Simple Mafia 3.5
Moderator: Mafia Mods
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Normal? Really? Interesting choice for scum to target. That lynch of ghat was bullshit, it was a bw gone amuck.
I'm less suspicious of DP now that Animivore has more opportunity to post. Revenge voting, saying that lynchvoting someone and giving a reason is a scum tell, bah.
vote animavore
I'm less suspicious of DP now that Animivore has more opportunity to post. Revenge voting, saying that lynchvoting someone and giving a reason is a scum tell, bah.
vote animavore
Badass Elf
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Interesting logic 

Libertarianism: The belief that out of all the terrible things governments can do, helping people is the absolute worst.
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
So looking at what we know now, we have one kill which seems to be a scum kill (riddled with bullets). If there was a vig they must have been blocked or their intended victim protected. I'm hoping and assuming we have a seer. Scum could have a don again, or maybe a prostitute (roleblocker). What else could raven have thrown in here? It's simple mafia but she's been rotating the specials around to give us different experience I think. Have we had an sk yet? I'd think it unlikely since we only had one kill last night.
Also, why normal for the scum kill? Could be he was town that seemed unlikely to be protected. I didn't see a statement that would make him a threat to scum. Fecks vote on col for "posting first" deserves fos imo. Also his hop onto the dp bw at the end. Charlou didn't vote. And Magic has done a lot of listing everyone's votes (which is very helpful,thanks!) but not as much scum sniffing.
Also, why normal for the scum kill? Could be he was town that seemed unlikely to be protected. I didn't see a statement that would make him a threat to scum. Fecks vote on col for "posting first" deserves fos imo. Also his hop onto the dp bw at the end. Charlou didn't vote. And Magic has done a lot of listing everyone's votes (which is very helpful,thanks!) but not as much scum sniffing.
Badass Elf
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
My reasons were all perfectly sensible and town motivated .....what more do you want ?




Give me the wine , I don't need the bread
- Magicziggy
- Posts: 4847
- Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2010 8:56 am
- Contact:
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Just imagine DP and Higgs on the same scum team. What possible gameplan could they have? DP acting out of character. Higgs with a vote on him. He survives and then DP is no longer that scummy. Anyone who didn't notice DPs scummy play is fair game for a lynch. Higgs making her own reasons for voting Ani and then citing me for not scum sniffing. Fosing Feck for voting first. I thought its a fair tactic to vote a player to put presure on them. DP said so. I dunno. It's fishy.
- colubridae
- Custom Rank: Rank
- Posts: 2771
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2010 12:16 pm
- About me: http://www.essentialart.com/acatalog/Ed ... Stars.html
- Location: Birmingham art gallery
- Contact:
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Four have voted for anima, and 1 (ani himself) for magicz.
if there are three scum then at least 1 town has voted for ani.
possibly more.
back on the bandwagon
if you are town sorry but.
vote animavore
if there are three scum then at least 1 town has voted for ani.
possibly more.
back on the bandwagon
if you are town sorry but.
vote animavore
I have a well balanced personality. I've got chips on both shoulders
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Don't worry about it Col, I don't mind dying, in fact, I'm quite looking forward to it.
Libertarianism: The belief that out of all the terrible things governments can do, helping people is the absolute worst.
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
I never got a reply as to why when my vote was on Col this was this said
higgs2 wrote:
My power keeps going out, so quickly:
vote dp for his low content posts about nothing. fos feck also, and even more if dp turns up town.
.
Feck wrote:
Why would ,based on day one posts, Dp's innocence cast any suspicion on me ?
I didn't vote for him or Fos him I take the point that he was being a bit talkative but I still like my hunch that Col cracked first probably from nerves .
.............................................................................................................................................................................................
Well as I know i'm innocent from my pov that could look pretty scummy of higgs , If DP was killed and is innocent higgs was fossing me DESPITE the fact Of what I said ..you were being pushed into some thing on day 2 that was based on nothing .That's why I changed my vote to DP late in the day to see how it would change the voting ...obviously it changed little because the vote was for Ghat anyway and scum didn't really care if DP or Ghat got lynched
I repeat Where was the logic unless higgs is scum
Seems to me like higgs knows Dp is innocent and knows I am . I could be wrong but
If higgs is town and suspected Me just say so ...the link to DP's innocence (a known fact if you are scum ) is illogical .
I could be over analysing a mistake by higgs ..obviously DP could be scum and that would prove me wrong on this but
VOTE Higgs 2
higgs2 wrote:
My power keeps going out, so quickly:
vote dp for his low content posts about nothing. fos feck also, and even more if dp turns up town.
.
Feck wrote:
Why would ,based on day one posts, Dp's innocence cast any suspicion on me ?
I didn't vote for him or Fos him I take the point that he was being a bit talkative but I still like my hunch that Col cracked first probably from nerves .
.............................................................................................................................................................................................
Well as I know i'm innocent from my pov that could look pretty scummy of higgs , If DP was killed and is innocent higgs was fossing me DESPITE the fact Of what I said ..you were being pushed into some thing on day 2 that was based on nothing .That's why I changed my vote to DP late in the day to see how it would change the voting ...obviously it changed little because the vote was for Ghat anyway and scum didn't really care if DP or Ghat got lynched
I repeat Where was the logic unless higgs is scum
Seems to me like higgs knows Dp is innocent and knows I am . I could be wrong but
If higgs is town and suspected Me just say so ...the link to DP's innocence (a known fact if you are scum ) is illogical .
I could be over analysing a mistake by higgs ..obviously DP could be scum and that would prove me wrong on this but

