Are putative god(s) supernatural?
- JimC
- The sentimental bloke
- Posts: 74132
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:58 am
- About me: To be serious about gin requires years of dedicated research.
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
- Contact:
Are putative god(s) supernatural?
In another thread, I was castigated by Seth for asserting that, in debating the god issue, atheists quite reasonably use one of the descriptors of various gods as postulated by their believers, i.e. that their god was supernatural (or had supernatural properties). By supernatural, I mean that he/she/it can do things, or cause things to happen, that clearly do not obey any natural law applying to the rest of the universe; miracles, in the Judeo-Christian sense, would be examples. There is no doubt whatsoever that the vast majority of current religions and their adherents believe in a supernatural god.
This brings up some interesting questions:
1. Is it logically possible for an entity who would, in most other respects, fit the god definition, to be non-supernatural?
2. As a possible example of #1, consider an immensely powerful and intelligent alien, perhaps from another universe, who understands the deep physics of the universe to a level well beyond our current knowledge. Just as many aspects of our current technology seem to disobey "natural" laws to a Cro-Magnon, its actions would to us. Some have speculated about the possibility of such a being (presumably acting from another, larger universe) actually "creating" our universe, or at least running it as a super-simulation on a vast computer...
However, such a being is scarcely likely to fit all the other descriptors of the various gods imagined by various tribes of our past, nor would it be likely to exhibit the properties of the modern version of a personal, caring god; no more than a lab scientists cares about the individual bacteria in her petri dish...
This brings up some interesting questions:
1. Is it logically possible for an entity who would, in most other respects, fit the god definition, to be non-supernatural?
2. As a possible example of #1, consider an immensely powerful and intelligent alien, perhaps from another universe, who understands the deep physics of the universe to a level well beyond our current knowledge. Just as many aspects of our current technology seem to disobey "natural" laws to a Cro-Magnon, its actions would to us. Some have speculated about the possibility of such a being (presumably acting from another, larger universe) actually "creating" our universe, or at least running it as a super-simulation on a vast computer...
However, such a being is scarcely likely to fit all the other descriptors of the various gods imagined by various tribes of our past, nor would it be likely to exhibit the properties of the modern version of a personal, caring god; no more than a lab scientists cares about the individual bacteria in her petri dish...
Nurse, where the fuck's my cardigan?
And my gin!
And my gin!
- pErvinalia
- On the good stuff
- Posts: 60702
- Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 11:08 pm
- About me: Spelling 'were' 'where'
- Location: dystopia
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
Yes.
Sent from my penis using wankertalk.
"The Western world is fucking awesome because of mostly white men" - DaveDodo007.
"Socialized medicine is just exactly as morally defensible as gassing and cooking Jews" - Seth. Yes, he really did say that..
"Seth you are a boon to this community" - Cunt.
"I am seriously thinking of going on a spree killing" - Svartalf.
"The Western world is fucking awesome because of mostly white men" - DaveDodo007.
"Socialized medicine is just exactly as morally defensible as gassing and cooking Jews" - Seth. Yes, he really did say that..
"Seth you are a boon to this community" - Cunt.
"I am seriously thinking of going on a spree killing" - Svartalf.
- cronus
- Black Market Analyst
- Posts: 18122
- Joined: Thu Oct 11, 2012 7:09 pm
- About me: Illis quos amo deserviam
- Location: United Kingdom
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
What will the world be like after its ruler is removed?
- rainbow
- Posts: 13755
- Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2012 8:10 am
- About me: Egal wie dicht du bist, Goethe war Dichter
Where ever you are, Goethe was a Poet. - Location: Africa
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
Obviously the Creator would have made those natural laws, and it follows that they can change them at will.JimC wrote:In another thread, I was castigated by Seth for asserting that, in debating the god issue, atheists quite reasonably use one of the descriptors of various gods as postulated by their believers, i.e. that their god was supernatural (or had supernatural properties). By supernatural, I mean that he/she/it can do things, or cause things to happen, that clearly do not obey any natural law applying to the rest of the universe; miracles, in the Judeo-Christian sense, would be examples. There is no doubt whatsoever that the vast majority of current religions and their adherents believe in a supernatural god.
This brings up some interesting questions:
1. Is it logically possible for an entity who would, in most other respects, fit the god definition, to be non-supernatural?
2. As a possible example of #1, consider an immensely powerful and intelligent alien, perhaps from another universe, who understands the deep physics of the universe to a level well beyond our current knowledge. Just as many aspects of our current technology seem to disobey "natural" laws to a Cro-Magnon, its actions would to us. Some have speculated about the possibility of such a being (presumably acting from another, larger universe) actually "creating" our universe, or at least running it as a super-simulation on a vast computer...
However, such a being is scarcely likely to fit all the other descriptors of the various gods imagined by various tribes of our past, nor would it be likely to exhibit the properties of the modern version of a personal, caring god; no more than a lab scientists cares about the individual bacteria in her petri dish...
Therefore no.
I call bullshit - Alfred E Einstein
BArF−4
BArF−4
- JimC
- The sentimental bloke
- Posts: 74132
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:58 am
- About me: To be serious about gin requires years of dedicated research.
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
Humans have an irrational but understandable tendency to think that everything needs a creator (which can include a mother to be born from). Such primitive notions were understandable before a true appreciation of the nature of our universe.rainbow wrote:Obviously the Creator would have made those natural laws, and it follows that they can change them at will.JimC wrote:In another thread, I was castigated by Seth for asserting that, in debating the god issue, atheists quite reasonably use one of the descriptors of various gods as postulated by their believers, i.e. that their god was supernatural (or had supernatural properties). By supernatural, I mean that he/she/it can do things, or cause things to happen, that clearly do not obey any natural law applying to the rest of the universe; miracles, in the Judeo-Christian sense, would be examples. There is no doubt whatsoever that the vast majority of current religions and their adherents believe in a supernatural god.
This brings up some interesting questions:
1. Is it logically possible for an entity who would, in most other respects, fit the god definition, to be non-supernatural?
2. As a possible example of #1, consider an immensely powerful and intelligent alien, perhaps from another universe, who understands the deep physics of the universe to a level well beyond our current knowledge. Just as many aspects of our current technology seem to disobey "natural" laws to a Cro-Magnon, its actions would to us. Some have speculated about the possibility of such a being (presumably acting from another, larger universe) actually "creating" our universe, or at least running it as a super-simulation on a vast computer...
However, such a being is scarcely likely to fit all the other descriptors of the various gods imagined by various tribes of our past, nor would it be likely to exhibit the properties of the modern version of a personal, caring god; no more than a lab scientists cares about the individual bacteria in her petri dish...
Therefore no.
Now, they are mere babble from our childhood.
Nurse, where the fuck's my cardigan?
And my gin!
And my gin!
- rainbow
- Posts: 13755
- Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2012 8:10 am
- About me: Egal wie dicht du bist, Goethe war Dichter
Where ever you are, Goethe was a Poet. - Location: Africa
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
On the other hand understanding cause and effect is quite useful.JimC wrote:Humans have an irrational but understandable tendency to think that everything needs a creator (which can include a mother to be born from). Such primitive notions were understandable before a true appreciation of the nature of our universe.rainbow wrote:Obviously the Creator would have made those natural laws, and it follows that they can change them at will.JimC wrote:In another thread, I was castigated by Seth for asserting that, in debating the god issue, atheists quite reasonably use one of the descriptors of various gods as postulated by their believers, i.e. that their god was supernatural (or had supernatural properties). By supernatural, I mean that he/she/it can do things, or cause things to happen, that clearly do not obey any natural law applying to the rest of the universe; miracles, in the Judeo-Christian sense, would be examples. There is no doubt whatsoever that the vast majority of current religions and their adherents believe in a supernatural god.
This brings up some interesting questions:
1. Is it logically possible for an entity who would, in most other respects, fit the god definition, to be non-supernatural?
2. As a possible example of #1, consider an immensely powerful and intelligent alien, perhaps from another universe, who understands the deep physics of the universe to a level well beyond our current knowledge. Just as many aspects of our current technology seem to disobey "natural" laws to a Cro-Magnon, its actions would to us. Some have speculated about the possibility of such a being (presumably acting from another, larger universe) actually "creating" our universe, or at least running it as a super-simulation on a vast computer...
However, such a being is scarcely likely to fit all the other descriptors of the various gods imagined by various tribes of our past, nor would it be likely to exhibit the properties of the modern version of a personal, caring god; no more than a lab scientists cares about the individual bacteria in her petri dish...
Therefore no.
Now, they are mere babble from our childhood.

Did the Universe come to exist without a cause?
I call bullshit - Alfred E Einstein
BArF−4
BArF−4
- Svartalf
- Offensive Grail Keeper
- Posts: 41028
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
- Location: Paris France
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
"cause and effect" do not imply a sentient agency
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
- Svartalf
- Offensive Grail Keeper
- Posts: 41028
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
- Location: Paris France
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
IF there is a being that can, at will, set and change the laws of nature, that being is clearly superior and beyond such laws, and so clearly supernatural in the truest senserainbow wrote:Obviously the Creator would have made those natural laws, and it follows that they can change them at will.JimC wrote:In another thread, I was castigated by Seth for asserting that, in debating the god issue, atheists quite reasonably use one of the descriptors of various gods as postulated by their believers, i.e. that their god was supernatural (or had supernatural properties). By supernatural, I mean that he/she/it can do things, or cause things to happen, that clearly do not obey any natural law applying to the rest of the universe; miracles, in the Judeo-Christian sense, would be examples. There is no doubt whatsoever that the vast majority of current religions and their adherents believe in a supernatural god.
