The Innsmouth Look game thread.

[Athene]

How will killing b.tern help us fulfil our win condition? She's not an investigator.

[Athene]

I don't care if you're not interested. This is an issue that needs to be thrashed out.

[Uselesstwit]

fine, explain how killing anyone last night was good for town? We're probably at lynch/lose right now BECAUSE of b.tern. Without last nights kill we could have made it tomorrow but now tonight is probably the end. Seriously show her actions last night in a protown light.

[ksen]

I'd like to hear why b.tern killed r.c. in light of this post:

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 27#p912527

I still wonder if UT is the final scum, tbh. I don't think UT is anywhere as cleared as everyone seems to think.

I'm wondering if b.tern just said that to increase the chances that mantis would protect UT last night thus leaving r.c. unprotected.

[Athene]

fine, explain how killing anyone last night was good for town? We're probably at lynch/lose right now BECAUSE of b.tern. Without last nights kill we could have made it tomorrow but now tonight is probably the end. Seriously show her actions last night in a protown light.

I'll repeat, how will killing b.tern help us fulfil our win condition which is to kill all investigators?

[Athene]

Poor mantis, what a choice.

[Mantisdreamz]

4 scum in a 16 player game though? isn't that a bit much?

[Mantisdreamz]

Poor mantis, what a choice.

haha this one is a toughy. here i was all excited yesterday about our win

[Mantisdreamz]

but ya.. ksen.

[Uselesstwit]

fine, explain how killing anyone last night was good for town? We're probably at lynch/lose right now BECAUSE of b.tern. Without last nights kill we could have made it tomorrow but now tonight is probably the end. Seriously show her actions last night in a protown light.

I'll repeat, how will killing b.tern help us fulfil our win condition which is to kill all investigators?

this bugs me also athene, but the game you're describing is so out of balance that i'm more willing to believe that aza messed up the role pm than the entire game design. Think about what it would mean if there were 4 scum.

Scum would start out about right balance wise but then aza added in:
and sk who is also a lover(most likely a penalty for town)
the princess(the biggest penalty I've ever seen for town)
a scum don
a scum roleblocker

against town's
doc
restricted doc
seer
tracker (oh wait, no you think ksen is fake role claiming)

that game is just so out of whack that I won't be playing in another aza game for a long long time if it's the case.

so yes to answer your question I find 3 scum and a mentor to be much more balanced than 4 scum and a sk who takes a town with them when they die.

[b.ternarius]

So rc was innocent. Of those left, I think ksen or UT.

I did not kill UT because the rest of you seemed convinced he's innocent.

I think ksen is town.

Consider carefully before you lynch me. I won't be around until late evening,

##vote Useless Twit##

[Uselesstwit]

why'd you kill anyone b.tern? several of us said it was a horrible idea.

[Athene]

You do present a good case UT.

Wouldn't it also be quite shitty of Aza to give us the wrong win condition and not let us actually win even though we've fulfilled it? Wouldn't that be a really shit thing for a GM to do? It's not our problem if he made a mistake and he should let us win with the win condition we were given.

If that's what has happened then I won't be playing in another aza game for a long long time.

[Athene]

So rc was innocent. Of those left, I think ksen or UT.

I did not kill UT because the rest of you seemed convinced he's innocent.

I think ksen is town.

Consider carefully before you lynch me. I won't be around until late evening,

##vote Useless Twit##

If you think ksen is innocent then he didn't lie about watching charlou visiting UT on night 3, which means that charlou did visit UT on night 3 but for what purpose if UT is scum?

[Uselesstwit]

that is a fair point athene. and i'm tempted to agree with you just for the whingeing rights that we'd have after the game. but I just can't get past how antitown b.tern has been. Also, b.tern might be some form of investigator. I only have her word about her role. i'm also finding you viewing three dead people in a row now to be kinda suspect. Like maybe you're covering up the loss of your powers.