VOTE Higgs 2




Give me the wine , I don't need the bread
- colubridae
- Custom Rank: Rank
- Posts: 2771
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2010 12:16 pm
- About me: http://www.essentialart.com/acatalog/Ed ... Stars.html
- Location: Birmingham art gallery
- Contact:
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Yeah now I don't know. is that scum flail?Animavore wrote:Don't worry about it Col, I don't mind dying, in fact, I'm quite looking forward to it.
all of us except higgs. zigmen and ghat have voted for town.
charlou hasn't voted?
and mantis has voted twice for town.
two things need ye know about the wise woman 1, she is wise, two she is a woman.



I have a well balanced personality. I've got chips on both shoulders
- colubridae
- Custom Rank: Rank
- Posts: 2771
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2010 12:16 pm
- About me: http://www.essentialart.com/acatalog/Ed ... Stars.html
- Location: Birmingham art gallery
- Contact:
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
and we are down to 8 versus 3.
I have a well balanced personality. I've got chips on both shoulders
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
ahemcolubridae wrote:Yeah now I don't know. is that scum flail?Animavore wrote:Don't worry about it Col, I don't mind dying, in fact, I'm quite looking forward to it.
all of us except higgs. zigmen and ghat have voted for town.
charlou hasn't voted?
and mantis has voted twice for town.
two things need ye know about the wise woman 1, she is wise, two she is a woman.![]()
![]()





Give me the wine , I don't need the bread
- colubridae
- Custom Rank: Rank
- Posts: 2771
- Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2010 12:16 pm
- About me: http://www.essentialart.com/acatalog/Ed ... Stars.html
- Location: Birmingham art gallery
- Contact:
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
Feck wrote:ahemcolubridae wrote:Yeah now I don't know. is that scum flail?Animavore wrote:Don't worry about it Col, I don't mind dying, in fact, I'm quite looking forward to it.
all of us except higgs. zigmen and ghat have voted for town.
charlou hasn't voted?
and mantis has voted twice for town.
two things need ye know about the wise woman 1, she is wise, two she is a woman.![]()
![]()
I didn't vote for town !(although I think it might turn out I did )
yes you did, you voted for me. I know I'm town, so I counted you in my list.
Unfortunatley your post doesn't help me . You're either being very smart scum or not so smart town.

I have a well balanced personality. I've got chips on both shoulders
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
When I am scum i play the same way I play town, hunting scum. I don't make plots and plans. And surely you can see why ani would get a lynch vote.Magicziggy wrote:Just imagine DP and Higgs on the same scum team. What possible gameplan could they have? DP acting out of character. Higgs with a vote on him. He survives and then DP is no longer that scummy. Anyone who didn't notice DPs scummy play is fair game for a lynch. Higgs making her own reasons for voting Ani and then citing me for not scum sniffing. Fosing Feck for voting first. I thought its a fair tactic to vote a player to put presure on them. DP said so. I dunno. It's fishy.
Badass Elf
- Magicziggy
- Posts: 4847
- Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2010 8:56 am
- Contact:
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
I can see why because I pointed it out in the first place but apparently I'm not doing much scum sniffing.
Re: Simple Mafia 3.5 - Day 2
dp is acting less scummy today, but still on my radar.
feck, I don't really understand what you are saying in your post.
feck, I don't really understand what you are saying in your post.
Badass Elf
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests