose Athene on Day 3?

[charlou]

Zigmen, why aren't you answering my question about your first post in the thread?

Did you read the wiki on masons?

Are you even willing to consider the possibility that ksen is scum?

Are you willing to consider that you're trolley tracking on me, just as you did with bili yesterday?

[charlou]

crosspost a heap of posts.

[Zigmen]

I would like an answer to this:

Amok, if we pop any Scum today, would you then think it safe to assume that neither Ksen nor I could be Scum?

That would mean there are currently 3 living Scum. That's impossible by any stretch of game balance.

Jesus Xpost city

Why did you leave open the possibility that you're not both town aligned in your first post in this thread?

Have you read the mafiascum wiki on masons that I linked to earlier?

Our PM did not say anything about our alignment, As I've already said, Ksen and I worked it out by character name, mechanics, and in keeping with the flavor.

My father found the Stargate and left me some objects. Ksen is the archaeologist that solved the Stargate's code, and, according to the wiki, was like a son to me.

IOW, it took us some time to figure it out.

[Zigmen]

Zigmen, why aren't you answering my question about your first post in the thread?

Did you read the wiki on masons?

Are you even willing to consider the possibility that ksen is scum?

Are you willing to consider that you're trolley tracking on me, just as you did with bili yesterday?

I'm answering as fast as I find questions, and typind as fast as I type. This thread is blasting me. I think i just replied to the post you mean, though.

[higgs2]

Diva, you are without a doubt one of the worst and most unpleasant players I have had the misfortune to play with, with your "it's all about me", tantrumy, self voting for effect, revenge for what happened in previous games that no one remembers style of play. I suggest you consider getting a mentor before you pull the whole fabric of tr and ratz mafia down into the mire of feelings and emotions rather than logic and scum tells.

I know that was p. harsh, I will probably regret it later.

That said.

I'm the doc, actually the body guard.

day one i protected irre
day two, bili
day three, athene
And I think maybe I should keep last night to myself unless you guys really want me to tell.

I would wait as long as possible to out but we're going in circles so it seems that I should now.

Why did you chose Athene on Day 3?

I thought she seemed town, she's a good player that gets taken out early, I had hardly had time to read any of the game so I didn't really know exactly what was going on so she seemed like a good guess.

[charlou]

higgs, that puts your first couple of days scummy looking posts in a different light.

[amok]

Zigmen, if you and KSen are Town Specials, do you think a lynch of one of you (which would reveal that on the flip), could possibly result in a Town win, using my earlier scenario? If we spend the next hour or so making a sensible decision about a Night Kill for me?

[charlou]

vote Athene

[higgs2]

I almost protected irre again instead of athene and I wanted to kick myself when irre was killed. Almost protected bili again last night but i wasn't sure any more and anyhow the wifom...

[Zigmen]

Thanks, Higgs. Amok confirms we do have some sort of protection on Bili on N2.

Don't say who you protected last night.

Who's your top pick for Scum?