This brings up some interesting questions:
1. Is it logically possible for an entity who would, in most other respects, fit the god definition, to be non-supernatural?
2. As a possible example of #1, consider an immensely powerful and intelligent alien, perhaps from another universe, who understands the deep physics of the universe to a level well beyond our current knowledge. Just as many aspects of our current technology seem to disobey "natural" laws to a Cro-Magnon, its actions would to us. Some have speculated about the possibility of such a being (presumably acting from another, larger universe) actually "creating" our universe, or at least running it as a super-simulation on a vast computer...
However, such a being is scarcely likely to fit all the other descriptors of the various gods imagined by various tribes of our past, nor would it be likely to exhibit the properties of the modern version of a personal, caring god; no more than a lab scientists cares about the individual bacteria in her petri dish...
Therefore no.
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
- rainbow
- Posts: 13755
- Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2012 8:10 am
- About me: Egal wie dicht du bist, Goethe war Dichter
Where ever you are, Goethe was a Poet. - Location: Africa
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
Mebbe.Svartalf wrote:"cause and effect" do not imply a sentient agency
What other agency could it be, and then how would we define 'sentient'?
I call bullshit - Alfred E Einstein
BArF−4
BArF−4
- Svartalf
- Offensive Grail Keeper
- Posts: 41028
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
- Location: Paris France
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
I'd define sentient as self aware and able to act with a will, as opposed to the complete impersonal application of laws of nature, even, a nature that was different from that which we know as must have been the case at and before the big bang
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
- rainbow
- Posts: 13755
- Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2012 8:10 am
- About me: Egal wie dicht du bist, Goethe war Dichter
Where ever you are, Goethe was a Poet. - Location: Africa
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
Highly evolved perhaps.Svartalf wrote:IF there is a being that can, at will, set and change the laws of nature, that being is clearly superior and beyond such laws, and so clearly supernatural in the truest sense
There are things we can do today that would be considered to be 'supernatural' only a few years ago.
Like making a young Beaujolais reasonably pleasant drinking.
I call bullshit - Alfred E Einstein
BArF−4
BArF−4
- Svartalf
- Offensive Grail Keeper
- Posts: 41028
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
- Location: Paris France
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
and we're still justified in applying Clarke's third Law until and unless we can effectively differentiate such world shaking abilities from magic
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping
- Hermit
- Posts: 25806
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 12:44 am
- About me: Cantankerous grump
- Location: Ignore lithpt
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
If you presume that everything must have a cause you'll have to ask why the creator of the universe did not.rainbow wrote:Did the Universe come to exist without a cause?
If you presume that the creator of the universe did not need to be caused on what grounds do you justify that the universe did?
I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein’s brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops. - Stephen J. Gould
- pErvinalia
- On the good stuff
- Posts: 60702
- Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 11:08 pm
- About me: Spelling 'were' 'where'
- Location: dystopia
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
God works in mysterious ways. Something something...
Sent from my penis using wankertalk.
"The Western world is fucking awesome because of mostly white men" - DaveDodo007.
"Socialized medicine is just exactly as morally defensible as gassing and cooking Jews" - Seth. Yes, he really did say that..
"Seth you are a boon to this community" - Cunt.
"I am seriously thinking of going on a spree killing" - Svartalf.
"The Western world is fucking awesome because of mostly white men" - DaveDodo007.
"Socialized medicine is just exactly as morally defensible as gassing and cooking Jews" - Seth. Yes, he really did say that..
"Seth you are a boon to this community" - Cunt.
"I am seriously thinking of going on a spree killing" - Svartalf.
- Xamonas Chegwé
- Bouncer
- Posts: 50939
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 3:23 pm
- About me: I have prehensile eyebrows.
I speak 9 languages fluently, one of which other people can also speak.
When backed into a corner, I fit perfectly - having a right-angled arse. - Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: Are putative god(s) supernatural?
You forgot mumble mumble.rEvolutionist wrote:God works in mysterious ways. Something something...
A book is a version of the world. If you do not like it, ignore it; or offer your own version in return.
Salman Rushdie
You talk to God, you're religious. God talks to you, you're psychotic.
House MD
Who needs a meaning anyway, I'd settle anyday for a very fine view.
Sandy Denny
This is the wrong forum for bluffing
Paco
Yes, yes. But first I need to show you this venomous fish!
Calilasseia
I think we should do whatever Pawiz wants.
Twoflower
Bella squats momentarily then waddles on still peeing, like a horse
Millefleur
Salman Rushdie
You talk to God, you're religious. God talks to you, you're psychotic.
House MD
Who needs a meaning anyway, I'd settle anyday for a very fine view.
Sandy Denny
This is the wrong forum for bluffing

Paco
Yes, yes. But first I need to show you this venomous fish!
Calilasseia
I think we should do whatever Pawiz wants.
Twoflower
Bella squats momentarily then waddles on still peeing, like a horse
Millefleur
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests